Environment, Headlines, North America

EMVIRONMENT: Canada Bans Export of Water from Great Lakes

Mark Bourrie

OTTAWA, Sep 2 1999 (IPS) - The US-Canada commission that monitors the health of the Great Lakes has issued a six month ban on the export or diversion of water from the world’s largest fresh-water body.

The International Joint Commission on Boundary Waters (IJC) imposed the ban to give governments time to study the environmental impact of removing large amounts of water from the five Great Lakes. The water is in demand in the parched east and midwest US regions, as well as in Asia.

The IJC study says only 1 per cent of the Great lakes is renewable, and any major sales would irreparably harm the lakes’ ecosystem.

“Once you go beyond that 1 per cent, you’re mining,” said IJC co- chairman Leonard Legault. “It’s not a renewable resource.”

The Great Lakes region provides drinking water for more than 20 million people on both sides of the border between Canada and the United States. It has a moderating influence on the climate of the eastern parts of both countries and also is major freshwater fish- producing region and transportation link to the interior of North America.

The US administration is under pressure to open diversionary canals in the midwest to allow water from the Great Lakes into the Mississippi Basin, where it would be used to maintain river levels as water further upstream in the Missouri River system is used for irrigation.

Most irrigation water west of the Mississippi River comes from the Oglala Aquifer, a once-huge pool of groundwater that has been depleted by US farmers.

As well, several Canadian companies want to export Great Lakes water by tanker to Asian countries. Water bottling companies, which remove billions of gallons of groundwater from the Great Lakes basin, are already threatening the health of the lakes, which are now at historic low levels, the IJC says.

Water exporters view the Great Lakes as un untapped resource. The huge lakes, formed by the melting of the Ice Age glaciers that covered most of Canada, can’t take the pressure of water diversions, the monitoring agency says.

But Canada’s federal government does not have the power to stop water exports. Environment and natural resources are responsibilities that are shared with the country’s provincial governments. The 10 provinces also own most of the land below the 60th parallel.

David Anderson, Canada’s environment minister, wants to meet his provincial colleagues this month to try to get an agreement to stop large-scale water exports. Talks between the former federal minister, Christine Stewart, have dragged on for a year without any sign of an agreement.

Anderson, who was appointed to the job earlier this summer, is believed to be a much stronger minister, one who can muster pressure from environmental lobbyists and his colleagues in the federal cabinet.

He is expected to use the IJC study as ammunition in his negotiation with the provinces, and has already slapped a six- month moratorium on water exports, a move recommnended by the IJC. The unilateral moratorium is not likely to become permanent, unless a federal-provincial agreement and an accord with the United States is reached soon.

More than 12 months ago, an Ontario company was given an Ontario government permit to export water from Lake Superior, the world’s largest fresh-water lake, to Asia. After a public outcry and pressure from the Ottawa government, the province of Ontario revoked the license.

A deal is unworkable without the support of the government of Quebec, a Canadian province with huge reserves of unpolluted water. The government of Quebec, which is committed to taking the province out of the Canadian federation, will probably resist any perceived inroads on its constitutional powers. Quebec’s environmental lobby is, however, fairly powerful an vocal.

The Great Lakes are not the only targets of water exporters.

Small lakes in Newfoundland and British Columbia have also been the focus of applications for water export licenses. In Newfoundland, Canada’s poorest prvince, a company has asked for a permit for a permit to export 50 billion litres from a lake near the Atlantic coast.

Environmentalists also fear that internation trade law may work against them. If water is defined as a commdity, treaties such as GATT and the North American Free Trade Agreement may prevent Canada’s government from interfering with exports.

“Once one province, or any province, starts exporting water, the GATT rules say Canada has to keep the tap running,” says Maude Barlow, head of the anti-globalization group Council of Canadians.

“NAFTA says that we have to treat American and Mexican investors exactly the same as we treat Canadian investors and already we have two NAFTA challenges,” she says.

“Just over a year ago, a company in Alaska was given permission to export water, and the province of Newfoundland is still seriously looking at a proposal to take water from Gisborne Lake. We know that there is an investor in Quebec who has started a company to export water from the Great Lakes.”

Barlow claims that There are very real preparations by corporations to enter the world market for water. “We’ve got water, but we’ve got no legislation; we have underestimated a potential threat.” she says.

“There are Canadian businesspeople who think Canada can become the OPEC of the water business, because we have such a huge supply. The signs are there that there’s a lot of financial interest, but we haven’t had a debate on the problem,”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags