Friday, November 20, 2026
Mark Bourrie
- Canadians in Ontario have been disturbed to discover their province is now second to the US state of Texas in the list of North American polluters.
A study based on North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) statistics shows that Ontario, Canada’s second-largest and most populous province, has moved from third to second place in the pollution rankings.
Texas’s top position has remained unchanged while the US states of Louisiana and Ohio are in third and fourth positions.
Environmentalists are blaming Ontario’s neo-conservative government, which virtually has dismantled its environment department since 1995, as the cause of pollution problems in the province.
The study by the Commission for Environmental Co-operation (CEC) says that half of Canada’s top 50 facilities for pollutant releases are in Ontario and two companies – Co-Steel Lasco in Whitby and Inco in Sudbury – are listed among the 25 biggest polluters.
Co-Steel Lasco is cited for dumping large amounts of zinc into a landfill near Lake Ontario. Inco operates a huge nickel and copper smelter in the northern Ontario city of Sudbury that is North America’s worst source of acid rain pollutants.
Ontario Premier Michael Harris denies his government is responsible for increased pollution levels. He says the study was based on out-of-date statistics but the authors of the CEC report say the data is the most recent available.
CEC was set up under NAFTA to monitor the environmental impact of the trade deal. NAFTA was the focus of criticism by environmentalists who worry that the agreement will push Canada’s provinces to scale back their environmental laws to make them similar to those in the United States.
CEC’s report, “Taking Stock 1996” shows the overall level of industrial pollution in Canada and the United States dropped 2.3 percent to 1.225 billion kilograms in 1996, compared with 1995, continuing a downward trend noted in the commission’s first two reports.
Ontario produced 68,763,262 kilograms of industrial pollution in 1996, down 7.4 percent from the previous year but still enough to bump Louisiana from second place and put Ontario right behind Texas – which produced more than 122 million kilograms of pollutants.
(Data from Mexico – the other NAFTA partner – was not included in the study. A report on the Mexican pollution situation will be completed by the CEC this fall.)
Ontario’s major polluters are in some of the most isolated regions of North America. Pulp and paper mills in the wilderness northern part of the provinces pollute the air with sulphur compounds and dump millions of gallons of waste into waterways every year.
The huge smokestack at the Inco smelter in Sudbury is blamed for the acid rain that has destroyed many lakes in areas hundreds of kilometres from the mining region.
Premier Harris says that the study is based on 1996 statistics, and doesn’t include a provincial program to test car emissions in a campaign to cut air pollution in Toronto and the other larger Ontario cities near the U.S. border.
“In the first year of our mandate, we have not substantially improved, that’s true. I believe, though, that we are improving. It’s a priority for us,” he said, noting both his government and the previous socialist government challenged the methodology of the research.
Harris’ government has cut the budget of the province’s Ministry of Environment by about 40 per cent since 1995.
It has reduced the ministry to a junior department with low- profile ministers and handed over much of the responsibility for resource industries to other departments.Inspectors were fired, and the system for pollution exemptions was revamped in favor of industry.
The present minister, Tony Clement, is considered a likely leader of the next generation of Canada’s neo-conservatives.
Clement says it is inappropriate for the report to simply compare raw tonnage from a highly industrialized province such as Ontario, home to 10 million people, with smaller, less developed jurisdictions such as Prince Edward Island or Arkansas.
He says there is no need to radically change Ontario’s pollution enforcement. “We have the laws in place. We’re working to enforce them better,” he says.
Others are not so sure.
“There’s no reason to expect to see an improvement in Ontario’s performance,” said Mark Winfield, a research director at the Canadian Institute for Environmental Law and Policy in Toronto, who has written several negative reports in the past year on Ontario’s environmental policies.
“When so many authoritative voices have presented so much evidence of serious environmental problems in the province, deteriorating conditions, and the impact of the situation on the health of Ontarians, one is left wondering what it takes to get the government to act.”
The study is the latest of several to document Ontario’s environmental plight.
Last April, Eva Ligeti, Ontario’s independent environmental commissioner, reported the province’s environmental protection programs were in shambles and public health was at risk. Fire fighters who battled a huge, three-day fire at a plastics recycling factory in Hamilton, Ont., also have criticized the province’s regulation of toxic chemical disposal.