Headlines | Analysis

//CORRECTED REPEAT//POLITICS: Germany’s New Role in the Middle East Peace Process

Analysis Yojana Sharma

BERLIN, Jul 13 2001 (IPS) - The visit to Berlin of Syrian President Bashar Assad, just a week after Israeli prime minister Ariel Sharon held talks with Chancellor Gerhard Schroeder, has highlighted Germany’s new-found pivotal role in the Middle East peace process.

Assad’s visit — Tuesday and Wednesday — was the first by a Syrian leader to Germany in 23 years.

European Union diplomats see the visit as an indication of Europe’s new role as a counterbalance to the US in the Middle East, with Germany, one of the largest of the EU countries, in a position to put pressure on both sides in the conflict.

Germany’s role in the Middle East came to the fore last month when German Foreign Minister Joschka Fischer’s planned visit to Jerusalem coincided with the bombing of a disco in Tel Aviv, providing him with the unexpected opportunity to act as a calming influence on both sides.

In the wake of the bombing, German diplomats had played a direct role in influencing Palestinian leader Yassar Arafat’s Jun 2 statement promising action by the Palestinian Authority to end violence which helped diffuse the situation, according to a foreign ministry official in Berlin.

Fischer had made it “unmistakably clear” to the Palestinian leadership that the attack was indefensible and inexcusable and that the violence had to be held in check, German officials in Berlin said.

Fischer himself is modest about his diplomatic efforts to avert a slide into war, even though it brought him international recognition as an effective diplomat in a crisis, and one which both sides seemed willing to listen to even while tempers were high.

While his efforts helped stop what Fischer himself referred to as “two trains about to collide at top speed”, the German foreign minister maintains that this had merely given both sides in the conflict “more time”, rather than resolving any underlying differences.

A diplomatic analyst in Berlin has pointed out that the praise heaped on the German foreign minister “for being in the right place at the right time” has increased expectations on Germany and Fischer to play a mediating role that the country may not be so willing to play.

During a visit to Berlin in April, Egypt’s President Hosni Mubarak had expressed the hope that Germany would assume a more prominent role in Middle East talks, as a “very important element and a very important country in Europe with a strong voice”.

Mubarak told a German television in April that if Chancellor Schroeder were to play a mediating role, he would welcome it.

In an interview with a German newspaper just before his visit, Sharon said “of all the European countries, Germany is the only one pursuing a balanced approach to the Middle East”.

As if to underline this “balance” Schroeder told both Sharon and Assad that Germany would “demonstrate” solidarity with Israel and Syria, but this did not mean “supporting every position”.

But, while it has been the office of the German Chancellor rather that Fischer’s foreign ministry that has prepared the visits of Sharon and Assad to Berlin, Schroeder has been cautious about any specific German involvement in further mediation.

Germany has traditionally been a reluctant player in the international arena, because of its own militaristic past. But involvement in the Middle East is an even more sensitive issue for Berlin, which because of the Nazi extermination of the Jews some 50 years ago, has meant close ties with Israel.

Ironically this, in itself, has helped Germany emerge as an even-handed participant in the Middle East process. In the past, the European Union countries were seen as too close to the Arab world for the sake of their oil, during an era of rising oil prices, to be able to play any even handed role. Only Germany had the requisite closeness to both sides.

Fischer has been careful to stress that his intervention last month has not set a precedent for a special German role in the Middle East. He has repeated that his mediation efforts were intended to avoid the worst in the Middle East and not born of a desire for Germany to be more directly involved in the region.

However he underlines that his intervention confirms “the usefulness of a European role” and that any German action was to be co-ordinated with EU and the US – an indication that Europe was not willing to replace the US in the Middle East process, but to support it.

But this does not mean that Germany will keep completely to the sidelines as in the past. By contrast with its past reluctance to play a key role in foreign affairs “Germany is moving but slowly”, says Karl Kaiser of the German Foreign Policy Institute in Berlin.

“But the politics of reserve are still there. There is an evolution: it is a matter of being more aware of one’s interests and ready to state them openly,” he says.

Diplomats, wishing not to be named, note that even were Germany to insist on only acting in the Middle East “through the EU” it could still be drawn into a greater role.

They point out that the administration of US president George W. Bush has indicated less interest in pursuing a solution to the Middle East crisis as predecessor Bill Clinton.

“Mr Bush no longer wants the US to be the sole key player in the (Middle East) peace process and appears to be willing to work more closely together with Europe,” said an official in the chancellery, the office of Schroeder.

At the same time, the emergence of a co-ordinated European Union foreign policy under its representative for foreign affairs Javier Solana has meant that Europe is more able to become involved politically as a group rather than as individual governments with individual national interests and emphases.

“Thanks to Mr Solana, Washington is willing to work more closely with Europe on the peace process,” a chancellery official said.

Diplomats in Berlin also note a call for greater European involvement by Israel, which is already closely linked to the EU through a special trade agreement. The Palestinian National Authority also is closely linked to the EU through a major aid deal.

Diplomats note that the aid deal gives the EU some clout. “In theory to exert pressure on one side or the other the EU could threaten to limit or freeze aid to the Palestinians, or they could limit Israeli exports to the EU,” says a Brussels-based diplomat.

This view may be overstated. German foreign ministry officials say Fischer remains unconvinced that economic sanctions will have any effect on Israel’s settlement policy and would only lead to Israel losing confidence in Europe as a mediator. They say a strong stance by EU commissioner Chris Patten has merely meant him being sidelined in Israel.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags