Economy & Trade, Headlines, Labour, Latin America & the Caribbean

LABOUR-JAMAICA: New Minimum Wage Satisfies None

Dionne Jackson Miller

MONTEGO BAY, Dec 11 2001 (IPS) - Thirty-five year old Charmaine Walsh is a household helper in this coastal city who earns 43 dollars per week. A single mother raising four children ranging in age from 5 to 14 years, she often finds it hard to make ends meet.

“We have to wash, cook and iron, (do) a lot of things, including baby sitting. Sometimes we have to pay (taxi) fare, maybe more than one fare. And when you look at the bills, it is very hard, but we just can’t do better,” she said.

Walsh was less than impressed to hear that effective Jan. 7, a new national minimum wage will move the bottom rung on the pay ladder from the current 26 dollars per week to 39 dollars on average – less than what she earns.

“It should be more,” she said. “Some (employers say they) can’t afford to pay (above the minimum) so either you take it or you leave it. If the employer pays you the exact (39 dollars), my God, it is very hard.”

The government’s decision on the new minimum wage was a compromise that satisfied no one. Union leaders argue the new minimum will remain below the level required to keep workers above the poverty line. Business leaders express doubts about the country’s ability to afford the pay hikes, which average around 50 percent but vary somewhat between sectors of the economy.

Valerie Juggan-Brown, chief executive officer at Guardsman Group, is among the business figures expressing concern about the effects of the change on local commerce. Her company provides security guards to other businesses.

“The guards have not had any increase for over two and a half years, they protect billions of dollars worth of assets, they’re presently living on the edge and I’m very happy for the guards,” she said. “Whether the clients can afford it or not is another matter.”

The security industry association had recommended the increase be limited to 12-20 percent, Juggan-Brown said, to contain costs and avoid further job losses.

“One year we had 22,000 guards” in the industry, she said. “Now we’re down to 15,000.”

The Jamaica Employers Federation (JEF) recommended a 25 percent increase in the minimum wage in the first year, subsequent increases in succeeding years, and measures such as subsidised bus passes, easier access to food stamps, childcare facilities, and unemployment insurance.

On the other hand, the National Workers Union (NWU) had recommended a minimum wage of 54 dollars per week, about double the current rate. NWU Vice President Danny Roberts said this recommendation already was a compromise between idealism and practicality.

The ideal had been to raise wages above the national poverty line of 3,414 dollars per year, Roberts said. According to the Planning Institute of Jamaica, this is the minimum amount a household of five must earn to satisfy basic nutritional and living requirements.

“You’ll find that the minimum wage should be somewhere in the region of 3,730 dollars per year,” Roberts said. “If the minimum wage is not at that level it would obviously be inadequate.”

From “a pragmatic standpoint”, the union realised that a leap from 26 dollars per week to around 69 dollars was impractical, he added, “so we submitted a compromise position.”

At the employers’ federation, however, research committee Chairman Robert Wynter rejected the very notion of a minimum wage.

“Do you pay people because of what they need to live or because of the value of the output you’re getting?” he asked. “We believe you should pay based on the value of the output, so we do not really support the discussion that people need x, y and z to live and therefore the pay should be x y and z.”

Wynter argued, further, that minimum wage laws take away people’s rights to accept whatever jobs and wages may be available to them.

“There are persons who would be willing to accept wages below the minimum wage and they (would be) actually flouting the law. If they do not flout the law then they do not get any pay because someone who is paid the minimum wage, and has to pay someone to look after their children for example, cannot afford the minimum wage. So they either don’t pay somebody or they flout the minimum wage law, so there’s an inherent weakness in the whole matter of the minimum wage law,” he said.

Poverty is increasing, according to the government’s “Jamaica Survey of Living Conditions 2000”.

The reported incidence of poverty in 2000 stood at 18.7 percent, up from 16.9 percent the previous year. Poverty rose to 25.1 percent, from 22 percent, in rural areas and to 16.6 percent, from 12.1 percent, in urban areas, although it fell to 9.9 percent, from 10.6 percent, in the capital, Kingston.

The economy has been stagnant for most of the past decade but grew by 0.8 percent last year. The government had projected 3-5 percent growth this year but its expectations have been hit by political violence, which disrupted Kingston commerce in July; the Sep. 11 terrorist attacks in the United States, in the wake of which income from tourism, the country’s chief foreign exchange earner, has fallen by 30 percent; floods that have devastated infrastructure and farming in the eastern part of the country; and a 22 million dollar tax shortfall for September and October.

With the economy shaky, the Jamaica Manufacturers Association has raised the prospect of layoffs as bosses are forced to swallow pay hikes they cannot afford. The JEF has said 10,000 workers lost their jobs when the minimum wage was increased two years ago.

Union leader Roberts countered that labour groups have found no correlation between job losses and minimum wage rises.

The JEF’s Wynter, however, faulted the minimum wage as a strategy to fight poverty.

“We’ve had changes in minimum wage over the years, and this has really not affected our general economy, it’s not affected persons’ ability to live. It’s just a weak tool to use to undo the problems in the economy,” he said.

Roberts agreed, up to a point.

“We can set the ideal figure, but it becomes even more difficult to reach if the economy is declining,” he said, so the minimum wage must be “tied in to the performance of the economy.”

However, added Roberts, “how we proportion the earnings of a society is going to be critical to trying to lift the bottom income earners out of a quagmire of poverty, because it is recognised if you don’t do that you run the risk of the economy running into chaos and social exclusion.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags