Economy & Trade, Headlines, North America

ECONOMY-US: All Eyes on Summers as Rubin Steps Down

Abid Aslam

WASHINGTON, May 12 1999 (IPS) - Robert Rubin quit his post as US Treasury Secretary Wednesday, leaving his deputy Lawrence Summers to follow four years of plaudits from Wall Street but misgivings abroad.

Unlike his former boss, who hailed from Wall Street, Summers is a product of the worlds of academic economics and policy-making. His appointment must be confirmed by the Senate although Republican leaders indicated they would not block it.

While Rubin amassed a fortune at the Wall Street investment firm of Goldman Sachs – which he joined in 1966, becoming co- chairman in 1990 – the younger Summers was making waves as an abrasive academic at Harvard and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT).

Summers was appointed as Deputy Treasury Secretary in 1995, at the same time as Rubin took the top job following a two-year stint as the first chairman of the National Economic Council, set up by President Bill Clinton and modelled on the National Security Council.

Like Rubin, the 44-year-old Summers has been a champion of fiscal discipline at home and an aggressive campaigner for free trade and unfettered capital flows abroad.

Much of the economic liberalisation agenda had been set during the Republican administrations of Ronald Reagan and George Bush but Rubin and Summers, working closely with Clinton, brought new passion to the mission and expanded it to push for open capital markets.

So much so that the ‘New York Times’ described the pair as “the dynamic duo of free capital” and their offices, on the third floor of the U.S. Treasury here, as “the command centre for free markets.”

Rubin’s first major action in 1995 was to advise Clinton to intervene following the Mexican peso’s meltdown, and to assemble a 20-billion-dollar U.S. bailout. His recommendation, according to NEC chairman Gene Sperling, in turn had been based on economic analysis furnished by Summers.

The move was extremely unpopular – only about 11 percent of US voters surveyed at the time backed it – so Rubin declined in mid- 1997 to contribute to an international bailout in Thailand.

Rubin again was roundly criticised and he quickly moved to reassert ‘US leadership’ over subsequent bailouts in East Asia, which nevertheless failed to prevent the crisis from spreading to Russia, and Brazil.

As Rubin and Summers garnered attention for their efforts to contain the wildfire, South Korean and Thai officials were left to rue some of their dealings with the Treasury officials.

It had been Washington’s idea to lure Seoul within shooting range of speculators – without regulatory protection – with the promise of membership in the rich nations’ Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development.

Thai central bank officials in 1997 wrote to their US and German counterparts to warn of an impending crisis as foreign investors poured billions of dollars into Thailand and began leveraging its currency.

The Germans responded by demanding to know which German banks were culprits but Washington blandly suggested that the matter was best left to the markets.

‘Continuity’ was the watchword Wednesday as administration officials sought to assure Wall Street that Rubin’s departure – commonly described as “a shock but not a great surprise” – would not disrupt the course of U.S. economic policy.

“We must press forward with the strategy that has brought us this far,” Clinton said at a White House ceremony late Wednesday.

The 60-year-old Rubin’s departure had been a staple of the Washington rumour mill for years. Wall Street took an early tumble, dropping more than 200 points on the resignation news but recovered, closing at 11,000.37 – off only 25.78 points for the day.

For his part, Rubin described his years in office as among the most memorable of his personal and professional life. They had also been demanding years and “it’s time for me to go home to New York and do whatever it is I’m going to do.”

Clinton said he would miss Rubin’s “cool head and steady hand” before turning to Summers, whom he described as “brilliant and able.”

Rubin concurred, adding that Summers “has a sense of humour about himself.”

On occasion, that sense of humour has caused outrage. In 1991, as chief economist at the World Bank, Summers argued in an internal memo that waste and high-pollution industries ought to be transferred from the rich to the poor countries. He later said the memo was meant to be ironic.

“Just between you and me, shouldn’t the World Bank be encouraging more migration of the dirty industries to the LDCs?” he wrote, referring to ‘less developed countries’.

“I think the economic logic behind dumping a load of toxic waste in the lowest wage country is impeccable and we should face up to it…I’ve always thought that underpopulated countries in Africa are vastly under polluted.”

Summers has steered clear of such assertions since and reportedly has taken lessons in self-effacement from the mild- mannered Rubin in a bid to improve what the ‘Washington Post’ described as “his notoriously deficient people skills.”

Softened style notwithstanding, Summers could have his work cut out.

A recent survey of international investors by Medley Global Advisors found that 37 percent believed financial upheaval would be at least “somewhat more likely” if Summers replaced Rubin. The majority had no opinion and the investment advisory firm would not say how many people they had asked.

Also changing jobs as a result of Rubin’s departure was Stuart Eizenstat, the underscecretary for economic affairs at the State Department.

Eizenstat, a veteran of the Jimmy Carter administration, was to take over Summers’ old job at the Treasury subject to Senate confirmation.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags