Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Human Rights

/CORRECTED REPEAT/RIGHTS: Refugees in Poor Countries Need More Attention, Money, Says UNHCR

Jim Lobe

WASHINGTON, Nov 14 2000 (IPS) - The international community, especially donor countries, need to give the tens of millions of refugees and internally displaced persons (IDPs) uprooted from their homes in poor countries considerably more attention and more resources, according to the annual report released here Monday by the outgoing United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), Sadako Ogata.

In one of her final appearances before her retirement, Ogata, who has served as UNHCR since 1990, warned that refugee problems may only worsen in coming years as desperate people, particularly in poor regions, such as sub-Saharan African, which donor nations do not consider “strategic” to their interests, try to make their way to nations which can give them security or greater economic opportunity.

“This will be a very big issue,” she said about the growing trend by wealthy nations to make it more difficult for asylum-seekers or economic migrants to enter their borders. “So far, the response has been much too much (about) stopping people.”

“If the disparity between the world’s wealthiest and poorest countries continues to grow. and if countries outside the industrialised world are not sufficiently encouraged and supported in providing protection and assistance to refugees in their regions, the numbers of people seeking new lives in the world’s wealthiest states will remain high,” according to the new report.

Ogata, who will be succeeded by former Dutch prime minister Ruud Lubbers when she steps down, said that the result of such a strategy was a booming business by international traffickers, a problem which “will get worse. Globalisation means movement of goods and money”, she said. “Why not people?”

Ogata’s presence here marked the global release of ‘The State of the World’s Refugees: Fifty Years of Humanitarian Action,’ the fourth in a series of UNCHR reports. Falling shortly before the 50th anniversary of UNHCR’s creation in January, the 348-page report reviews the work of the Geneva-based agency over the past half century.

It notes that UNHCR began its work with a staff of 33, a budget of only 300,000 dollars, and a mandate to help Europeans still displaced from World War II and its aftermath to find permanent homes.

As of the end of 1999, according to the report, the agency’s staff has grown to some 5,000 in 120 countries, with a corresponding rise in the budget to about 1 billion dollars. In the meantime, it has taken up new problems, including the plight of IDPs or internally displaced people, more than 6 million of whom are under UNHCR’s protection in several regions, including the Russian Caucasus, the Balkans, and Colombia.

But there are some 20 to 25 million IDPs worldwide, according to the report, which noted that they often suffer worse conditions than those of their compatriots who actually make it across an international border.

“In spite of the increased awareness of the problem of internal displacement, the international response has remained selective, uneven, and in many cases inadequate,” according to the report which called for much more attention to be devoted to the problem and international co-ordination to address it.

More than half of the world’s IDPs are found in Africa, some 4 million in Sudan alone, and another 1.5 to 2 million in Angola. Yet, like African refugee crises, these IDPs receive far less attention and resources than those in more ‘strategic’ areas, particularly Europe.

“There is a disparity in the response to refugee crises,” Ogata said. While raising money for dealing with the 1999 Kosovo refugee crisis was no problem at all, “I had a very hard time getting international attention on refugee issues in Africa”, she noted.

Without discounting the role played by racism in the disparity, the fact that Kosovo took place in Europe where both the European Union and the United States had a “real strategic interest” also played a part in the different treatment of the two regions.

Indeed, UNHCR received 90 percent of funds it requested in 1999 for the former Yugoslavia and only about 60 percent for its African operations. About 120 dollars per refugee was spent in the former Yugoslavia in 1999; more than three times the 35 dollars per refugee spent in West Africa.

“There was a lot of resentment in Africa (and) criticism that there was a double standard,” said Ogata, and while she rejected criticisms over the disparity in per capita spending, she stressed that “attention to Africa should be aroused”.

She said there was another resources gap that also made UNHCR’s work much more difficult: the gap between the outbreak of the crisis when resources become more available as a result of the attention it gets in the global media and the immediate aftermath when it disappears from view.

“When the (television) screen no longer looks at the emergency, then I don’t get the money. And that’s when I really need it,” she said. “This is a time when there is a huge gap” between the emergency itself and the ability of international agencies to put in place a plan for rebuilding. “This is something I have to appeal to the media for, too,” she said, calling for more consistent coverage.

Despite those frustrations, she said, UNHCR could take pride in its role in a number of regions over the past decade of her stewardship, including the return of more than a million Kurds to their homes after the Gulf War, the repatriation of 1.7 million refugees to Mozambique, and almost as many to their homes in Cambodia, the rest of Indonesia, and Central America.

She added that trends were moving in a “good direction” in Rwanda, Bosnia, and the rest of the former Yugoslavia, although she expressed doubt that NATO’s air campaign against Yugoslavia during the 1999 Kosovo war had really solved the refugee problem in that province. As Albanian Kosovars moved back after the campaign, she noted, “then started the outflow of some 250,000 Serbs and Romas”.

“It takes time to solve refugee problems,” she stressed.

While these problems were at least moving in the right direction, she said, the refugee situations in and around Afghanistan, Angola, and the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC) were getting far less attention than they needed.

Some 2.5 million Afghans are a “very, very heavy burden on (Pakistan and Iran), and there is very strong pressure on them to be returned”, she said. But the Taliban government is a “very difficult regime, (and) I have great difficulty getting funds for the refugees or to (help) them return home”.

Similarly, Angola has “enormous IDP issues, (but) funding (is) very, very limited”. As for the DRC, the situation is “very, very confused”, with more than 1 million IDPs, some 300,000 refugees in neighbouring countries, and 200,000 refugees from other countries in the DRC.

Another major issue of growing concern is the safety of UNHCR and other relief workers. Of the six UN workers killed this year, four were from UNHCR. Three were killed in riots in the Indonesian province of West Timor, and another in Guinea.

In both cases, the victims were working in refugee camps which are used by armed forces – another knotty problem for UNHCR whose mandate above all is to protect refugees. “You can’t protect refugees by remote control,” she said. “You have to be with them.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags