Thursday, November 19, 2026
Pushpa Adhikari
- The shabby “school” was all of two small rooms, with some 20 children learning what Chinese youngsters do in primary scho ol — writing and reading, singing and playing with their classmates.
“I have a lot of friends and I enjoy playing there and the teachers a re good,” says eight-year-old Liu, a pupil.
But things are not that simple for his father Lu Zhengyong, a 48-year-old worker who hails from Henan province in central China and who knows the value of education although he cannot write his own name.
He constantly worries about what will become of his son after studying at this “school” without a name in Chaoyang district, in the outskirts of Beijing.
That is because the “school” is not a government-recognised school, and is in fact one of a growing number of institutions catering to the children of the ever-growing ranks of labour migrants in Beijing who do n ot have residential permits.
“The municipal education commission has not recognised the school,” explains Lu. “So after completing four years in this school what to do next?”
There are many, many more parents like Lu, judging from the number of workers who come to Beijing in search of jobs. According to government statistics, the transient population from Chinas other provinces to Beijing reached 3 million in 1998 — nearly 20 percent of the capital’s population.
For schools like that in Chaoyang, no land and money has been allocate d and most of the officials from Ministry of Education and municipal government hesitate to accept that they exist.
Besides the cold winter and many exercises in different subjects, thes e transient children live with the fact there can be little permanence in this kind of schooling, badly needed but not quite legal.
The teachers there know they are conducting an illegal business every day, according to some principles and regulations devised by the Beijing Education Committee. However, they wonder why the local government has no t closed these “illegal” schools, and made other arrangements for the children.
In the Chaoyang school, one teacher, Sun Yi, says they teach the pupil s all the basic things others in their age group learn. One “head teacher’ ‘ comes every week and asks if their problems, and is responsible for monetary matters.
The teachers also say the rooms are in fact provided by the local district committee.
These “illegal” schools are cheaper than the government- recognised schools. Lu pays 500 yuan (60.24 U.S. dollars) per semester, which is mor e than five times cheaper than regular schools.
Clearly, the schools fill a crying need among a significant group of Beijing’s population but present a dilemma for local officials.
On the one hand, Zhang Yi, an official from the municipal government, says “more extraneous labour will flood Beijing if it provides good educational conditions for children of the floating workers”.
On the other hand, denying children proper education and classrooms is not in line with Chinas law on nine-year compulsory education, which a sks both parents and governments to provide the conditions for every school-a ge child to receive at least nine years of basic schooling.
Economics also helps sustain the existence of “illegal” schools, giv en the difference in costs with sending children to regular public schools.
Every term in a public primary school costs at least 3,000 yuan (363 dollars). In public middle schools, the fee rises to 10,000 yuan (1,200 dollars) every term.
But according to the ‘Labour Daily’ newspaper, the average total incom e of the floating labourers is less than 5,000 yuan (602 dollars) annually. Af ter their daily expenses and some taxes, they have little left for other things, much less high education fees.
The “illegal” schools exist also because the Chinese have traditionally placed a high value on education and spend on it even with the limited income they may have.
According to a recent survey by the National Bureau of Statistics, 44 percent of Chinese people, whether urban or rural, now save most for thei r childrens college education. Likewise, it says parents today spend as much as 42.8 percent of their savings on their childrens education.
In fact, some colleges in 1999 cashed in on this value and raised tuition by huge margins. Others lowered admission score thresholds in ord er to be able to collect more money from students who would otherwise not ha ve qualified for entry.
According to a report published in ‘Peoples Daily’ newspaper, these students have to pay as much as an extra 100,000 yuan (12,000 dollars) up from the 3,000 yuan (360 dollars) paid by normally admitted students.
Still, Xu Xian, director of the Beijing Municipal Education Commiss ion, says the city can expect by 2010 to have an educational system just as go od as countries like Singapore or Malaysia.
“Opportunities should be expanded so that at least 50 percent of the youngsters between the ages of 15 and 22 have the opportunity to attend college,” he says.
However, first it may help to get a better picture of education in the capital.
According to statistics released by the Ministry of Education, more than 73 percent of China’s population had gone through nine-year compulso ry education by 1998. Some 98.93 percent of children of primary school age attended classes, whereas 87.3 percent went to middle schools.
But the government has no statistics about the transient children who have equal rights to education, despite their potentially huge number and the possible implications of their inadequate basic education for the future.