Friday, November 20, 2026
Mark Bourrie
- Environmentalists in the United States are looking at trade sanctions under the North America Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) as a way of forcing the Canadian government to pass a law to protect endangered wildlife.
Earlier this month, the Ottawa government killed the idea of adding endocrine-disrupting chemicals to its pollution laws and gave no sign it would heed pleas to introduce legislation to protect rare animals and their habitat. Canada’s neighbour, the United States, has had laws to protect endangered species for 25 years.
Bill Snape, legal director of Defenders of Wildlife, a Washington lobby group, says his association will submit an official petition under NAFTA’s rules that would force the US administration to investigate whether the lack of an endangered species law gives Canada an unfair manufacturing and resource extraction advantage.
NAFTA links Canada and the United States with Mexico in a free trade agreement.
Proponents of sanctions against Canada say that its lack of an endangered species law can give illegal advantages to Canadian logging firms, fishing companies, farmers and land developers.
“Look, Canada, you’ve got to get going,” Snape said. “Now is truly the time, or the president of the United States will have the authority to impose trade sanctions upon you.”
Canada’s environment minister, Christine Stewart, says the United States may use the issue as “a convenient way to put up a barrier against Canadian trade,” which has been a constant threat since NAFTA was adopted in 1994.
But Canadian environmentalists say their government must come up with a law that protects the habitat of endangered animals, and no legislation proposal presented so far fits the bill.
“For federal endangered species legislation to be effective, it must apply to the full extent of federal jurisdiction,” said Marc Johnson, endangered species co-ordinator for the Canadian Wildlife Federation (CWF), an umbrella group of conservationists.
“It must list species at risk and their critical habitat needs based on scientific criteria, automatically prohibit killing, harming, harassing, or taking a listed species or destroying its ‘home’.”
American environmentalists say their government pours money and effort into trying to preserve the grizzly bear from extinction, but as soon as the animals cross the border into Canada they can be shot or the trees of their habitat cut down.
Piping plovers, also endangered and protected in the United States, migrate north to Canada to breed around Saskatchewan’s Lake Diefenbaker. But the provincial hydro utility closes a dam each spring and floods half their nests.
In two of the last seven years, there have been no young birds seen at the plovers’ largest remaining breeding site.
Another area of dispute is the habitat of Pacific salmon. The US government has declared nine species of wild salmon in the Pacific Northwest to be threatened with extinction. The coastal states affected by this extension of the U.S. Endangered Species Act protection are asking for funding of 100 million dollars to restore salmon spawning areas and begin reclamation measures.
“If we are investing millions to protect the salmon, we want to be sure our neighbours are doing the same thing,” says Heather Wiener, of the Washington office of EarthJustice, which has joined Defenders of Wildlife in its threat to launch trade action.
Negotiations between the Canadian and U.S. governments broke down last year over American refusals to agree to lower salmon quotas for their Pacific fishing fleets. When Canadian fishers blockaded Alaskan ferries in protest, relations between the two countries’ governments soured.
Anglers in the US state of Minnesota have asked the U.S. government to invoke NAFTA regulations to force Canada to relax conservation limits on the number of fish American anglers can take home from the Canadian side of the Great Lakes.
In 1996, Canadian federal, provincial, and territorial governments signed the National Accord for the Protection of Species at Risk, committing them to establishing “complementary legislation and programs that provide for the effective protection of species at risk throughout Canada”.
However, legislation to implement the accord has never passed through Canada’s federal Parliament. For constitutional reasons, the country’s 13 provinces and territories cannot pass their own laws until the federal law is passed.
“The provincial, territorial, and federal governments have failed to live up to their commitments to protect and recover Canada’s endangered, threatened, and vulnerable species,” said CWF’s Johnson.
“Canada’s endangered species cannot wait any longer. They need effective legal protection across the country. Only the federal government can provide this national safety net, at least until such time as all provinces and territories fully meet their commitments.”
Johnson said that 22 species of wildlife already had disappeared in Canada and a further 285 animal and plant species were in danger, including the Atlantic cod, grizzly bear, five lined skink, and the swift fox.
” The main threat is the destruction of habitat. Even the proposed law which failed to pass in 1997 would only have earned a D grade,” Johnson said.
Environmental scientists believe habitat protection is critical and have calculated that 80 per cent of Canada’s 285 endangered animal and plant species are at risk because of threats to the habitat.
In Ontario, the logging of 92 per cent of the “Carolingian” forest, that once blanketed much of the south-western part of the province, has endangered many bird and animal species.
Stewart’s original promise of habitat protection has wavered in the face of the jurisdictional complexities, Johnson said.
“Her long-awaited bill bodes to be almost as weak as its precursor; she’ll be protecting endangered species only on federal land (5 per cent of the total, since most government-owned land in Canada belongs to the provinces) while asking landowners and farmers to voluntarily fill in the gaps.
“It won’t do!”