Thursday, November 19, 2026
Chayanit Poonyarat
- What on surface was a diplomatic row that saw Thailand being caught in the one-China policy has exposed the difficulty of taking steps to help the country’s migrant workers in Taiwan and other countries.
Last week, a bilateral agreement to improve working conditions of some 180,000 Thai workers in Taiwan — the largest market for the country’s overseas labour — was put at risk when Thailand denied an entry visa to a Taiwanese labour representative on the eve of the signing ceremony.
Taiwan took great offence to the snub, which it saw as a last-minute attempt by the government of Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra to appease Beijing, and threatened to not sign the accord and to freeze or cut back its number of Thai workers.
The spat now appears to have quietened down after the Thai government on Monday said it is ready to issue a visa to Chen Chu, the Taiwanese chairwoman of the Council of Labour Affairs, saying that the signing of the labour agreement had been merely “postponed”.
On Tuesday, in a bid to contain the fall out, the Thai foreign affairs ministry placed blame for the incident squarely on the shoulders of its labour ministry and for their part labour officials said they would dispatch a representative to Taipei next week to patch things up.
But the incident is a stark reminder of how the migrant workers’ issue can become politicised, even as countries like Thailand try to find ways of improving the working conditions of their workers — many of whom work on construction sites in the Middle East, as domestic workers in Hong Kong and as factory hands in Taiwan.
In many ways, the vulnerability that Thai workers are exposed to is due to the system where workers are forced to pay hefty fees demanded by Thai job brokerage companies and where the government has had difficulty undercutting this system.
“The weak point of Thai law is that it allows individuals to get jobs abroad, that’s the main problem,” said Dr Supang Chantavanich, director of the Asian Research Centre for Migration (ACRM), which organised a conference on Thai workers’ problems late last week.
“This leaves room for placement agencies to take advantage of workers,” he said, referring to situations where workers can be recruited in Thailand individually by parties who charge large amounts and often end up leaving the workers deep in debt.
While this system is not unique to Thailand, some other labour-sending countries like the Philippines, the world’s largest organised exporter of labour, have put overseas employment agencies under monitoring systems.
Thailand’s labour accord with Taiwan was aimed precisely at undercutting the hefty brokerage fees, which was why officials and activists balked at the prospect of it being jeopardised by Thailand’s non-issuance of a visa to the Taiwanese official.
At present, given the highly competitive nature of the labour market for work in textile factories and on construction sites, placement agencies are prepared to bid for job contracts in Taiwan.
This leads to higher overhead costs, which recruitment agencies pass down onto workers, Sanachart said.
The problem is compounded by the fact that most Thai workers who are recruited for these jobs are illiterate and are rarely aware of their rights.
Thai workers in Taiwan are expected to pay about 180,000-200,000 baht (4,270-4,740 U.S. dollars) in fees, though all in all they should be paying around 80,000 baht (1,900 dollars).
For this reason the costs of applying to work in Israel, the third largest market for Thai labour, “are twice or triple what they should be,” Domedej Bunnak, the Thai ambassador to Israel, said.
This means fees in Israel are 100,000 to 230,000 baht (2,370-5,450 U.S. dollars) per applicant instead of just 50,000 baht (1,190 dollars). “Forcing themselves into debt is often the only way to pay the application fee costs,” he said.
However, once abroad, workers realise that they do not get paid a decent wage and receive few, if any, benefits as promised.
In Israel for example workers are paid a wage below the minimum wage, while in Taiwan it is not uncommon for employers to prolong workers’ payments for weeks — forcing many to borrow on the black market, which means a huge proportion of their wage is lost on interest payments.
“Slaves in the modern world,” is how one Israeli judge described in a court hearing the working conditions of Thai workers, said Domedej.
Because workers are unlikely to speak out or assert their rights, placement agencies and employers claim that Thai workers are satisfied with their pay and working conditions, he added.
But often, workers tend to stay on in their adopted country and look for more work to pay off their debts, and sooner or later they find they are illegal labourers, adding further to their problems.
“Problems are complicated and overlap with many different issues,” the director-general of the department of South Asian, Middle East and African affairs at the foreign ministry, Sanachart Dhebhasdin na Ayudhya, said.
Like many other labour-sending countries, Thailand is caught between competing interests in a way — its overseas workers send money home, but the government also finds itself looking for ways to reduce the risks of labour and other abuses.
Thai overseas labour brings in from Taiwan around 50 billion baht (1.1 billion U.S. dollars) a year in foreign exchange, according to the Ministry to Labour and Social Welfare.
After Taiwan, the second and third biggest markets for Thai workers are Singapore, with about 68,000 workers, and Israel with about 20,000.
“This is a problem involving the whole structure,” said Supang, adding that “what is needed is for both countries — sender and receiver — to work together”.
A failure to get bilateral talks off the ground with Taiwan has, to say the least, “not been a very good start,” added Supang.
“If workers are considered another major export from which makes the country a lot of money, the government needs to support them,” said Sanachart.
Thai workers, one among the different workers who come from countries like Indonesia and the Philippines, are also facing competition for jobs in Taiwan.
There has been a sharp increase of Vietnamese labourers on the island over in the past few years and they can work for lower wages, posing a threat to Thai labour, Supang explained. “We should rather develop workers’ skills in order to compete,” he said.
The main problem is that Thailand seems to only want to expand its market abroad, without considering the quality of that work and the benefits to the workers, said Sanachart.
But “money must not be the only factor we consider,” said Domedej, who quizzed, “how about our social investment such as the breakdown of families and providing for the physical and mental conditions of our workers?”
“Government should cooperate with local agencies to provide workers with correct information about working abroad as well as to raise awareness about their rights as workers,” he said.
The idea that working abroad will solve their financial predicament and earn them the respect of their peers also needs to be challenged, one participant at the conference said.