Friday, November 20, 2026
Dipankar De Sarkar
- A row over experiments by multinational companies in producing genetically altered crops has led to calls for government action amid growing public unease over possible health risks posed by such foods.
A public opinion poll last week showed that 57 percent of Britons were concerned at the effect of genetically-modified (GM) food after a campaign against the experiments by ‘green’ organisations and some scientists.
The row also has caused a split in the ruling Labour Party as critics have questioned the integrity of some ministers with connections to the agri-food business.
In what appeared to be the beginnings of a political fallout of the health controversy, opposition Conservative Party members of parliament have called for the resignation of Britain’s billionaire Science Minister Lord Sainsbury – the scion of the Sainsbury supermarket dynasty.
Sainsbury, one of the Labour Party’s most enthusiastic wealthy backers, became minister soon after Labour’s election success in May 1997. His critics point out that Lord Sainsbury is a passionate supporter of denetically-modified food, and therefore constituted a conflict of interest.
“The whole world knows that he has a big shareholding in the supermarket chain and we also know he was a big investor in two companies (involved in the new food process)” Conservative MP John Redwood said.
In addition to his stake in the Sainsbury supermarket chain – Britain’s largest – Lord Sainsbury founded the Batsby Foundation which has invested 18 million pounds into the study of genetically modified organisms.
There also is controversy over the composition of a government body on genetically-modified food after allegations that people on the Advisory Committee on Novel Foods and Processes had links with biotechnology companies.
Green campaigners’ suspicions after it was disclosed that a move to nominate Julie Shepherd, a member of the Consumers’ Association, to the committee was rejected.
The committee’s chairwoman Janet Bainbridge recently challenged a food scientist after he leaked confidential results of an experiment on GM food.
Dr Arpad Pusztai, a researcher at the government-funded Rowett Institute in Aberdeen, Scotland, was forced to retire after he released results suggesting rats fed GM potatoes had suffered damage to their immune systems. Pusztai has since received the support of a 20-strong group of scientists.
However, Bainbridge said “it is deplorable that these results are apparently being made available to the press while the Dean of the Medical Faculty at Aberdeen Univbersity has forbidden their disclosure” to her committee.
Other forms of pressure was increasing on the British government.
British premier Tony Blair rejected a demand by the Conservative Party to place a three-year moratorium on the new food, saying “there is no genetically-modified food that can be sold in this country without going through a very long regulatory process.”
Echoing Blair, his minister in charge of enforcing cabinet coordination, Jack Cunningham, said, “Some carefully controlled, limited-scale trials (of GM crops) are taking place.”
“I believe that the demand for these to be stopped on environmental grounds are irresponsible. How can be judge the impact which a crop might have on our countryside and wildlife if we shun such trials?” Cunningham, a former agriculture minister, added.
Environmentalists said that gentically-modified crops are bad for wild plant populations and biological diversity, arguing that the release – or even restricted field testing – of GM crops can lead to crossing with related wild species growing nearby.
They feared that some GM crops, resistant to herbicides for instance, could displace related wild species and endanger biodiversity. Last year, a British court rejected an appeal by an organic farmer for a ban on field trials with GM crops on a field next to his.
Links between companies involved with GM crops and the British government were highlighted in further revelations that the government has earmarked 15 million pounds to encourage these companies to expand their operations in Britain.
The issue has split the ruling Labour Party with Cunningham opposed by Environment Minister Michael Meacher, who has urged the government to establish an independent ethics commission on GM food.
A number of Labour MPs joined opposition colleagues in charging that the government was putting the interests of big business before that of ordinary Britons.
But the government continued to insist doggedly that GM food posed no health risks and that only three kinds of GM foods were available in Britain – soy beans, tomato puree and some kinds of grain – a claim vigorously challenged by nongovernmental organisations.
Cunningham declared last week, “There is no question over the safety of GM products on sale for human consumption.”
Cunningham’s protestations invoked memories of the dying days of the Conservative government, when its agriculture minister John Gummer, seeking to calm public unease over the quality of British beef in the “mad cow” scare, went on television to feed a hamburger to his little daughter.