Environment, Headlines, North America

ENVIRONMENT: Plans to Slaughter Four Million Snow Geese

Mark Bourrie

OTTAWA, Feb 8 1999 (IPS) - The graceful snow goose is as identifiable with Canada as is the maple leaf displayed on the nation’s flag. Yet Candian officials want to slaughter as many as four million snow geese in order to protect the ecosystem of the North American sub-arctic.

Until the 1980s, scientists rejoiced at the way the huge birds had recovered their numbers after being at the brink of extinction. But now there are more than seven million snow geese in North America and scientists believe they need to be culled or they will fall victim to starvation and disease.

The hunt is opposed by wildlife groups who believe a slaughter of the birds could cause them to return to a state of near extinction.

Snow geese whose numbers dropped dramtically 30 years ago have adapted to new areas when their wintering region along the Gulf of Mexico was destroyed by industrial and tourism development. They moved inland, to the rice and wheat-growing regions of the southern Mississippi Valley, where they have flourished.

The supply of available food in their northern range, however, is more sparse and Canadian and U.S. scientists say the geese are stripping large areas of the Arctic tundra of its slow-growing vegetation.

In the sub-arctic plains west of Hudson Bay, snow geese flocks have denuded the landscape by tearing plants out by the roots. Goose droppings acidify the soil and prevent new plants from germinating.

Now, thousands of young birds die each summer because they cannnot get enough to eat, according to scientific studies which authorities say justify plans to cull the number of snow geese.

But even if the a massive hunt is allowed, there may be few people who want to shoot so many birds.

Lorne Scott, the environment minister of Saskatchewan province, says: “People just don’t seem to hunt that many snow geese. The flavour is good, but the meat is black, and most hunters seem to prefer other species,” he said.

Scott himself believes that disease and predators will naturally stabilize the population of the birds – eventually. Some aboriginal groups, however, believe mass killings of snow geese by hunters in the United States and southern Canada could destroy a traditional food source for Indians in the north of the country.

In a letter to the Canadian government, Dene National Chief Bill Erasmus said no one has consulted the Dene about the goose issue. He says reports that snow geese are destroying nesting grounds in the Hudson Bay region are “a sensational view that has not been properly documented or researched”.

Erasmus is backed by environmentalists and some biologists. Vernon Thomas, a University of Guelph (Ont.) biologist who visited the snow goose nesting region last July, said he couldn’t find signs of irreparable damage to the habitat.

But David Duncan, chair of the Canada Snow Goose Committee, a government-appointed group that has recommended the hunt, says he estimates “one third (of the habitat) is completely destroyed. Where there used to be marsh, there is now mud flats”.

Meanwhile, another major Canadian hunting dispute began last month pitting the Ontario provincial government against the powerful U.S. hunting lobby.

U.S. hunters and gun ownership supporters launched a boycott campaign in January when the government of Ontario, which has a wilderness area equal in size to all of France, announced that the spring bear hunt is now illegal because too many baby bears were being orphaned by hunters.

Hunters like the spring hunt because the bears, which are emerging from hibernation, are easy to shoot. They are hunted for their meat and for thick winter pelts that are prized as rugs.

U.S. Rock star Ted Nugent, an outspoken hunting and gun ownership crusader who lves in the woods of Michigan near the Canadian border, is supporting the boycott in protest against Ontario’s “tom foolery.” Last year, he was found guilty of impaired driving while on a hunting trip in a wilderness area north of Lake Superior.

Public and private wildlife refuges in Ontario say they can’t cope with the number of orphaned baby bears brought to them each year. Animal activists have pressed Canadian governments for years to ban the spring bear hunt.

They failed to get the social democratic government that ran Ontario from 1990 to 1995 to outlaw the hunt, and were surprised when the present neo-conservative regime announced the banning of the practice.

“The banning of the Spring bear season just doesn’t help the bears. It only helps the touchy-feely fantasy of a bunch of people who would ban you or I from ever wearing leather or having a steak,” says Nugent, who hunts with a bow and arrow.

He says he has killed about a dozen bears in Ontario since the late 1960s and believes Ontario would be over-populated with bears if hunting was stopped.

Joy Williams, spokeswoman for the Ontario government, said the spring hunt was banned because orphaned cubs “have absolutely no chance of survival. We cannot accept the fact there are any orphaned bear cubs,” she said.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags