Friday, November 20, 2026
Farah Khan
- Debate is raging in trade union owned companies, in South Africa, on whether they should take part in the state’s privatisation programme.
Government has extended sweeteners in the form of funding for black companies, employee share ownership schemes as well as mass share offerings.
The dominant view in the unions is that they should not touch privatisation, but those unions with business interests (over 20 have their own investment companies), face a lobby by union executives to take a piece of the action.
Another dilemma lies in whether or not union companies should bid for outsourcing contracts. They offer debt-free opportunities for union investment companies, but they also often come on the back of job losses.
The foray into investment companies may be one of the more significant and exciting developments in contemporary trade union history, but it remains the most fraught.
The Congress of South African Trade Unions (Cosatu), the labour federation whose affiliates have the highest number of union investment companies, has fought a long-standing battle for control of the direction of its investment companies.
First in its line of fire was personal enrichment. Cosatu drew up a Code of Investment that prevented union officials and office- bearers benefiting from co-investment rights that made millionaires of Golding, who started the National Union of Mines’ Mineworkers Investment Company). And Johnny Copelyn, who started the South African Clothing and Textile Workers Union-owned Sactwu Investment Group (SIG). Officials and office-bearers also cannot earn directors fees any longer.
The federation established an Investment Council that is meant to direct strategy of all its allied investment companies. Cosatu wants investments made in the productive and socially useful sectors.
In other words, no speculative investments, but direct investment is instead allowed. They should also aim to change the current patterns of ownership, control and corporate governance, which should include securing and advancing the rights of workers in companies.
The Investment Code precludes unions drawing on retirement funds and it suggests that investment companies consult with unions operating in the sectors or companies where equity stakes are envisaged.
The federation’s efforts at taking the control have been largely unsuccessful. Cosatu General-secretary Zwelinzima Vavi said recently the “Secretariat was over-stretched” and that the Investment Council was not a top priority.
Consequently, the Council had not developed a policy that would direct the investment companies towards the federation’s strategic aims.
“We risk the emergence of vested interests opposed to our broader goals. For instance, union investments should not participate in privatisation and outsourcing, or strengthen the private health sector in ways that undermine the push for national health insurance,” he warned.
The dominant view in Cosatu is that the union investment companies are here to stay, but their shape and form is still contested terrain. The hard-line perspective, as reflected in a South African Municipal Workers Union (SAMWU) debate last year, is that to tamper in wealth creation is to contaminate the function of a union.
Consequently, SAMWU decided not to start an investment company. It is a minority perspective.
Almost a year after its Congress, Cosatu shows no sign of developing a coherent investment strategy – it remains over- stretched and its forces are being spread ever-thinner as challenges facing the union movement grows.