Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Middle East & North Africa

/REPEATING FOR POINTS NEEDING/POLITICS: Mideast Violence Slows Down UN Treaty on Terrorism

Thalif Deen

UNITED NATIONS, Mar 2 2001 (IPS) - The spiralling violence in the Middle East is slowing down the creation of a new UN treaty – described as the most “comprehensive convention” against global terrorism.

“We have made significant progress, but there are still several important issues outstanding,” says Rohan Perera, chairman of the UN Ad hoc Committee on Terrorism.

Among the deadlocked issues: the distinction between terrorism and legitimate freedom struggle, and between “state terrorism” and “acts of self-defence” by state governments.

At a two-week long closed-door meeting of the Ad hoc Committee, which ended last Friday, one of the most contentious issues on the agenda was state terrorism.

The continued killings of Palestinians by Israel – over 350 since last September – and the aerial bombardment of Iraq by British and US fighter planes sparked a combative debate on the subject of state terrorism

Syria, Lebanon and Iraq argued that Israeli, British and American acts of violence in the Middle East are clearly “state terrorism”.

In a report released last week, the London-based Amnesty International said “the acceptance of unlawful killings by the Israeli government and its failure to investigate each death caused by its security services is leading to a culture of impunity.”

Cuba, on the other hand, has accused the United States of organising and financing groups of mercenaries to carry out “terrorist acts” against the Cuban government and its leadership.

Any comprehensive UN convention against terrorism should, therefore, include laws against terrorist acts undertaken or sponsored by state governments, these countries point out.

But the United States argues that the proposed convention should deal only with acts of terrorism by individuals or by groups of individuals. All state action can be covered, as it is now, only by international law, including human rights treaties and the Geneva Conventions governing military conflicts.

Currently, there are 12 UN and international conventions dealing with terrorism – ranging from a treaty against hijacking to a treaty protecting nuclear material.

The last two conventions adopted by the General Assembly were the 1997 International Convention for the Suppression of Terrorist Bombings and the 1999 International Convention for the Suppression of Financing for Terrorism.

But despite these treaties, terrorism has been on the rise: some of the most serious being the attack on the US warship Cole in Yemen last October, the bombing of US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania in August 1998 and the explosion outside the Khobar Towers housing complex near Dhahran, Saudi Arabia in June 1996.

On Wednesday, the British government announced that it will soon designate some 20 groups as “terrorists” under a new anti-terrorism law that came into force in Britain. These groups – including the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam of Sri Lanka, the Armed Islamic Group of Algeria and the Kurdistan Workers Party of Turkey – will no longer be able to operate out of Britain.

The convention currently under discussion – based on a draft submitted by India – is expected to cover all aspects relating to terrorism, including extradition of terrorists to their home countries.

Most Arab nations, however, insist that the convention should make the distinction between terrorism and the legitimate struggle for self-determination.

Under the terms of a proposal before the Committee, “people’s struggle, including armed struggle against foreign occupation, aggression, colonialism and hegemony, aimed at liberation and self-determination in accordance with the principles of international law, should not be considered a terrorist crime”.

A Third World diplomat told IPS that the Ad hoc Committee is clearly getting ready for the long haul. “The whole exercise is mired in Middle Eastern and Indo-Pakistan politics,” he said.

Until and unless there are political settlements in these troubled regions, there can be no dispassionate discussion of terrorism or the definition of a terrorist.

“What India does in Kashmir is considered state terrorism by Pakistan, and what Pakistan does in Kashmir is state terrorism in the eyes of India,” he said.

Speaking on behalf of the 15-member European Union (EU), Ambassador Bosse Hedberg of Sweden told delegates last week that the EU unequivocally condemns terrorism in all its forms and manifestations, regardless of motive or origin.

“Nevertheless, in its legitimate efforts to suppress terrorism,” he argued, “the international community must always respect human rights and fundamental freedoms.”

However, he added, “there must not be any safe havens for terrorists or impunity for their acts.”

Hedberg pointed out that the scope of the comprehensive convention – and in particular the relation to the previous conventions – remains a key issue.

Meanwhile, a longstanding proposal for an international conference on terrorism and a separate UN convention against nuclear terrorism have both been put on hold because of a lack of consensus.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags