Europe, Headlines

IRELAND-RELIGION: From Scandal to Scandal

Sarah O'Hara

DUBLIN, Nov 10 1995 (IPS) - If God had wanted the Irish to become less orthodox in their faith, then the traumatic series of sex scandals now rocking the Catholic Church could be seen as part of some divine plan.

Three years ago, the worst that had happened to the Church — into which 92 percent of the Irish are born — was the news that a popular and ebullient bishop had fathered a love child 19 years before.

It emerged over the following weeks that Bishop Eamonn Casey, who fled the country the day before the story broke, had treated mother and son coldly, and had secretly obtained the six-figure sum he used as maintenance money from parish funds.

In a book published in 1993, Gemma Hussey wrote: “Nothing that has happened to the (Catholic) Church in Ireland could compare with the trauma of the Bishop Casey affair in May 1992” (Ireland Today: Anatomy of a Changing State).

Little did she know.

No cleric in their wildest nightmares could have imagined the spate of revelations about the private lives of priests and bishops which have emerged since then, in the most orthodox Catholic community in the Western world.

Over the past two years, scandals seem to have become the order of the day.

An elderly priest died watching pornographic movies in a gay night club. A priest assaulted a teenage male hitch-hiker. A trendy media priest secretly fathered two children with his housekeeper. And many other priests have been accused of sexually abusing children entrusted to their care.

At least 10 Irish priests are facing charges of child sexual abuse.

When informed of a potential problem, the Catholic Church has “solved” the problem by moving the abusive priest from parish to parish. In some instances, these priests merely abused more children.

One particular bishop – perhaps the most respected in the country after Bishop Casey – is now in an alcoholism clinic in Florida.

“The Church should not have been as slow to see the seriousness (of the crisis), to see the hurt and repent properly,” Fr Colm Kilcoyne, a newspaper columnist and parish priest (in Cong, Co Mayo) told IPS.

The stories have taken their toll on the Catholic Church as an institution. Five years ago, over 80 percent of Irish Catholics went to mass on Sundays.

Now the latest poll, published in the Sunday Independent last week (Nov. 5), shows that only 64 percent attend Mass every week. This is a drop of a third over the past 20 years – down from 91 per cent in 1974.

“The scandals are horrendous,” says Kilcoyne. “The level of them would have taken most people, including priests, by surprise. Most of us would have said the ‘tiny minority’ thing but it seems to go on and on.”

The behaviour of the Catholic hierarchy in moving priests from one parish to another in order to cover up scandal was the second shock for Fr Kilcoyne. His views would be part of the mainstream of Irish priests.

The priest feels that there would have been “some excuse” for ignorance on the scale and gravity of child sexual abuse 15 years ago, but not now. “The research was available and anybody who wanted to know would have known that the solution was not to move people around,” says Kilcoyne.

“We put priests on a pedestal, and we’re suffering for it now,” says one lay Catholic.

Margot Davis, editor of Modern Woman, a provincial monthly newspaper for women, is one of the Catholics who has stopped attending Mass every week. Now she just goes “the odd time”.

“Most of the time, I come out of Mass disgusted. They’re not bringing the Bible into today’s way of thinking. If they could do that, we would perhaps enjoy it.

“If they’d only come down and talk to us as friends, there would be a hell of a lot of people coming to mass and enjoying it,” says Davis, who was brought up in a strict Catholic family in the 1940s.

“My mother used to say, ‘If you ever cross (pass) a priest on the street, step off the path because he might be carrying the Host (the Communion Host)’.

“And then if you met the Bishop, you had to kneel down and kiss the Bishop’s ring. Little things like that. No matter how contrary or awkward the priest, you had to put up with (tolerate) them. You had to go to confession and tell them everything.”

Religious affairs correspondent for The Irish Times, Andy Pollak, observes an undermining of the authority of the Catholic Church, rather than an erosion of values.

“The vast majority of people are still strongly Christian,” Pollak says. “They still believe in God. But the moral authority is being undermined by these scandals. Not the faith but the moral authority of the Church as the moral leaders (of the people).”

Kilcoyne says: “I think Irish Catholics have a good sense of God, with living their faith no matter what people like us (the priests) say or do. I think there is an independence in it. Of course, there are a number of people who are shocked to the point where they’ve walked away (from their faith).”

Both Kilcoyne and Pollak say that the scandals have speeded up a secularising tendency in Irish society that would have occurred anyway.

“It’s a cliche to say that (Irish) society is moving from the culture of authority to the culture of experience,” says Kilcoyne. “We don’t mould our lives according to what authority says, we listen to the authorities but it carries no particular weight.”

Recently, Catholics had an opportunity to show their dissatisfaction on a live TV show. Their spiritual leader, Cardinal Cathal Daly, the Primate of All Ireland, made a surprise appearance on The Late Late Show last weekend.

Says Pollak: “The cardinal came under siege from the audience, many of whom were devout Catholics. For the first time they got up shouting at this traditionally unquestioned leader, unquestioned and unquestionable. He was there, like anybody else, on a TV panel, being questioned.”

The demand for accountability is a relatively new one for the Irish Catholic Church. “It has never been accountable to anyone except to the Pope and to God,” Pollak told IPS.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags