Economy & Trade, Headlines, Labour, Latin America & the Caribbean

LABOUR-MEXICO: Once-Powerful Union in Check this May Day

Diego Cevallos

MEXICO CITY, Apr 29 2001 (IPS) - The Confederation of Mexican Workers (CTM), a dominant force during the 71 years of Institutional Revolutionary Party (PRI) rule, has accelerated in its downward spiral following a blow from the Judiciary, the movement’s former ally, just in time for International Labour Day, May 1.

Mexico’s Supreme Court of Justice ruled in April, based on a lawsuit filed by a group of workers at a sugar mill, that obtaining or keeping a job with a company no longer depends on an individual’s union membership, a status known in Mexico as the “exclusion clause.”

According to the justices, employees can leave a union or form another without that fact becoming a threat to job security. The exclusion clause, even though it is spelled out in labour laws, is contrary to the Mexican Constitution, they concluded.

The ruling puts an end to decades of control by industry-specific unions – nearly all allies of the PRI – over the collective contracts and hiring practices at a given company.

Nevertheless, the Confederation of Employers warned that allowing the creation of several unions within one company or industry, or permitting employees to quit the unions outright, could generate “a sort of licentiousness.”

Since the presidency of PRI member Ernesto Zedillo (1994-2000), the CTM, the PRI’s umbrella union that represents approximately five million people, has suffered deep divisions and scepticism within its ranks, including accusations of corruption.

Fearful that its grassroots would rebel against the Zedillo government, the CTM suspended its traditional May 1 marches throughout the six years of the presidential term.

On Tuesday, Labour Day, the CTM will hold commemorative ceremonies in a closed venue, while other union centrals are planning marches in the streets of the capital and in other cities.

The arrival last December of Vicente Fox to the presidency, the first non-PRI president in seven decades, contributed to the weakening of the formerly dominant CTM and allowed other labour unions to build strength, especially those originating in dissident groups, such as the National Union of Workers.

More than a half million workers have left the CTM in the last three years, according to the unofficial calculations of experts in labour affairs. The PRI-affiliated union giant has not once called a national strike throughout its long history.

The CTM long used the exclusion clause to fight dissidence within its ranks, and the union’s top executives negotiated collective labour contracts, all in the name of unity and the defence of workers.

Labour experts largely agree that this month’s Supreme Court ruling was a decisive blow against union corporatism. The long-time labour leaders allied with the PRI, however, interpret the court decision as a government attempt to undermine the union movement in general and to divide workers.

With the exclusion clause, many unions abandoned the goal of defending workers’ rights and simply became monopolies that used privilege to achieve greater power, maintains Sergio Sarmiento, a columnist for ‘Reforma’ newspaper.

In the past, the Supreme Court had continually refused to rule on the exclusion clause and its justices never issued any kind of resolution that would negatively affect the CTM or the PRI.

But in 1996, when a series of legal reforms guaranteed the Judiciary’s independence, the Supreme Court began to emit rulings affecting political interests that had previously been considered untouchable.

“The ruling against the exclusion clause represents a major advance in the efforts to hem in union corporatism and vindicates the changes that Mexico is experiencing,” Fernando Herrera, labour researcher at the Autonomous Metropolitan University (UAM), told IPS.

“This opens the door for union freedoms. The corporatist leaders, accustomed to abusing their power and to the lack of internal democracy, of course they are going to react against the court decision,” commented Herrera.

For constitutional lawyer Ignacio Burgoa, “The Supreme Court, now free of so many prejudices, correctly ruled that all obstacles restricting union freedoms should be removed.”

Meanwhile, José Ramírez, PRI lawmaker and member of the CTM’s executive committee, stated that the court decision “demonstrates the rightist tendencies of President Fox’s government and its goal of ending the union movement.”

Despite the threats the CTM has directed at Fox and his economic and political strategies, the group has not carried out any act of protest. On the contrary, the former powerhouse has accepted all of the government’s invitations for dialogue.

The CTM’s leaders “are weak and no longer have the opportunity to oppose the wave of changes the country is experiencing,” said political analyst Santiago Trejo.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags