Economy & Trade, Headlines, Labour, Latin America & the Caribbean

LABOUR-TRINIDAD AND TOBAGO: No End in Sight For Nurses’ Strike

Peter Richards

PORT OF SPAIN, Jun 8 2000 (IPS) - For 17 years, Nurse John has complained about her low wages every time she looked at her monthly pay slip. At the end of last month her complaints were even more vocal – when she received her pay slip, it contained nothing.

Nurse John was not alone. Over 100 nurses in the country’s public system either received no wages, or had their salaries for the month drastically cut back.

“They are trying to frustrate us,” said one angry nurse, while another added “I never wanted to take up a foreign job, but they are forcing me to do so.”

The Trinidad and Tobago government says it has started implementing the policy of “no work, no pay” as it relates to the ongoing impasse involving the nurses.

Acting Health Minister Vimla Tota Maharaj told reporters “there is a policy of no work, no pay and we will adhere to that policy at this time.”

Prime Minister Basdeo Panday, himself a former trade union leader, says there is nothing “morally wrong” with the policy, recalling that during his days as a trade unionists, particularly in the sugar industry, he and his membership were also victims of a “no work, no pay” policy by employers.

Some leading trade unionists have called for “good sense to prevail.”

The Trinidad Sugar and General Workers Trade Union President Boysie More Jones says he cannot “recall any such practice” by previous administrations.

“In my 24 years as a trade unionist, I’ve never seen a case as interesting as this current nurses’ situation. We have to remember their issue with the employer is not about money,” says Robert Giuseppi of the National Union of Government and Federated Workers.

Lyle Townsend of the Communications Workers Union says Panday, as a former trade unionist should stop “talking stupidness” since nurses have been registering for work daily, and not leaving “the place of work for the day.”

For the past 83 days, nurses have been taking protest action to force the government and the Regional Health Authorities (RHA) – established as part of efforts to decentralise the health sector – to improve their working conditions and increase their remuneration.

The nurses at the major health institutions throughout the country, as well as in the sister isle of Tobago, have been going to the hospitals, signing the daily work register, but refusing to carry out any function.

Patients complain of lack of attention, late meals and medicine, and television pictures show some patients lying on the bare ground. At least one hospital has joined medical wards in order to deal with the shortage of nursing personnel.

Under the Industrial Relations Act, nurses are considered essential workers and therefore cannot participate in any strike action.

Their union, the Public Service Association (PSA) says the workers are “reporting for duties, but do not have the necessary tools to carry out their function and are therefore not on any strike.”

The government’s move has resulted in legal action being taken by at least three nurses whose salaries have been affected.

They have filed a constitutional motion claiming that the government, their employer, found that they were guilty of breaching Regulation 135 of the Civil Service Regulations without taking disciplinary proceedings against them for their alleged absences from work.

The motion also says there was no adjudication of any such charge of Misconduct, or order by the Public Service Commission that such deductions be made and the nurses and their colleagues were not given any opportunity to be heard.

The nurses are asking for aggravated and exemplary damages. No date has been set for hearing the motion.

Lecturer at the Hugh Wooding Law School here and former magistrate Dana Seethal says under the Public Services Act, the government must inform workers in writing of any plans to deduct from their salaries. She says some nurses have said they never received such letters.

Section 51 of the Public Services Act states “on no account shall money be deducted from an officer’s salary without prior notice in writing to him of not less than one month.”

The decision to cut the nurses’ salaries followed an attempt by the Regional Health Authorities to end the impasse. After eight hours of negotiations on May 24, the RHAs and the PSA reached agreement on a number of outstanding matters including recruitment of nurses, upgrading of work conditions and patient care at the hospitals and acquiring new equipment.

The parties had agreed that the nurses would resume work pending the outcome of the negotiations on salary increases.

The PSA had been seeking a 50 percent incentive allowance, reducing that figure to 45 percent. The government had countered with a 25 percent hike on condition that the nurses join the RHAs, a move that the union and its membership have dismissed.

During the negotiations Dr. Tim Gopeesingh, chairman of the North West Regional Health authority, said that while his organisation could not give a commitment that the salary deductions would be withdrawn, he would make representation to the cabinet.

But Acting Health Minister Tota Maharaj shot down the accord, saying the authorities were sticking to its “no work no pay policy” and would not seek to “jeopardise any negotiations at this stage.”

Former PSA President Clyde Weatherhead questioned the government’s motive for trying to get nurses to join the RHAs.

“How can a government, which is hell-bent on making public officers leave their employment for lower quality employment in the RHAs claim to be acting in the interest of the people?” he asked.

Now the PSA has announced plans to shut down the country on Jun. 15, as part of the action to “get the employer to listen to us.”

“Not a ship shall sail in or out, not a plane shall land, not a taxi must move, all workers must stay home and pray,” says the PSA in radio advertisements seeking support from the other trade unions and workers on the island.

Last weekend, the PSA together with other trade unions including the powerful, Oilfield Workers Trade Union (OWTU) staged a “Black Friday” march through the streets of the capital.

At the rally that followed, trade union leaders warned the government to settle the matter quickly and not to jeopardise the health of citizens. The unions are likely to announce further action plans at the upcoming Labour Day activities on Jun. 19.

Meanwhile, Dean Knolly Clarke of the Anglican Church has written the Prime Minister offering to “mediate” in the impasse. He has not yet received a reply.

“This is a situation that can deteriorate even further, that’s why I want to mediate,” he said.

The government instead of responding to the request for mediation has sent the matter to the industrial court. The court will hear the case on Jun. 21.

“The matter is now at the industrial court. This is how we deal with matters like this. We go by the law,” Panday said after telling reporters that the nurses were free to seek employment overseas.

“This is a free country,” he said.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags