Friday, November 20, 2026
Abid Aslam
- US lawmakers are unable to make sense of financing requests from the International Monetary Fund (IMF) because the institution appears to make them up as it goes along, according to a report to Congress.
A document, prepared by the US General Accounting Office (GAO), calls into question legislators’ approval last year of an IMF capital increase, including a 45-percent rise in membership dues. The Fund had said this was needed because it lacked money to lend.
The findings of the independent audit unit has sparked muttering among legislators who are preparing for another fight, this time over IMF proposals to raise income for a combination of debt relief and new loans for heavily indebted poor countries.
At issue is how much money really is at the IMF’s disposal.
The agency says that it has 77 billion dollars in liquid resources available to meet the demands of its 182 member states.
The General Accounting Office, however, insists that the figure is higher because the Fund sets aside 19 billion dollars in a ‘working balance’ reserve that has not been used in more than 20 years.
“Consequently, the IMF’s available and uncommitted resources may have been understated,” says the GAO’s report.
It also assails the IMF’s argument that it needs to maintain a ‘liquidity ratio’ – or a balance of available resources against its liquid liabilities – of at least 30 percent.
“While a low-end liquidity threshold appears reasonable, we found no analytical basis for the minimum ratio used by the Fund,” the document declares.
It adds that the Fund has “no formal methodology for deciding what the appropriate level should be; consequently, this threshold does not provide an analytical basis for determining whether the IMF’s resources are constrained.”
What’s more, GAO argues, “if the Fund’s liquidity were to fall to a level considered too low, the Fund could under specified conditions supplement its resources by using its 46 billion dollars in credit lines or by borrowing from sovereign governments, their central banks, or private entities.”
The IMF has never turned to private financial markets to raise cash, although it considered doing so in the 1980s.
Officials say such a move would undermine the nature of the Fund as a cooperative society of member states chipping in membership dues and, as needed, extra financing.
Fund officials also defend their ‘working balance’ reserve and liquidity ratio requirement as prudent measures necessary to maintain member states’ confidence.
Nevertheless, IMF critics in Congress find favour with the GAO’s latest revelations.
“The GAO supports my point (during last year’s funding debate) that the IMF’s destitution was being exaggerated by the IMF and (US) Treasury,” says Jim Saxton, vice chairman of the Congressional Joint Economic Committee.
The body has conducted five IMF hearings in the past two years and members have been frustrated by the complexity of the Fund’s book-keeping.
Their misgivings were compounded in February, 1998, when Karin Lissakers, the US representative on the IMF’s executive board, admitted to lawmakers that the Fund’s accounting system “is not fully transparent to me as a layman in this area.”
The GAO report also contains ammunition for those who say that the IMF has strayed from its original mandate of providing short- term balance-of-payments support, and instead has become a self- styled development bank by extended longer-term financing in exchange for structural adjustment.
“Industrial countries’ use of IMF resources decreased rapidly and, by 1988, all users of IMF resources were developing countries,” the document states. As a result, Fund programmes “have expanded from short-term currency purchases for balance-of- payments problems to nine types of arrangements and facilities that have tended to have longer repayment periods.”
The main reason for the shift is that wealthier nations have gained increased access to world financial markets, leaving only poorer ones in need of IMF support.
As a consequence, says GAO, “Fund facilities grew to address shortfalls in export earnings, to finance oil purchases and other imports…to fund the transition from centrally planned economies to market-based economies,” and to mobilise international financing in the wake of debacles including the 1994-95 Mexican peso crisis and the past few years’ troubles in Asia, Russia and Brazil.
In the poorest countries, “the leading edge of this drift in IMF policy is the Enhanced Structural Adjustment Facility (ESAF),” says Saxton.
The soft-loan window, which operates as a separate trust fund administered by the IMF, has come under fire for dispensing low- cost debt in exchange for economic austerity and restructuring in impoverished nations.
The agency last week won approval from its governors to rename its embattled ESAF the ‘Poverty Reduction and Growth Facility’ but “it will take more than the Orwellian step of renaming this programme to undo the damage of past IMF policy mistakes,” says Saxton.
The New Jersey Republican is co-sponsor, with Ohio Democrat Dennis Kucinich, of proposed legislation that would condition approval of IMF funding requests on a series of reforms – chiefly, a permanent end to the use of low-interest loans to enforce the Fund’s policy prescriptions.
That condition also would apply to the IMF’s intended off- market sale of 14 million ounces of gold from reserves held in the United States, Britain, France and India.
Proceeds from the transfer would be invested, and the resulting interest would be used to write off a portion of poor countries’ debts while offering them new loans to implement Fund-approved economic policies.