Headlines, Human Rights, North America

RIGHTS-US: Gay Couples Migrate to Canada

Kerstin Marx

NEW YORK, Jul 13 1999 (IPS) - US citizen Jay McMillan simply wants to live in peace with his Japanese partner Yoshihiko Ito but both men now plan to leave their jobs in the United States and move to Canada – to become what gay rights activists term “refugees for love.”

“In a way it’s very scary leaving this country and the security of a job” says McMillan, a salesman from Detroit. But to be able to continue living with Ito, a self-employed translator, “makes it worth it”, he adds.

The US-Japanese couple are the latest of a number of binational gay and lesbian couples to look for a joint future in Canada – one of only 11 countries in the world that grant immigration rights to same-sex partners.

While marriage to a US-citizen entitles heterosexual foreigners to remain in the US, gay couples are not allowed the same rights, complains the Lesbian and Gay Immigration Rights Task Force (LGIRTF), a New York-based advocacy group.

Currently, there is no state in the US that allows same-sex marriages and, even if there one did exist, a 1996 Federal law denies homosexual couples any immigration benefits.

The US government, says LGIRTF’s National Coordinator Lavi Soloway, practices “horrible discrimination” against same-sex couples when granting immigrant visas to foreigners.

Immigrant visas or “green cards” allow the holder to reside permanently in the US and to work and travel freely. After five years, green card-holders are eligible to seek US-citizenship.

“Since they cannot legally marry, and since the law provides no avenue for a US citizen or permanent resident to petition for his/her same-sex partner, binational gay and lesbian couples are torn apart, their lives routinely disrupted and their relationships destroyed,” says Soloway.

Homosexual immigrants and their partners are faced with a “unique challenge to address their invisiblity in the law” which affects at least 10,000 same-sex couples in the United States, he says.

Critics of any change to current legislation fear that too much room could be left for abuse.

“How would immigration officials distinguish between life partners and sex partners?” asks Congress Representative Bob Barr, a conservative Republican from Georgia, in an article in the ‘New York Times’. “How would they even know who is homosexual and who isn’t?”

Homosexuality generally served as a reason for being refused entry to the United States through a clause in the Immigration and Nationality Act which barred “sexual deviants”. The law was replaced in 1990.

In neighbouring Canada, new immigration regulations opened the door to gay and lesbian immigrants in 1994.

Like the United States, Canada officially does not recognise homosexual partnerships. But Canadian immigration officers can cite “humanitarian and compassionate grounds” to allow a same- sex partner with foreign nationality stay to stay in that country.

According to LGIRTF, in the past five years more than 700 people were granted immigration status in Canada to remain with their same-sex partners.

McMillan and Ito regard these regulations as their last option to realize their “ultimate goal of being together”. From Japan, Ito recently filed his papers to the Canadian immigration offices, and McMillan plans to do the same. If granted immigration status, either one could bring in the other.

The two men met during a 1997 vacation in California and, after waiting returning to Japan for eight months Ito received a US work permit in 1998, allowing him to accept employment at a New Jersey software company. The 29-year old had been lucky: The visa, which is granted to foreigners with special skills and lasts for a maximum of six years, is usually hard to get because of its limited numbers.

But only a few months later, Ito was among eight employees that were laid off by the company due to financial problems. With the job, he lost his visa and was forced to return to Japan.

“It was very hard when he left,” says McMillan, stressing that there were very few alternatives for his partner to quickly obtain legal status in the United States.

For McMillan and Ito, the only way to stay together is to live emigrate to Canada. Other more desperate homosexuals often seek illegal ways to remain together in the US – such as faking a heterosexual marriage.

Such a marriage by a homosexual to someone of the opposite sex is usually done for money and is a felony which, if discovered, includes penalties of imprisonment, fines and a lifetime ban on re- entering the country.

Asylum based open sexual orientation, on the other hand, is only guaranteed to those who prove that they would face anti-gay persecution at home.

After all, McMillan says that he is excited to start a new life with Ito in Toronto but that leaving his country is also somewhat bitter to him. “What is the difference (between a hetero and homosexual couple) if you are in love and have a partnership?” he asks.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags