Headlines, North America

RIGHTS; Canada Turns Screws on “Modern” War Criminals

Mark Bourrie

OTTAWA, Aug 12 1999 (IPS) - Canadian war crimes prosecutors are shifting their attention from Nazi-era fugitives to war criminals from former Yugoslavia, Africa and Asia who are hiding among the thousands of refugees who have settled here since World War II.

In Autumn, Nicholas Ribic, a 25-year-old Bosnian Serb, is due for trial in Ottawa for kidnapping United Nations peacekeepers in the Serb-dominated Bosnian city of Pale in May, 1995.

Among the peacekeepers Ribic is alleged to have kidnapped is Patrick Rechner, 35, a Canadian army captain serving in Pale. A photo of Rechner handcuffed to a post as a “human shield” against NATO air attacks on Bosnian Serb positions was published in newspapers throughout the world.

Ribic, a Canadian immigrant who had returned to Bosnia, was arrested in Edmonton, Canada last year while visiting relatives who had moved from Bosnia to Canada.

Under Canadian law, Ribic faces a maximum life sentence for four counts of hostage-taking. Canada’s war crimes law allows this country’s courts to prosecute hostage-takers for crimes committed abroad.

“Canada, along with other countries, solemnly undertakes to criminalize this conduct and to prosecute its nationals for an offence such as this not matter where it’s committed,” says Peter Lamont, a federal Justice Department lawyer prosecuting the case.

“It is the first time we’ve prosecuted for a hostage-taking committed abroad.”

The prosecution of Ribic is part of a Canadian crack down on war criminals that runs parallel to the country’s involvement in the International Court of Justice in the Hague. Canada has been a strong supporter of the court and has seconded two of its top judges to the world body.

Government lawyers and investigators are working on some 400 modern-day cases involving war crimes. Immigration officials already have prevented 307 modern war-crimes suspects from entering the country, and 25 others were expelled by refugee tribunals.

Along with developing its struggling domestic war crimes prosecutions, Canada has been an active supporter of the UN’s War Crimes Tribunal and the proposed International Criminal Court (ICC). Canadian Louise Arbour is finishing her term as a tribunal prosecutor before taking a seat on Canada’s Supreme Court in September.

The United States has refused to support the ICC because of administration fears of indictments of its military or political leaders for actions during peacekeeping or “peacemaking” actions.

After the expulsion of those suspected of modern-day war crimes last year, the government has opened files on another 200 individuals living in Canada.

Most arrived in the waves of refugees that Canada accepted in the wake of wars in Eritrea, Somalia, Rwanda, Yugoslavia, and southeast Asia. But officials have admitted they don’t know what to do about people like the wife and children of a Somali warlord who was admitted to Canada in 1990 as a refugee and has been living on welfare in an Ontario city.

Investigators say that she is not linked to criminal activity and did not lie about her husband when she asked to be admitted to Canada as a refugee.

Since 1995, the Canadian government has launched criminal or immigration actions against 16 people suspected of committing war crimes during World War II, with mixed results. Canada has found it difficult to track down witnesses or overcome legal challenges launched by defendants.

Canadian war crimes investigators are winding down their search for ex-Nazis to concentrate on modern war criminals.

Many of Canada’s recent prosecutions of World War II criminals have turned out to be embarrassments to the government. In mid- July, the federal justice department lost a court case to deport a Latvian-born man who was alleged to have been a Nazi war criminal.

The government used its standard allegation, that Eduards Podins, 81, had lied when he applied to come to Canada from Britain in 1959.

Podins was able to prove that he was a naturalised British citizen when he applied to come to Canada, and that British subjects were not put through the same kind of security screening as immigrants from countries occupied by Nazi forces.

The Canadian government had spent hundreds of thousands of dollars prosecuting Podins. They sent investigators to Latvia to interview survivors of the concentration camp where Podins was accused to have worked between 1941 and 1943.

The court even held hearings in Valmiera, Latvia, to take sworn testimony from witnesses who were too frail to come to Canada. But Federal Court judge William McKeown ruled that the camp was a jail for Russian prisoners, and that Podins was not involved in the type of brutality associated with death camps.

The ruling was another defeat for war crimes prosecutors, who have lost three of the six World War II cases brought to court in the past six years. Another six cases are still before the court.

A scandal erupted in 1996 when the Chief Justice of the Federal Court of Canada met secretly with prosecutors, then ordered his subordinates to work more quickly on war crimes cases. One judge resigned in protest, the chief justice resigned soon after, as did another senior judge.

Last year, two people accused of World War II crimes left Canada voluntarily under threat of deportation and the government began legal action to deport a third person alleged to have been an accessory to Nazi atrocities.

Some Canadian politicians have accused prosecutors of being in in over their heads, wasting time and money prosecuting cases that they are ill-prepared to litigate.

John Reynolds, justice critic for the opposition Reform Party, said the number of lawyers working on war crimes cases and the 25 million dollars spent last year should have produced better results.

“Where does this money go?” he asked. “It seems to be a lot of money for the result. I know lawyers who have bigger case loads.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags