Economy & Trade, Europe, Headlines

FINANCE-EUROPE: No End in Sight to Fishy Subsidies

Greta Hopkins

BRUSSELS, Apr 26 2002 (IPS) - Spain has led a move to maintain massive subsidies for fishermen within the European Union (EU), activists say.

The European Commission had in a draft proposal recommended an end to the subsidies of more than one billion dollars a year for EU fishermen. But its plans, which were last due to be made public on April 17 have been held up twice. It now seems unlikely that they will be tabled before the end of May.

Reports in the Spanish press allege that the proposals were withdrawn after Spanish Prime Minister Jose Maria Aznar spoke to the president of the European Commission Romano Prodi.

“It is clear that Aznar did ring Prodi, and that the proposals were withdrawn,” says Julian Scola from the World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF). “This makes it very difficult for the policy to be reviewed by the end of the year.”

Tony Long, director of (WWF) European policy office in Brussels says the WWF fears that the Commission is coming under intense pressure to water down the proposals to meet the short-term interests of at least one member state.

The WWF warns that fish stocks will collapse if the EU does not urgently implement a new common fisheries policy.

One of the key proposals in the European Commission’s draft proposal is an end to public aid for modernising or building new fishing boats. The WWF says the European Union has allocated 585 million dollars just for decommissioning boats and 754 million dollars for modernising or building new boats.

“The WWF suspects improper and unwarranted influence behind closed doors,” says Long. “I challenge the Commission to have the courage to publish robust and independent proposals untainted by narrow, short-term interests.”

The European Commission had concluded after wide consultations last year that an overhaul of current practice is long overdue. EU leaders agreed at a summit in Sweden that “the review of the common fisheries policy in 2002 should, on the basis of a broad political debate, address the overall fishing pressure by adapting the EU fishing effort to the level of available resources.”

EU Fisheries Commissioner Franz Fischler wants subsidies to be used instead to help fishermen find alternative employment. He wants improved surveillance to prevent illegal fishing, and uniform penalties to be applied to all EU members.

“We have never been so efficient at catching fish, but now we are overexploiting our oceans,” Fischler says. “Species like cod and hake have been subjected to so much fishing that stocks are near to collapse,” Fischler said in a recent letter to the industry.

He said “we have to face up to the fact that cutting fleet overcapacity will mean some contraction of the industry, and job losses.”

The draft policy paper on the reform of the common fisheries policy, obtained by IPS, warns that if current trends continue fish stocks will collapse.

“At the same time, the fishing capacity of the Community fleets far exceeds that required to harvest the available fishery resources in a sustainable manner,” the draft document says. As remedy the paper proposes cutting the EU fishing fleet by 40 per cent, and introducing fishing quotas from January next year.

The WWF and other campaigning groups like Greenpeace and BirdLife oppose EU subsidies which are leading to unsustainable fishing in European waters and also to fishing off the coast of developing countries.

“One result of over-fishing in EU waters has been for fishermen to fish further and further from home,” says Dr Simon Cripps, Director of WWF’s endangered seas programme. “The EU now has fishing agreements with over 20 countries, many of them developing nations in Africa. And for fishing outside EU waters, the EU pays even more taxpayer subsidies – giving EU fishing fleets an unfair advantage over local industry.”

In direct contradiction of its development policies, the EU is “actually taking a food and economic resource away from developing countries,” Cripps says.

The draft reform plan proposes a policy dialogue with developing countries, particularly those which have concluded fisheries agreements with the EU. The purpose of such a dialogue it says would be to “gradually improve their capacity to achieve sustainable fisheries while contributing to their development objectives.”

The document proposes that in the future “the Community’s actions shall aim to promote and strengthen international co-operation and ensure sustainable and responsible fisheries outside Community waters and with the same commitments as in its own waters.”

But Scola is concerned that the draft proposal does not include any legally binding measures to give poor countries a better deal. “Some of the words are well and good, and have the potential to have a positive impact if they are implemented,” he says. “But they are only non-binding action plans and strategies.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags