Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

RELIGION-THAILAND: Errant Monk’s Case Sparks Introspection

Chayanit Poonyarat

BANGKOK, Oct 30 2001 (IPS) - “Though the world breaks up into dust, love fills my heart and even if my body is in a tomb, my heart is warm and flies to be with you,” read a letter supposedly written by a Thai man to his girlfriend.

However, the man supposed to have written this letter to female follower is Phra Issaramunee, one of the most well-known monks in this mainly Buddhist country and whose followers and supporters included Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra.

Since this month’s expose by local media of accusations about his relationship with a female disciple and his excessive fondness for worldly goods that included expensive living quarters and a Mercedes Benz, Issaramunee has voluntarily left the monkhood.

The former monk, however, denied the allegations and claimed that he was framed by the media.

Still, analysts say the case is an opportunity to look at how Thais deal with religion and spirituality in a modern society, against the backdrop of commercialism and materialism, and their attitude toward and expectations of religious figures today.

Some say people tend to create a line between themselves and their attitude toward religious leaders and not look enough into their own roles as followers.

“The main problem of Buddhism in Thailand is that it is based on hypocrisy,” said Dr Suwanna Satha-Anand, associate professor in the department of philosophy at Chulalongkorn University. “Thai Buddhists always believe that the purity of Buddhism depends only on the monks, so on the other hand, we push all the responsibility to them.”

There have been mixed reactions to the scandal involving Phra Issaramunee, who was the abbot of the Dhammavihari temple in Phetchaburi province 123 km south of Bangkok and is famous for his book on ‘Dharma’, of which he says sold two million copies in 10 languages have been sold.

(‘Dharma’ is the main doctrine of Buddhism, which teaches selflessness, detachment from worldly affairs, and the simple life.)

“We have to understand that the scandal concerned an individual, not the religion, and Buddhists should distinguish between the two,” said 22-year-old Sorawit Sangsuwan, a practising Buddhist.

Still, he thinks that problems with monks definitely impact on Buddhists’ faith, even though Phra Issaramunee has already quit the monkhood. Sorawit says Buddhism – 94 percent of Thailand’s 62 million population are Buddhists — is a religion that depends much on its disciples’ support.

Phra Issaramunee’s case is the not the first of the sort, but it generated controversy due to his seniority and because of the fact that Thaksin was a follower of his.

Several revered monks have earlier been brought down by sex scandals: Phra Kru Thamthorawanchai Thawaro was found dating a woman at a coffee shop while wearing a military uniform over his saffron robes. Phra Yantra Amaropikku was alleged to have had sexual affairs with a group of female followers, and Phra Paowana Puttho was accused of having sexually abused hilltribe girls.

In a statement he faxed to news agencies to announce his departure from the monkhood, Issaramunee, whose name is Viraphol Ruechai, said: “From now on, I will lead a peaceful life and will not bother about people’s opinions concerning this scandal.”

Living quarters worth 6 million baht (135,272 U.S. dollar) at his Dhammavihari Temple, a Mercedes Benz and a Honda Civic car, a 200,000 baht (4,500 dollar) rest room, underwater diving gear and a big satellite dish are among the luxurious belongings the monk was said to possess.

“Disrobing is considered the highest penalty, according to the recent disciplinary mechanism in the Buddhist hierarchy,” Phramaha Jerm Suvaco, general director of Buddhist Research Institute, said in an interview. “The problem is mostly treated as an incident, then later fades away from people’s memories.”

Beyond that, some have started to raise questions about how monks join the religious life as well as the bigger picture of lay Buddhists’ responsibility, including in the kinds of gifts they give to monks — which highlights the issue of spirituality in today’s materialistic culture.

“In trying to support Buddhism, some Buddhists give improper things to monks, at the same time asking the monk not to be attached to with worldly goods,” Suwanna added.

Media reports say Thaksin and his wife have donated at least six million baht (135,272 U.S. dollars) for the construction of a consecrated assembly hall in the temple compound of Phra Issaramunee.

The Religious Affairs Department has also recently been told to push for accountancy systems at all temples.

“Buddhism stands in the middle of materialism and isolation. ‘Dharma’ teaches us to know how to make use of modern equipment but not to be infatuated with them or be dominated by them,” explained Phramaha Jerm. “Buddhists have to know how to support Buddhism intelligently.”

He added, “Buddhism is based on the community concept with ideally a flat-hierarchy organisation. Community members, both monks or citizens, could give advice to each other with kindness.”

There are some 350,000 to 400,000 monks in Thailand, but studies have shown that less than 10 percent of the number stay in the monkhood for more than 10 years.

“The way recruiting monks in Thai society is also problematic as it mostly depends on quantity,” Suwanna said. She said this is relevant to Thai values that believe that every Buddhist man, once in his lifetime, should be able to experience the monkhood.

“Responsibility in the monks’ organisation should be drawn more clearly and systematically,” she explained. “Only monks who stay in the monkhood over certain time can preach or take care of the temple’s financial matters, but on the other hand it should not elbow out the ones who want to experience Buddhist ‘Dharma’.”

Sorawit agreed: “This should be the time that Buddhism reviews its way of recruiting monks. Those men should prove that they have strong will to become monks.”

He suggests that there be probations or spiritual assessments for those who would like to enter the monkhood. “If the person is not ready to be in the monkhood, he could still always learn ‘Dharma’ as an ordinary Buddhist,” Sorawit said.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags