Asia-Pacific, Headlines

THAILAND-LAOS: Film Project Digs Up Old Tensions

Chayanit Poonyarat

BANGKOK, Jul 20 2001 (IPS) - Its script is not yet complete and not a single frame has been shot, but a film about a heroine who is believed to have staved off a Lao invasion of Thailand centuries ago is reviving old suspicions between the neighbouring countries.

This week, there was talk of plans by an irked Laotian government to boycott Thai goods if the planned movie project continues — reports that Laotian officials denied.

On Thursday, the row reached the Senate, where the film’s director Phisarn Akraseranee called anger over the movie ‘Thao Suranaree’ an “overreaction” because it had nothing to do with politics.

Still, “we will surely pay back if the film affects us but I cannot say how now,” Hiem Phommachanh, Laos’ ambassador to Thailand, was quoted as saying by local media this week.

“I do not see the need to bring up the Thao Suranaree story,” said Khammy Bouasengthong, first secretary at the Laotian embassy. “Thailand and Lao are closely related through blood, tradition, and language. We wish our ties to be good.”

The film project, the latest in a spate of Thai historical movies involving foreign aggression, tells of the story of Thao Suranaree, wife of the governor of Korat (today Nakhon Ratchasima province) and who Thai historical chronicles say led local folk in defending Siam from a Lao invasion in 1827.

It is said that Thao Suranaree, also called ‘Khunying Mo’, tricked Lao invaders into drinking large amounts of alcohol before launching an ambush.

She was the first commoner in Thai history to be honoured with a national monument built in 1934 at the square of Nakhon Ratchasima, a province about 260 km north-east of Bangkok.

Every year from Mar. 23 to Apr. 3, thousands of people flock to this monument to honour Thao Suranaree, who is seen as a guardian spirit for local folk.

But this story riles Laotians, because they revere King Anuwong, her opponent, as one of their greatest leaders who tried to liberate Laos from subordination to Siam (Bangkok).

“For Laos, King Anuwong is a revered monarch who could be compared to King Naresuan the Great (the Thai monarch who helped Thailand gain independence from Burma during the Ayudhya period),” historian and professor Charnvit Kasetsiri told the Senate foreign relations committee on Thursday.

Thus, some academics say Thailand should show an understanding of Laos’ sensitivity in the same way it is sensitive to issues relating to respect for the monarchy.

“Every war has a justified cause, but the history between Thailand and its neighbours has many aspects young generations should avoid,” Professor Dhawat Boonnotoke, a visiting lecturer on the Thai language at Burabha University, was quoted as saying.

“A war-related story like that of Thao Suranaree should not be thrown into the world of entertainment at a time when Thailand needs to make peace with its neighbours,” he said.

Indeed, the film project also came up during the June visit of Prime Minister Taksin Shinnawatra to Laos. There, Laotian officials urged the Thai government to stop plans for the movie in order to avoid hurting bilateral ties.

“The government cannot dictate to stop making the film,” Thaksin said. “We are a democratic country though we would try our best not to cause dissatisfaction with our neighbours.”

Thailand’s ties with Laos has had many ups and downs through the years.

The Laotian ambassador recalled that the two neighbours had a conflict a decade ago at their common border, Ban Rom Klao, which Thailand lost.

But recent years have seen cooperative moves. In April 1994, the Friendship Bridge, spanning the Mekong river near the Laotian capital Vientiane, linked the nation to Thailand for the first time.

Plans for a second ‘friendship bridge’ were discussed during Thaksin’s visit, along with cooperation on drug prevention, trade and an electricity generation contract. Construction of this bridge is expected to start next year and to be completed three years later.

Laos and Thailand also have deep economic ties but bilateral tensions exist on issues like Laos’ wariness about rebels, demanding a return to constitutional, who seek refuge in Thailand.

During a National Security Council meeting Thursday, Laos and Thailand agreed on ways to prevent members of anti-Vientiane movements from staging sabotage activities from Thailand, including barring the entry of the movements’ leaders into Thailand.

Even in Thailand itself, the story of Thao Suranaree has been the subject of debate, though not a high-profile one. Delving into it has also proven to be sensitive, causing tensions between researchers and local people in Nakhon Ratchasima some years ago.

Still, Saipin Kaewngamprasert, in her masteral thesis on the ‘Politics of the Thao Suranaree Monument’ done for Thammasat University, asserts that the story of Thao Suranaree’s exploits had a lot to do with meeting political and societal needs as well.

“Siam in 1932 was passing from absolute monarchy to constitutional monarchy. A modern face showing women rights and people power then was very much needed,” said Saipin.

The study raises the question of political necessity playing a role in Thao Suranaree’s story, noting that the heroine’s courageous act was not mentioned in Thai historical chronicles until decades later.

Saipin added that not long before the erection of the monument to her, Nakhon Ratchasima was accused of being the base of a revolt against Bangkok. “Thao Suranaree therefore perfectly served as an ideal symbol to show the locals’ loyalty to the Thai nation,” she wrote.

Hiem also urged the producer of the planned film to study the Lao version of events, saying there is no mention of the female warrior in Laos’ history at all.

This is not the only Thai historical film that has touched on relations on its neighbours, focusing on the themes of patriotism and nationalism.

The film ‘Bang Rajan’, shown earlier in the year, portrayed the struggle of Thai villagers who fought against Burmese invaders centuries ago. Another historical film about Thai-Burmese hostility, ‘Suriyothai’, will be released on Aug. 12.

But Phisarn Akraseranee, director of ‘Thao Suranaree’, told the Senate committee that “the film has nothing to do with politics”.

“I felt threatened. I think they (Laotians) have misunderstood my objective in making this film. I think we would be better served by talking instead of overreacting like this,” he argued.

Meantime, the production house Saha Mongkhol Film will continue working on ‘Thao Suranaree’. Shooting is expected to start in August, and the film is scheduled for release early next year.

“We have excellent role models in our long history that today’s people can look up to for inspiration. Why should be we afraid of telling the truth as it is?” Phisarn asked.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags