Saturday, November 21, 2026
Jim Lobe
- A three-year-old campaign by civil- rights and Arab-American groups to ban the use of secret evidence in immigration courts is gathering steam.
In the latest case, a federal judge last week ruled that the due- process rights of a Palestinian professor, Mazen Al-Najjar, who has taught at Southern Florida University for some 19 years, had been violated when an immigration judge denied him bail on the basis of classified evidence which neither he nor his lawyer was permitted to see.
Mazen, a father of three who has been held in jail for more than three years, is one of about two dozen pending deportation cases – almost all of them involving Muslim immigrants – in which secret evidence has been used against them.
Over the last 18 months, however, several US courts have found that the use of secret of evidence violates constitutional guarantees of due process.
Now, Congress is becoming more involved. A new bill that would ban the use of classified evidence in immigration hearings has gained 90 co-sponsors from both major parties. While it is unlikely to be voted on this year, backers are planning to attach parts of it as an amendment to a key appropriations bill in the coming weeks.
“Secret evidence is a national embarrassment, and we need to take action,” says House Minority Whip David Bonior, who, along with California Republican Rep. Tom Campbell, is the major author of the Secret Evidence Repeal Act. At a recent hearing on the bill, Bonior noted that Amnesty International has found several targets of “secret-evidence” cases to be political prisoners.
The practice actually dates back to the McCarthy period of the early 1950s when the fear that the Soviet Union was infiltrating agents into the United States resulted in a series of laws permitting the authorities to deport suspect aliens if they threatened “national security.” Judges were authorised to review classified evidence in making their decision.
The practice was reduced in the 1960s and 1970s, but gained new life in the 1990s, especially after the 1993 New York World Trade Center bombings for which a number of Muslim immigrants were convicted. In 1996, new immigration legislation explicitly authorised the practice in deportation cases in which the subjects were suspected of involvement in terrorism
Under current law, classified evidence deemed “relevant” by federal agencies can be used to deny immigrants entry into the United States or avoid deportation. The evidence can also be used, as they were in Al-Najjar’s case, to jail immigrants until their deportation cases are decided. Many targets in such cases have voluntarily left the country rather than face protracted detention.
Little attention was paid to the plight of these immigrants until last October when a federal judge ruled that the government’s use of secret evidence against a Palestinian immigrant violated his constitutional rights.
Hany Kiereldeen, who overstayed his student visa, was arrested and thrown in jail in March 1998 on the basis of secret evidence which alleged that he had links to some of the men convicted in the World Trade Centre bombing. It turned out that the secret evidence in question had been manufactured by his ex-wife after a bitter divorce and made part of his file by the Federal Bureau of Investigation.
The following month, Attorney-General Janet Reno declined to block the release of an Egyptian immigrant, Nasser Ahmed, after an immigration judge assailed secret evidence against him as “double or triple hearsay.” Ahmed, who was a legal assistant to Sheik Omar Abdel Rahman, one of the convicted defendants in the Trade Center case, had been jailed – often in solitary confinement – since 1996.
In yet another case, an Iraqi doctor, who was evacuated by the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) to the United States in 1996 after the collapse of a CIA action against President Saddam Hussein, has been jailed for nearly four years because of secret evidence against him. Last month, a California federal judge ruled that his lawyer, former CIA director James Woolsey, had presented “more than sufficient evidence” to rebut government’s argument that he should be deported as a threat to national security.
Woolsey, who had the required security clearance to review the government’s evidence, denounced it as “hearsay” and “nonsense.” He served on a special Congressional commission on terrorism which Monday called for ending the use of secret evidence in immigration cases and instead creating special “anti-terrorism” courts – already authorised by law but never established – in which secret evidence would have to be shared with defence counsel.
David Cole, a professor at Georgetown University Law Centre who has represented 13 aliens against whom the INS has used secret evidence, says the evidence itself has been consistently weak. “In none of these (13) cases, did the INS’s secret evidence even allege, much less prove, that the aliens had engaged in or supported any criminal, much less terrorist, activity,” he testified last month. “In most cases, the government’s allegations, once revealed, consisted of no more than guilt by association.”
The fact that virtually all of the targets were Arab Muslims has naturally aroused the Arab-American community which has taken a leading role in challenging the practice and which, according to political analysts, could play an important role in key states – notably Illinois, Michigan, and New Jersey – in the November elections.
“Virtually all of the ‘secret evidence’ cases have been directed at Muslims and people of Arab descent,” according to Rep. Campbell, who is the Republican candidate for senator in California this year. “This has created a perception in those communities that the Government is targeting them with the most repressive tools available to it. This law is clearly discriminatory and unconstitutional, and we need to take a stand against it.”
The INS has itself defended the law. In testimony last month INS General Counsel Bo Cooper cited a hypothetical example of an asylum applicant about whom the agency obtains classified information identifying him as an “activist in a terrorist organisation” from an official of that organisation.
“To protect the national security, the immigration judge must be allowed to see the classified information before she decides whether that alien should be given asylum,” said Cooper. “But neither the INS nor the immigration judge can show the information to an alien without risking the national security. The INS believes that the judge should be allowed to see the evidence.”
Some Jewish organisations have also opposed the Campbell-Bonior bill and its blanket ban on secret evidence. The Anti-Defamation League, a Jewish civil-rights group, has instead called for tighter oversight of secret evidence and changes in the law that would guarantee that targets of such cases receive at least summaries of the charges against them that would enable them to prepare a serious defence.
Jim Lobe
- A three-year-old campaign by civil- rights and Arab-American groups to ban the use of secret evidence in immigration courts is gathering steam.
(more…)