Asia-Pacific, Headlines

RELIGION-MALAYSIA: Gov’t Jittery Over Fringe Islamic Groups

Anil Netto

PENANG, Malaysia, Jul 12 2000 (IPS) - Fringe Islamic groups have come under scrutiny following a major arms heist by a mystical martial arts group, an attack that sparked a nationwide security alert last week.

The surrender by 27 members of the Al-Ma’unah (Brotherhood of Inner Power) on Jul 6, after a five-day standoff with security forces, has again thrown the spotlight on “deviationist” Islamic groups in mainly Muslim Malaysia.

Posing as military officers, the group raided two armouries some 20 km from the town of Gerak, near the Malaysian-Thai border on Jul 2. They carted away 100 assault rifles, rocket launchers and thousands of rounds of ammunition.

Posing as military men, the militants murdered two hostages, both security personnel, before surrendering to the authorities when crack anti-terrorist commandoes advanced on them. The group was led by a former army private and several ex-military men.

Fringe Islamic groups have sprouted and at times flourished, more so since Malaysia gained independence from the British in 1957.

Abdul Hamid Zainal Abidin, director-general of the Islamic Development Department, said Al-Ma’unah’s activities fall under the department’s definition of “deviationist”.

Hamid said at least 17 other deviationist groups operate in Malaysia, and warned their teachings are a threat to Muslims.

The department is also probing another 36 groups for suspected involvement in practices that conflict with Islamic teachings, he added. Hamid said the authorities had identified 124 deviationist groups in the country since 1995.

Although any violent streak among these groups is universally condemned, not everyone accepts the official definition of deviationism at face value.

“What do you mean by deviantionist?” asks historian Dr Ariffin Omar, who has researched social movements and “deviationist” groups. He says authorities classify those who do not agree with their interpretation of certain aspects of Islam as deviationists.

Some 55 to 60 percent of Malaysia’s 22 million people are Muslims, nearly all of whom subscribe to the Sunni strand of Islam (the other strand being Shia).

Of the four schools of jurisprudence in the Sunni strand — Shafi’i, Maliki, Hanbali, and Hanafi — it is the Shafi’i school that has been granted official recognition in Malaysia, while the other three are tolerated, says Ariffin.

Named after its leader (imam) Muhammad ibn Idris al-Shafi’i, the Shafi’i school today is dominant in Egypt, Syria, South-east Asia, and East Africa, as well as a few other regions.

The government also has the legal right to prosecute those who spread Shia teachings, Ariffin says, adding that other groups such as the Ahmadiah and the Ismailia fall outside the officially accepted fold in Malaysia.

As for why groups like Al-Ma’unah emerge, Ariffin replies: “They are disgruntled groups.”

The group’s website, for instance, says “jihad is our path” and “Islam will be victorious” and asks people if they could bear to watch Muslims being “betrayed and oppressed”. The group’s exact aims are not as clear yet, but its rituals include being burned by fire.

Many Al-Ma’unah members are well-educated, a fact that adds to the government’s worry. Among those detained under the Internal Security Act for suspected involvement in the group after the Jul 2 heist were accountants, engineers and systems analysts.

Officials are also worried that “deviationist” groups might become extreme or violent ones that the government may no longer be able to control, and which may turn into political causes.

Ariffin says such groups emerge because of what they see as too much control over religion — which leads to conflict and a lack of tolerance and freedom within the religion. There is an official unwillingness to compromise and accommodate different views, he argues, which may provoke feelings of alienation.

Normally, religious cults arise as a reaction to colonial rule as in Indonesia and Burma, Ariffin says. But in Malaysia, such groups became more prominent after independence, he observes.

In the 1970s, these groups started hitting the headlines.

The Penang-based Crypto cult movement, formed in 1977, aimed to set up a theocratic order. The group claimed that the government was not giving Islam its proper due, and the government clamped down on it in 1992.

Another group whose interpretation of Islam was deemed unacceptable was the Koperasi Angkatan Revolusi Islam Malaysia (KARIM or Malaysian Islamic Revolutionary Front) formed in 1974 in Kuala Lumpur. It was later banned, its leaders detained.

In 1980, members of the Islamic party PAS were accused of being involved in a shadowy militant group called the Pertubuhan Angkatan Sabillullah, recalled political scientist Farish A. Noor, in a recent commentary.

The incident flared in 1980 after thousands of Malay farmers in northern Kedah state demonstrated against a government proposal to introduce a forced savings scheme using coupons.

Security forces arrested 90 farmers and their leaders, and Farish says the government claimed that PAS leaders and activists had “masterminded” the demonstrations.

Indeed, the authorities have occasionally implied that PAS, Malaysia’s largest opposition party, has influenced these groups, a charge PAS denies flatly. But “I don’t this it is fair to link it (Al-Ma’unah) to PAS,” says Ariffin. “There’s no basis.”

There is, however, a political dimension. “Such groups are probably unhappy with the present political leadership and their unwillingness to vacate,” he argues.

Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad said Monday that the Al-Ma’unah wanted to topple the government by force, and police officials said they have a “political” agenda.

“They are involved in politics in their own way. In fact, they asked for the prime minister and his kuli (servants), meaning Cabinet members, to resign. They said this during their first communication over radio with our security forces,” he said.

Mahathir said he was worried that though the group’s actions were now being condemned, it would not be too long before efforts begin to legitimise its actions.

“Certain groups will start defending their actions by saying that they were frustrated with the Government for being un- Islamic, like allowing liquor to be sold in the country. This is what sympathisers and the Sauk rebels will say for their common aim is to strive for an Islamic state,” Mahathir said.

Officials normally get more worried and begin cracking down when these groups draw a significant following.

This partly explains its clampdown on the popular Al-Arqam movement in the 1990s, and its banning in 1994. Until last year, authorities saying they were keeping watch over attempts to revive it.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags