Friday, November 20, 2026
Jim Lobe
- In a major victory for big US business and President Bill Clinton, the Senate Wednesday voted to set aside a key amendment to a bill that would establish permanent normal trade relations (PNTR) with China.
If passed, the amendment, which would have required the president to impose sanctions against Beijing if Chinese firms transferred nuclear or other technology that could be used to make weapons of mass destruction to third countries, would have effectively killed the bill’s chances of final approval this year.
The 65-32 vote to table the amendment opens the way to easy passage of the PNTR, which will formalise a far-reaching trade accord reached between Washington and Beijing last November, either late this week or early next.
That agreement, the price for US support for China’s entry into the World Trade Organisation (WTO) requires Beijing to open its economy wide to US investment and imports. Under it, China must slash tariffs on imports ranging from agricultural products to automobiles and offer US companies much greater freedom in distributing goods and services and investing in Chinese enterprises.
China concluded a similar accord with the European Union (EU) last May. US corporations, which have led the battle for the PNTR, were worried that if Congress did not pass the bill this year, China would deny them the advantages gained under the November agreement, leaving its vast market and labour force open to competitors from the EU and other WTO members.
Coincidentally, the Senate voted just minutes before another major China-related event Wednesday: the release from nine months of federal detention of Taiwan-born scientist Wen Ho Lee. Lee had been accused of stealing US nuclear secrets from the Los Alamos National Laboratories and passing them on to Beijing.
Lee was released after pleading guilty to only one count – of downloading classified material to an unsecured computer – of 59 counts the government filed against him. As part of the plea agreement, Lee, who has denied spying for China or any other country, agreed to help investigators track a number of missing tapes which had contained the classified information. But he also received an extraordinary apology from the trial judge “for the unfair manner in which you were held in custody.”
Lee’s supporters, among them Asian-American associations and the heads of the most prominent US scientific academies, have argued that the scientist’s treatment at the hands of the justice system resulted in part from anti-Chinese hysteria in Congress following intelligence reports that Beijing had obtained some of Washington’s most closely-held secrets about nuclear and missile technology.
They also charged that he had been singled out for investigation and prosecution because of his Chinese nationality. His case has drawn major attention in the Chinese media.
While the Lee case was not directly related to Wednesday’s vote, the coincidence of the two events highlighted two of the most sensitive issues in the often-delicate relationship between Washington and Beijing: national security and trade.
Indeed, many Republicans and some Democrats have opposed the trade deal because they believe that Beijing is determined eventually to challenge Washington’s global position and is building its military and intelligence capacities in order to do so as quickly as possible. To strengthen China economically through trade, according to this view, could well accelerate that process.
They have also charged that China has been supplying missiles, and nuclear and other dangerous technology to various “rogue states” and others which threaten US interests and allies in strategic regions, such as the Gulf, the Middle East, and South Asia.
Chinese deliveries of missile and nuclear technology to Pakistan and Iran have drawn the most attention from US intelligence agencies in recent years, although intelligence analysts stress that China also appears to have sharply reduced the frequency and sophistication of questionable transfers.
While there is broad support in both houses of Congress for some kind of sanctions against China for weapons proliferation, the key question Wednesday was whether there was enough to derail the trade bill.
The PNTR bill, Clinton’s top trade priority for his last year in office, passed the House of Representatives in May after a bruising battle which pitted Clinton and big business against the trade-union movement and its allies in the human rights and environmental community.
The unions, worried that PNTR would mean the loss of tens of thousands of manufacturing jobs to China, put heavy pressure on Democratic lawmakers to break with Clinton and vote to defeat the bill, while business coalitions, including such heavyweights as the Business Roundtable and the US Chamber of Commerce, spent a record amount of money on a lobbying and ad campaign in its favour.
In the end, the administration and business prevailed 237-197, but Clinton was forced to rely on a strong majority of Republican votes to win, as most Democrats voted against him.
PNTR was always expected to pass easily in the Senate, which generally is more favourable to free trade. But the more-relaxed rules in the upper chamber permit senators to amend the bill, and, if any passed, the bill would then have to return to the House for a new vote there, instead of going straight to Clinton’s desk for his signature.
Given the short time remaining in the current year’s Congressional session and the fast-approaching general election in November, the chances of the House approving an amended bill were regarded as nil. Vice President Al Gore, who supported PNTR and is running to succeed Clinton in the November elections, has been particularly alarmed at the prospect of another House vote which could drive a wedge between him and his Democratic base at a key moment in the campaign.
Senators opposed to PNTR have introduced a series of amendments to the bill this week, each of which was handily defeated. The only one that was given a strong chance of passage was the sanctions amendment against Chinese nuclear and weapons proliferation, sponsored by Republican Fred Thompson of Tennessee and Democrat Robert Torricelli of New Jersey.
“There are an awful lot of Republicans and some Democrats who would like to vote for (the) Thompson (bill),” noted Sen. Joseph Biden last week, “but they don’t want to be responsible for killing (PNTR).”
With business and administration lobbyists prowling the corridors, the pressure to shelve the amendment mounted steadily over the past week. “I feel like one of those poor rubes chasing that greasy China PNTR pig, trying to slow it down,” said one anti- PNTR senator. “But that pig is well greased … Porky is flying through the Senate.”