Saturday, November 21, 2026
Jim Lobe
- Police harassment and abuse of front-line AIDS- prevention workers in India are adding to the epidemic’s rapid advance in the world’s second most populous nation, according to a report released Tuesday by Human Rights Watch (HRW).
The Indian government’s official policies recognise the importance of reaching out to female prostitutes and men who have sex with other men as a central element in its battle against the HIV/AIDS, but such efforts are undermined by police persecution of fellow-prostitutes and gay men who provide information and condoms to the two high-risk groups, according to the 33-page report, ‘Epidemic of Abuse.’
The document was issued to coincide with this week’s XIV International AIDS Conference in Barcelona, Spain.
“The Indian government is shooting its own AIDS programme in the foot,” said Joanne Csete, director of the HRW’s HIV/AIDS programme and the report’s author. “Undermining prevention among high-risk people is a sure way to speed along the spread of AIDS among these persons and in the general population.”
In at least five states — Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka, Maharashtra, Manipur, and Tamil Nadu — the disease has already spread beyond high-risk groups into the general population, according to the report, which was based in part on the visit of a HRW delegation to India in March and April this year.
The report calls for greater government commitment to ensuring that police do not abuse or harass HIV/AIDS workers and delete from its criminal code offenses dating from 19th century imperial rule that criminalise sex between men.
Many AIDS experts have said the disease could spread rapidly, and with devastating results, in India. Officially, the number of HIV-positive people stands at about four million, already the second highest national total after South Africa, although the official infection rate stands at just below one percent of the adult population.
Most experts, however, believe that the actual number of HIV/AIDS cases in India is significantly higher; some estimate it is more than double the official figure.
The government launched a national AIDS control programme in 1987 and created a National AIDS Control Organisation (NACO) five years later. Its anti-HIV/AIDS efforts are funded largely by a 191-million-dollar World Bank loan, which also funds several state-level anti-HIV/AIDS programmes.
Almost 25 percent of the loan’s funds are used to support targeted interventions with high-risk groups, of which female prostitutes, men who have sex with men, and injecting drug users are three of the most important. Under the government’s national AIDS policy, approved just three months ago, a major strategy for reaching these groups includes “partnering with NGOs (non-governmental organisations) and CBOs (community-based organisations) that have a long history of addressing the needs of marginalised populations.”
In practice, this has meant working closely with groups with close ties to the target populations — indeed, often members of the target groups — to provide information to alert other members of the groups of the risks of practicing “unsafe sex” and the means, usually condoms, to reduce them.
The report cites several Indian organisations with a proven track record, particularly in providing help to female prostitutes. In Maharashtra State, for example, one organisation, SANGRAM, has helped distribute some 350,000 condoms per month in 12 districts in Sangli among sex workers and others at risk.
But in recent months, according to the report, police harassment and abuse of SANGRAM’s workers, as well as members of other groups working in Bangalore and Tamil Nadu, has sabotaged their efforts.
In Bangalore, for example, HIV/AIDS peer educators who worked with Samraksha, another group, were beaten severely while in detention and tried to frame them on charges of possessing narcotics and promoting prostitution.
“They are targeting peer educators; they . accuse them of spreading prostitution,” Samraksha’s director told HRW. “A policeman will say, ‘I don’t accept that a sex worker can be a peer educator’.”
In Nippani, Karnataka State, the work of SANGRAM/VAMP, which built a successful record of promoting condom use by sex workers and their clients, was effectively halted by police harassment earlier this year. When the group, which subsequently disbanded, tried to file a report against their assailants, the local police chief refused to take action, insisting that women prostitutes were not “normal citizens” with equal rights.
HIV/AIDS outreach workers who target men who have sex with men have suffered similar abuses, in part due to the criminalisation of homosexual practices under sec. 377 of the Indian Penal Code on “unnatural offenses.” Organisations that conduct AIDS education activities in Lucknow, Mumbai, Chennai, Sangli, Bangalore, and New Delhi reported serious incidents of police abuse against front-line workers.
In all of the cases, according to the report, the police also routinely extorted money or sex from their victims, knowing that sex between men constitutes such a taboo in India society that their targets would have no way to gain redress. They are also often detained for lengthy periods in jails where they are subject to further abuse.
Because male homosexuality is such a strong taboo in Indian society, according to the report, many men who are gay or bisexual get married. One survey last year of male sex workers in Mumbai (formerly Bombay) found that 43 percent of the men were married, with the result that the wives of these men were also at a high risk of becoming infected.
“The government provides condoms and sometimes money to groups doing AIDS outreach work with high-risk people and says this is a priority for AIDS prevention,” according to Ceste. “But the official statements ring hollow in the face of police violence. The big winner here is the AIDS epidemic, which will continue to kill millions unless this abuse is stopped.”