Friday, November 20, 2026
Danielle Knight
- The US government, hoping to ease fears that liberalising the trade in wood and paper products would increase logging in endangered forests worldwide, released a new study here this week that only increased the worries of environmentalists.
The study by the Office of the US Trade Representative (USTR) and the Council on Environmental Quality concluded that a rapid reduction in import tariffs on forest products would have only a small impact on the environment.
They based this premise on the fact that tariffs on forest products already were close to zero in many nations.
The report concluded that while logging would increase in some countries – including Malaysia and Indonesia – in other countries, such as Korea and Japan, timber production would decrease.
“This analysis demonstrates that further opening trade in the forest products sector is consistent with our commitment to environmentally sustainable economic growth,” said Charlene Barshefsky, the US Trade Representative.
But environmental organisations said the study proved that tariff reduction would accelerate logging in endangered forest “hot spots,” such as Indonesia.
They criticized the study for not analyzing the potential impact of negotiations on non-tariff measures, including forest protection laws that could be considered barriers to trade under international trading bodies.
“The Administration’s analysis only gives half of the picture,” said Andrea Durbin, international programmes director at Friends of the Earth, “but even that half shows this proposal could harm critically important forests in key regions.”
The government prepared its study in response to widespread criticism from environmentalists of its aggressive effort to accelerate the reduction of tariffs which began at the Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) forum in 1997.
According to the report, by 2010 the USTR’s plan to reduce tariffs will increase the aggregate world trade in forest products by a maximum of two percent and the timber harvest by 0.5 percent.
World production and consumption of forest products would increase by less than one percent, the report said.
Reflecting the current level of tariffs among individual countries, Finland and Australia likely would have the largest increase in their timber harvests in 2010 – 11 and 9.2 percent respectively – if tariffs were reduced.
Sweden also was expected to show an increase of 7.6 percent in timber production, while Malaysia by 2.6 and Indonesia would increase by 4.4 percent.
Meanwhile, Korea and France are likely to have large decreases in timber harvest of 11.2 and 6.4 percent, respectively, said the report. Japan would decrease by 5.8 percent, Russia by 4.1 percent and Mexico by 2.1 percent.
“It appears likely that decreases in timber harvesting will be concentrated in primary (untouched or ancient) forests and that increases will be concentrated in secondary forests and plantations,” said the report.
Contrary to the report’s conclusion, environmentalists said the report bolstered their concern that logging will increase in countries with threatened biologically diverse tropical rain forests, like Malaysia, Indonesia and Papua New Guinea – where over half the timber production is exported.
“The Administration’s analysis confirms some of our concerns about forest impacts, even though it considers only one tiny slice of the overall trade liberalisation effort,” said David Downes, senior attorney at the Centre for International Environmental Law (CIEL).
Environmentalists, deeply concerned at the rapid deforestation taking place worldwide, denounced the study as incomplete and too narrow in scope.
According to World Resources Institute (WRI), nearly one-half of the world’s original forest cover has disappeared.
At least 200 million hectares of forest were lost between 1980 and 1995 – an area larger than Mexico or Indonesia, said the 1997 United Nations Food and Agriculture’s State of the World’s Forests report.
Given these statistics, Doug Norlen, a policy analyst for the California-based Pacific Environment and Resources Centre, questioned the focus on only the acceleration of tariff removal rather than on the overall impact of tariff elimination on forests.
“It is as if there is a car speeding at eighty miles per hour toward a brick wall, and at the last moment it speeds to 85 mph, and a government study looking at this only does an assessment of a 5 mph crash,” he said.
Environmentalists blasted the study for not analyzing the potential impacts of the elimination of non-tariff measures in forest products, since the Administration has stated several times that it intended to introduce the discussion of such measures in future trade negotiations.
A report by Washington-based WRI and the CIEL also released on Tuesday, said domestic laws designed to protect forests could be seen as non-tariff barriers to trade and therefore be eliminated or weakened.
Efforts to label forests products, to control the import of invasive species that harm trees, and to pass laws restricting local and state governments from purchasing endangered wood products could all be seen as non-tariff barriers to trade, said the 26-page report entitled ‘Tree Trade’,
Such concerns were echoed in a letter sent to fellow lawmakers by Democratic Senator Barbara Boxer of California, which asked them to sign a letter urging President Bill Clinton to consider the impact of eliminating non-tariff barriers to trade.
“We oppose the elimination of non-tariff measures that threaten our own ability – yours and ours – to write and enforce the laws most needed to protect our environment and our communities,” a draft of the letter said.
Tree Trade urged trade liberalisation to be put on hold until mechanisms are put into place to ensure parallel progress on forest protection.
“To prevent further forest loss, governments need to put the same effort into forest protection that they put into trade liberalisation,” said Nigel Sizer, director of forest policy at WRI and lead author of the report.
Specifically the report recommended a drastic reduction in public subsidies that encourage logging. Tree Trade called for strong support within the WTO for ‘eco-labeling’ efforts that would better inform consumers about the wood products they purchase.
The report also urged the Administration to support the control of trade in threatened timber species, such as mahogany, under the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES).
“Mahogany logging is a major catalyst for tropical deforestation,” said the report. “Loggers expand operations into frontier forests and road construction facilitates settlement by farmers and conversion of forests for ranching.”