Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean, North America

POLITICS-US: Andean Plan Survives Debate on Slim Aid Budget

Jim Lobe

WASHINGTON, Jul 25 2001 (IPS) - The US administration’s 700-mullion- dollar counter-drug aid programme for Colombia and the Andean region has made it through the House of Representatives essentially intact.

The controversial programme, meant to bolster and extend Plan Colombia, will now be reviewed by the Democrat-controlled Senate, where it is expected to run into some flak from the powerful chairman of the Foreign Operations Subcommittee, Sen. Patrick Leahy.

Like a number of House Democrats, Leahy, who has imposed tough human rights conditions on aid to Colombia in the past, wants to divert money requested by Bush for the Andean programme to fighting infectious diseases in Africa and other poor regions.

The latest developments came during a 12-hour debate that ran late into Tuesday night on the 15.2-billion-dollar fiscal 2002 foreign aid appropriations bill. As finally approved by the House, the bill provided President George W. Bush with virtually everything he asked for when he submitted the request in March.

The total amount of the bill, two percent more in nominal terms than what Congress appropriated last year in foreign aid, amounts to only about 0.1 percent of the US gross domestic product (GDP), the smallest proportion of aid to GDP provided by any major Western industrialised country and, in real terms, close to the lowest level since World War II.

Moreover, more than one-third of the aid is earmarked for US allies in the Middle East. Of the total, only about two-thirds is devoted to development and humanitarian assistance in needy countries, which also marks a 55-year low, according to a recent report by the non-partisan Center on Budget and Policy Priorities.

The Andean programme was the most controversial part of the aid bill, but it withstood a series of assaults by mainly Democratic lawmakers who, like Leahy, had hoped to divert some of the money to other development accounts. Some 676 million dollars was approved for the counter-drug aid effort.

The Andean Initiative, as the Bush administration calls it, includes some 399 million dollars for Colombia, 156 million dollars for Peru, with the balance spread between Bolivia, Ecuador, Brazil, Venezuela, and Panama.

It comes on top of a two-year, 1.6 billion dollar programme designed by the administration of former President Bill Clinton to support Plan Colombia, an initiative to train, equip, and advise Bogota’s military and police forces to help them take control of the major coca-growing region of Putumayo in southern Colombia and eradicate coca and opium poppy fields there.

The Plan has been strongly criticised both here and abroad primarily because almost all of the aid was for military assistance for the Colombian army, which has a poor human rights record and a history of collaboration with right-wing paramilitary forces responsible for most of the mass killings which have taken place in the country’s multi-faceted civil war.

In addition, neighbouring countries have expressed strong concern about the “spillover effects” of Plan Colombia. Indeed, as new, US-trained special army battalions have moved into the mainly rebel-controlled South, thousands of peasants have been displaced, particularly into Brazil, Ecuador, and Peru. Neighbours have also complained that combatants, including guerrillas and paramilitaries are also moving in and out of border areas.

The Bush administration packaged its initiative in part to deal with those concerns. While the bulk of the proposed aid to Colombia will still support army’s operations, about 150 million dollars of it is to be used for economic, humanitarian and development purposes. The bilateral packages for the other countries also provide substantial amounts for non-military purposes.

The total package had already been cut in committee deliberations by 55 million dollars, reducing the total to the 676 million dollars approved Tuesday night.

Democrats, who argued both that the drug war in the Andes has proven ineffective and that more military aid risked an intensification of the violence, introduced a series of amendments to cut the package further.

The first, proposed by California Democrat Barbara Lee, called for 38 million of the total to be diverted into the World Bank’s Global HIV/AIDS fund to which the Bush administration has so far committed 200 million dollars. Her amendment was defeated by a 188- 240 vote.

The second, sponsored by Massachusetts Rep. Jim McGovern, called for 100 million dollars to be taken from the Andean account and split evenly between existing programmes to fight infectious diseases and promote child health in the poorest countries. It was defeated by a slightly larger margin.

“We need to stay the course,” argued Republican Rep. Ben Gilman, who noted that two dozen transport helicopters appropriated under Plan Colombia have only been delivered to the Colombian army in the past month.

On the other hand, lawmakers showed that they remain wary about deeper US involvement in Colombia’s civil war. The House adopted one Democratic amendment that limits the number of US military and civilian contract personnel to 800 at any one time. Civilian contract employees play a key role both in flying crop-duster aircraft on eradication missions and in maintaining equipment in the anti-drug war. The same amendment also requires the administration to notify Congress at least 15 days in advance before supplying any offensive weapons to the Colombian army.

Another amendment would suspend 65 million dollars in military aid for Peru pending a report by the State Department on the April 20 incident in which a Peruvian fighter jet on an anti-drug trafficking mission shot down a plane carrying a missionary family, killing the mother and her small baby.

The missionary plane, which reportedly failed to answer a number of attempts to communicate with it, was identified for the Peruvian air force by a second plane manned by CIA contract personnel as part of US anti-drug efforts. The administration has insisted that, while the CIA crew guided the Peruvian fighter to the suspect plane, they tried to dissuade it from firing on the plane without a greater effort to determine whether it was on a drug-trafficking mission.

Democrats had also planned to offer an amendment that would have blocked any of the funds approved under the Andean Initiative from being used for aerial fumigation, but withdrew it when they decided they lacked the votes to prevail.

Just last week, the governors of six Colombian states affected by the fumigation campaign against coca crops met with President Andres Pastrana to call for an end to such efforts. They said that the policy was “harmful” to the environment and human health, as well as “costly and ineffective” in addressing the drug problem.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags