Asia-Pacific, Headlines, North America

POLITICS: Sino-American Relations Run Into Choppy Waters

Jim Lobe

WASHINGTON, Feb 18 1999 (IPS) - Seven months after U.S. President Bill Clinton completed a triumphant tour of China, relations between Washington and Beijing have headed into distinctly choppy waters.

The two major powers increasingly are at odds over traditional irritants, such as human rights, trade, and Taiwan. New issues, including U.S. plans to deploy anti-missile defences and accusations that Beijing has systematically stolen sensitive U.S. military technology, are aggravating tensions.

The slowdown in China’s economy, coupled with a tightening up of currency controls and other measures that make it tougher for U.S. companies to operate in China, also has dampened the enthusiasm of powerful business interests in defending Beijing.

“It’s no surprise that the relationship is now saddled with a number of different issues which are rooted in very different perspectives,” says Robert Kapp, president of the US-China Business Council.

While the administration admits disappointment with China, it is sticking by its five-year policy of “comprehensive engagement.”

It has singled out China’s cooperation in dealing with the Asian financial crisis, bringing North Korea into peace talks, and abiding by pledges to curb missile and other controversial exports to Pakistan and Iran for special praise.

In addition, the administration has intensified negotiations with Beijing in recent weeks over the conditions under which it would support China’s accession to the World Trade Organisation (WTO).

The administration is hoping that it will be able to announce major progress towards that goal during the scheduled visit here in early April of Prime Minister Zhu Rongji. But Congressional forces which have long been sceptical of Clinton’s courtship of China are stepping up pressure on the administration to go slow.

Next week, Democrats in the House of Representatives will introduce a bill which, if passed, would require a majority vote in both houses of Congress before the administration can support China’s admission to the WTO.

In a letter circulating on Capitol Hill, Minority Leader Richard Gephardt argues that China’s trade policy “assaults the competitiveness of U.S. corporations and the standard of living of the American worker.”

He also notes that Beijing’s trade surplus with Washington hit 50 billion dollars in 1997 and would likely reach nearly 70 billion dollars in 1999.

Foes of Clinton policy are gearing up on the human-rights front, especially in the wake of the crackdown against democracy activists which followed the president’s visit last July. The repression culminated in December when several well-known dissidents received prison sentences of between 11 and 13 years for “subversion” for trying to form a non-Communist political party.

The sentences have been compared with the crackdown against Democracy Wall activists in Beijing in 1979. Even Secretary of State Madeleine Albright told her hosts at a special embassy dinner here to celebrate the 20th anniversary of US-Chinese normalisation last month that Washington was “profoundly distressed by the unjustified prison sentences.”

Albright will soon travel to Beijing to press personally for tangible signs of human-rights progress before Zhu’s visit. Just this week, China released a prominent journalist who has spent more than five years in prison in what some here believe is a first effort to address Washington’s concerns.

U.S. human rights groups, however, refer to Beijing’s practice of freeing dissidents at sensitive moments in Sino-US relations as “hostage-politik.” Unimpress, they are pushing for Clinton to sponsor a resolution condemning China at the annual meeting of the U.N. Human Rights Commission, which begins next month in Geneva.

From 1990 through 1997, Washington sponsored such a resolution but last year, as the moment for Clinton’s own visit to China approached, the administration decided against it.

Now pressure is mounting on Clinton to sponsor a new resolution. A bipartisan group of 16 senators, including Republican Majority Leader Trent Lott, has introduced bill which formally urges Clinton to take such an action.

“Given Congressional pressure, the administration will at least go through the motions of doing something in Geneva,” says Mike Jendrzejczyk, a China specialist at Human Rights Watch.

He notes that Washington’s sponsorship would add pressure on the European Union (EU), currently chaired by the new German government, to follow suit.

As in the past, a US-sponsored condemnation of China’s human- rights record is certain to annoy Beijing, but it has more serious complaints against the United States this year.

These include plans to accelerate development of an anti-missile system to defend Japan, South Korea, and independence-minded Taiwan, which Beijing regards as a renegade province which must be re-united with the mainland.

Such a system received a strong impetus after North Korea fired a ballistic missile over Japan last August. Tokyo, which felt threatened by the surprise launch, reversed its previous reservations about the programme, which is now going full steam ahead.

China worries that an anti-missile system only will cement Japan’s alliance with Washington, but will also upset the regional balance of power.

Beijing, which, according to a secret Pentagon report, is systematically building up its missile forces arrayed against Taiwan, is also concerned that such a system will neutralise its offensive capacity and thus encourage pro-independence forces in Taiwan as the island’s presidential elections in 2000 approach.

Most China specialists here agree that Taiwan is the single- most explosive issue in Sino-US ties. Indeed, the two countries came closer to actual conflict than at any time since the Vietnam War when Clinton sent an aircraft-carrier task force into the Taiwan Straits in 1996 while Beijing was conducting missile tests there.

The Chinese position gets little sympathy here. A still- classified Congressional report, which will soon be made public, reportedly details a successful Chinese espionage campaign against the United States to acquire some of its most sensitive military and missile technology.

The report’s publication is expected to re-ignite debate over whether Washington should adopt a “containment” policy toward Beijing, a course to which Clinton has been firmly opposed.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags