Asia-Pacific, Economy & Trade, Headlines, Human Rights, Labour

RIGHTS-INDIA: Scrap Pickers Demand Coverage by Labour Laws

Meena Menon

PUNE, India, May 18 2001 (IPS) - Ahilyabai Avte, an 80-year-old scrap collector, slowly walks up to the stage with her trademark white sack.

But instead of garbage, she takes out large placards stating the demands of thousands of scrap collectors from all over the western state of Maharashtra and presents them to its minister for labour, Dr Hemant Deshmukh.

At a meeting earlier this month in Pune, about 170 km south of from Mumbai, 3,000 odd scrap collectors packed into a sports stadium and made a forceful demand to the government to be included under labour laws.

Coverage by the law would give them some social security benefits and recognition for the valuable work they are carrying out, they say.

Ahilyabai is the oldest among the some 5,000 members of a trade union of scrap collectors, the Kagad Patra Kashtakari Panchayat (Scrap Collectors Association) which was formed in 1993 and has succeeded in extending group insurance cover to 650 scrap collectors.

Ahilyabai still goes out every morning to rummage in rubbish bins near Pune. Her lined face and thin voice, occasionally breaking with anguish, tell their own story .

“I get hurt while picking small pieces of glass and manage to earn 10 to 20 rupees (20 to 43 U.S. cents) a day. I have four children but they don’t help me. On the contrary they ask me for money,” she rued.

“When I started out I used to earn 10 to 15 paise a day, now I collect less garbage but earn more,” she added. (One hundred paise is one rupee.)

Sixty-year-old Anasuya laments,”The best years of my life were spent sorting rubbish.”

Like her, other grey-haired women some in their 50s and 60s still leave their homes early morning carrying their white sacks, grimy with dirt, and spend six to eight hours looking for recyclable waste.

But on the day of the convention here, the sacks were conspicuous by their absence. “Today is the day to listen to important people speaking,” said one woman, eating ice cream to beat the scorching mid-afternoon heat.

There are 100,000 scrap collectors in the state. They are mostly Dalit women, from the untouchable caste, who constitute a large portion of unorganised informal labour in cities.

Scrap collectors labour the whole day to retrieve paper, plastic, glass and metal scrap from garbage bins, streets and dumping grounds, which they then sell to scrap traders. Waste pickers are unorganised and informal sector workers and not covered by any labour legislation.

A study in Pune by researchers Poornima Chikarmane, Dr Medha Deshpande and Lakshmi Narayan reveals that scrap collectors save the Pune and Pimpri Chinchwad Municipal Corporations, which are civic authorities in charge of waste disposal and collection, more than one million rupees (21,700 U.S. dollars) a year in transport.

Scrap collectors in Pune collect some 151 tonnes in garbage daily in this city of 3 million people.

They are most likely to be women, married, illiterate and between 19 and 50 years of age. Almost half the waste pickers are the highest income earners in their households and about 27 percent in the age group 19-35 years and 33 percent in the age group 36-50 years have been deserted, separated or widowed.

The mean monthly per capita income ranges from 126 to 2,233 (2.73 to 48.5 dollars) and one in four scrap collectors falls below the poverty line. Their mean daily income is 1.3 dollars.

Narayan says 50 percent of the women earn more than the men and they contribute more toward the household income.

Apart from struggling to earn enough, scrap collectors do face occupational risks. One third of them have been bitten by dogs and every second scrap collector suffers an injury at least once a week due to metal edges or broken glass.

Three percent have suffered grievous injury that has rendered them permanently disabled.

Women often walk for more than eight hours to collect scrap, but there are no public spaces for them. Often, scrap collectors are not given any space to sort garbage.

The value of scrap collecting is underappreciated by city residents. In fact, the union says, the entire recycling pyramid is based on the labour of the scrap collectors. Because they are engaged in economically productive and environmentally beneficial work, they should be recognised as unprotected manual workers.

Every scrap collector should be registered with the local municipality he or she works in, it demands.

Already, many women members of the union boast of photo identity cards issued by municipal corporations, which they claim has reduced harassment and abuse from police or municipal workers.

More than 3,000 cards have been issued to scrap collectors by the Pune municipal corporation alone. The small red card has given them a measure of respectability, they feel.

Because scrap collectors are not covered by any law, they do not have benefits such as provident fund, bonus and paid leave.

Thus, the union wants them to be covered under the Maharashtra Hamal Mathadi and Other Unprotected Workers 1969, Likewise, they say traders and industries must contribute to the statutory benefits provided for under this law — and the state must province them medical and life insurance cover.

While scrap collectors have rights that must be recognised, the main difficulty is they do not have a legally tenable employer- worker relationship with retail scrap traders, says Lakshmi Narayan, general secretary of the union.

The government contends that ragpickers are self-employed and it is difficult to get the scrap traders to be responsible for the scrap collectors’ welfare.

At the convention, Deshmukh gave a typical government response to the union’s demands, saying he would look into the matter. The participants held him to a timeframe of two months to decide if laws for the unorganised sector could cover scrap collectors.

“We get very little money — we should at least get minimum wages for this work,” said Ulan Kamble, who has come from Satara, also in Maharashtra. She sells scrap worth 30 rupees everyday to make ends meet for her husband and four children.

Ratnamala Kamble has taken to scrap collecting after her husband deserted her 10 years ago. “In the monsoon, earnings dip so I have to find other work,” she said.

In short, for scrap workers there is no job security or retirement.

For older scrap collectors, 1972 was the year their misery began. A major drought crippled the backward regions of Maharashtra, sparking off large-scale migration that saw many people, including older women, come in search of work.

Many of them, homeless and hungry, found scrap collection the way to survive.

Mary Johnson, director of the International Labour Organisation in India, says working people should be able to choose work freely, to negotiate their working conditions, lead a decent and dignified life — and retire that way.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags