Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Kenneth Rapoza
- Parents in inner cities in the United States are increasingly agreeing with politicians and corporations in the country that insist that private schools are better at educating their children than public schools.
“Public education is coming under attack from the number one constituency that is most dependent on it – poor parents,” said Pedro Noguera, urban sociologist at Harvard University’s Graduate School of Education. “They’re questioning whether public schools have even really served them in the first place,” he said.
One-third of the US public school population lives in major cities. Their schools are at least 80 percent minority. It is these schools that are reported to be grossly under-funded, sometimes overcrowded, open to new immigrants, and always full of students with learning and behavioural problems.
“This is something private schools rarely have to deal with,” said Dennis Vicars, executive director of the private Phoenix Schools of Sacramento,á California.
When standardised test scores are revealed to the public, these under-funded schools are scolded for doing badly on the examinations. This is another hurdle private schools need not jump, as state tests are not required and student achievement is measured by individual schools.
Despite these stark differences in students and school rules, private education advocates are adamant that government-run schools have failed.
“Private schools do a better job serving the public and accommodating the needs of the disenfranchised as well as the high achievers,” said Darcy Olsen, Director of Education at the Cato Institute in Washington DC.
“The public schools don’t have to serve anybody, they just have to be open,” she added.
In the United States, poor children have just two hopes for attending a private school. The first is through school choice programmes or “opportunity grants”.
Formerly known as “vouchers”, this political minefield of a programme lets parents take their tax dollars out of failing public schools and use it to gain access for the children to private schools or other public schools.
“High demand for private schooling is a sign of deep failure of the public school system,” said Harry Brighouse, professor of philosophy of education at London University’s Institute for Education. “This explains the support for voucher schemes among inner-city blacks.”
A recent study by the Joint Center for Political and Economic Studies found that 88 percent of African-Americans were in favour of choosing a private school over a public one. Ninety-five percent of those favouring public schools came from families earning below the poverty line.
Private schools now hold out a promise for the poor. But there are many strings attached.
Milwaukee, Wisconsin, located in north central United States, lets families earning at or below the poverty line use their tax dollars to send their children to private school. The programme is strictly regulated by the state, which allows families access to state taxes only, not local town taxes.
“They’ve been able to educate these public school students for less money,” said Brighouse, who praised the regulated programme. Academically, though, these students maintained the same grades.
So how do private schools educate the poor better than public schools? At least three studies show that they do not.
The National Assessment of Educational Progress showed low performing, private-school students in the fourth grade did better than their peers in public schools. But high achieving private school students were no better than high achieving public school students.
“That’s a big deal considering public schools have to accept everybody and private schools can choose their students,” said Gerald Bracey, independent education researcher. “Our public school kids from the suburbs are as good as any student anywhere.”
A 1998 Stanford University study published by the Economic Policy Institute in Washington D.C. revealed similar data and concluded that private schools are not exceedingly better than public schools.
The second way a poor children can attend a private school is through the privatisation of their own public school. Corporations like Edison Corp., Mosaica Education Inc. and SABISá – a Lebanese firm that manages US schools for profit – are taking over troubled schools or relieving pro- privatisation school administrators of the task of running their schools.
Jill Wynns, member of the school board and no fan of the Edison Corp., the largest such company, said the programme had some merit.
Edison Corp. runs the Edison Elementary School, a San Francisco neighbourhood school serving poor black and Latino children ages five to eleven.
“They made new rules. There’re school uniforms and more order, like the military. Now the standardised test scores are going up,” Wynns said.
Edison, like most new firms that have entered the education market in the last ten years, say they can improve a school faster and cheaper than the government and teachers’ unions.
But a report released in late February by researchers at Western Michigan University, a state where 70 percent of new public schools are run by such for-profit companies compared to 10 percent nationally, revealed students at Edison-run schools do as well as they did prior to privatisation.
“The reviews are mixed regarding private industry running public schools,” said Gary Miron, professor and lead researcher of the study. “After four years, the students were not doing substantially better than the national norm. Definitely not as good as Edison says they are.”
The United States lags behind most of the world in terms of private education. Nearly 88 percent of its students attend public schools. In the Ivory Coast, 60 percent of secondary school students are in private schools.
In India, Africa and Southeast Asia, new private firms like the National Institute of Information Technology and Aptech have opened new private schools. These institutions serve poor neighbourhoods, but not for free.
In India, the Federation of Private Schools’ Management in Hyderabad runs 500 private schools serving poor communities. It costs 10 dollars a year. Less than one-third of students attend the school for free.
Objetivo private schools in Brazil reach 500,000 students, costing 215-355 reals a month, nearly four times the country’s minimum wage.
“In Peru, new private schools have opened up in response to cuts in K-12 public education spending and they are now attracting the middle class,” Noguera said. Noguera researches schools in the Caribbean and Latin America.
Nevertheless, public education in the United States and the developing world is being considered a monopoly that some politicians and companies would like to dismantle.
Nearly one-twentieth of the global gross domestic product is spent on public education, according to a series of reports published by UNESCO last November. Private sector involvement in education accounts for one-fifth of the global gross domestic product.
How the private sector captures more of the education market in the United States will likely depend on how they can serve the dissatisfied consumers of public education – African-Americans and Hispanics.á