Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines

ENVIRONMENT-RIGHTS: NGOs Call for End to ‘Corporate Welfare’

Danielle Knight

WASHINGTON, Mar 28 1999 (IPS) - An international coalition of environmental organisations is launching a campaign to stop government export finance agencies, based in industrialised countries, from backing environmentally and socially destructive projects in developing countries.

These export credit agencies (ECAs) and investment insurance organisations run by Australia, European countries, Japan, and the United States provide more than 100 billion dollars a year in guarantees, loans and insurance to help their companies compete for business abroad.

The agencies are now the world’s largest public international financial institutions subsidizing more than 10 percent of world trade, according to a report by more than 30 non-governmental organisations (NGOs) from 23 countries.

Billions of dollars from these agencies is going toward destructive large dams, mining, oil, and fossil fuel projects, says the coalition.

“These agencies are providing global corporate welfare and financing environmental destruction worldwide with public money,” said Jon Sohn, a policy analyst with Friends of the Earth-US.

Since the ECAs do not have common environmental standards, they often end up financing projects that other lending institutions – which do set standards – will not fund, NGOs say.

“These agencies often are financing projects that are rejected by the World Bank and rejected by other bilateral and multilateral public aid agencies, not just on social and environmental grounds, but on economic grounds,” says Bruce Rich, senior attorney with the Environmental Defence Fund.

“It’s really been a privatisation of profits and public assumption of risk, not only financial risk but also environmental and social risk.”

The US Export Import Bank (Ex-Im) and Overseas Private Investment Corporation (OPIC) do have some environmental and human rights standards.

But because of fierce competition to finance projects, agencies worldwide end up lowering their standards in what environmental groups call a “race to the bottom,” say groups.

Ex-Im and the World Bank also set standards, for example, they steered clear of providing loans or guarantees for China’s Three Gorges Dam – which will displace more than one million people – German, Swiss and Canadian ECAs stepped into the gap.

Some Republican members of Congress, however, feel that US corporations are now at a disadvantage and want to abolish Ex-Im’s and OPIC’s guidelines.

To prevent this happening, environmental groups are urging the “Group of Eight” industrialised countries to adopt guidelines that at least meet World Bank environmental and human rights requirements.

Ex-Im is already beginning to back down and lower its standards, says Sohn.

He pointed to Ex-Im’s support, along with Austrian, Britain, German, Italian, Japanese, Portuguese, Swedish and Swiss ECAs, for the Ilisu Dam, a 1-billion dollar hydroelectric project planned for Turkey.

The scheme would dam the Tigris River near the Iraqi border, flooding an area of 313 square kilometres and forcing the resettlement of at least 15,000 Kurds, who are strongly opposed to the project. An ancient archaeological site – revered by the Kurds – would be flooded.

“Ilisu illustrates a case of what happens in the absence of strong minimum common social and environmental standards,” says Sohn.

Bilateral ECAs are also responsible for an increasing amount of debt, leading to the financial dependency that limits the progress of many less developed countries, according to “A Race to the Bottom; Creating Risk, Generating Debt and Guaranteeing Environmental Destruction.”

In 1996 they accounted for 24 percent of the total indebtedness of all developing countries, and for 56 percent of their official debt, or that owed to multilateral or bi-lateral agencies.

About 24 percent of Indonesia’s total external debt – approximately 28 billion dollars – is held by export credit agencies, according to Titi Soentoro, coordinator of Bioforum, a coalition of more than 70 Indonesian NGOs.

Much of this foreign investment has gone to mega-projects which are notoriously plagued with corruption and linked closely to the family of the former dictator Suharto, she says.

“Investment projects such as factories, plantations, and mines not only destroyed natural resources, but also gave rise to other significant environmental and social impacts including the destruction of the livelihoods of the local peoples who owned, managed, and utilized these resources,” says Soentoro.

German, Finnish, Swedish, Japanese and Canadian agencies, for example, have supported more than one billion dollars in financial assistance to a pulp and paper mill and plantation project, slated to by one of Indonesia’s largest.

Owned by the Barito Pacific Group, Indonesia’s largest logging conglomerate, and Suharto’s eldest daughter, the company’s plantation operations have been involved in deforestation and forced seizures of lands owned by surrounding communities, says Soentoro.

“We call upon the German government to become a leader in international efforts to set standards to halt the taxpayer- subsidized havoc caused by these agencies,” says Heffa Schuecking with Urgewald, a coalition of more than 100 church, developmentand environmental groups.

Urgewald has launched a campaign to reform Hermes, the German ECA, which is also providing funding for several other controversial projects including Three Gorges Dam, which will flood several cities, ancient archaeological sites, and relocate about one million people.

Hermes is also providing support for the Maheshwar dam in India which involved a loan to purchase turbines and generators from the German company Siemens. This hydroelectric project is expected to submerge 61 villages and displace more than 20,000 people.

“In conjunction with other dam projects on the Narmada river, Maheshwar poses serious risks, including water pollution, health hazards, loss of fish, increased flooding and earthquakes,” says Schuecking, who hopes the change in Germany’s government to a Social Democrat and Green Party coalition will be more receptive to the idea of reforms for Hermes.

Friends of the Earth – Japan is also urging its country’s ECAs to stop funding destructive projects, especially since the announcement that the Japanese Export Import Bank (JEXIM) will merge with its counterpart Japanese Overseas Economic Cooperation Fund.

With a combined budget of 27 billion dollars, the new institution will be the world’s largest ECA.

In the Brazilian Amazon, JEXIM is helping to finance a 64 million dollar loan to construct the Urucu Gas Processing Plant and two 500 kilometre pipelines in the remote western part of the rainforest, according to Adilson Vieira with the Coordinating Group of the Indigenous Organisations of the Brazilian Amazon (COIAB).

“The plant will cause widespread destruction to the rainforests since the pipeline and roads will provide access to loggers, miners, ranchers, and farmers into pristine areas, in some cases inhabited by isolated indigenous groups,” says Vieira.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Environment, Headlines, Human Rights, North America

ENVIRONMENT-RIGHTS: NGOs Call for End to ‘Corporate Welfare’

Danielle Knight

WASHINGTON, Mar 28 1999 (IPS) - An international coalition of environmental organisations is launching a campaign to stop government export finance agencies, based in industrialised countries, from backing environmentally and socially destructive projects in developing countries.
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags