Sunday, November 22, 2026
Jim Lobe
- Despite significant improvements in civil liberties since Nigeria’s transition from military to civilian rule four years ago, the basic right to freedom of expression is still not guaranteed, says a new report by Human Rights Watch (HRW).
The 40-page document, ‘Nigeria: Renewed Crackdown on Freedom of Expression’, details killings, arrests, detentions, ill-treatment, torture and other forms of harassment against suspected critics of both state and federal governments, the worst of which took place last July during protests against the rising price of fuel.
Between 12 and 20 people were shot dead in Lagos, Port Harcourt and on the outskirts of the national capital Abuja simply for demonstrating against the price increases, says the report, released as Commonwealth heads of government gather in the capital this week for their annual summit.
”Commonwealth leaders meeting in Abuja should not give Nigeria a free pass on human rights,” said Peter Takirambudde, HRW’s Africa director. ”Even though military rule has ended, Nigerians still cannot express themselves freely without fear of grave consequences,” he added in a statement.
Takirambudde said foreign leaders, including U.S. and British officials, have been reluctant to denounce Nigerian abuses as well as political violence that preceded last spring’s elections, since the country’s return to civilian rule.
Nigeria is a key oil exporter and has also provided thousands of troops for regional peacekeeping operations to which western nations have been reluctant to contribute.
Mugabe, who has cracked down hard on the independent press and opposition forces over the past year, was not invited to this week’s meeting.
The government of Nigerian President Olusegun Obasanjo, who has tried to coax Mugabe into a political transition, decided against inviting him both because of his most recent attacks on the press and because other key Commonwealth leaders, notably Queen Elizabeth and the prime ministers of Australia, New Zealand and Canada, vowed to boycott if Mugabe showed up.
But while many observers see Mugabe’s repression as one of the greatest threats to basic civil and political freedoms in Africa, Nigeria should also be of concern, argues the HRW report, stressing that abuses of the right to freedom of expression have increased steadily since mid-2002.
As Africa’s most populous nation, Nigeria has long been seen as critical in determining the future direction of the continent. With the return of civilian rule after the brutal reign of the late General Sani Abacha, much of the region and the international community hoped Abuja would become a model for democratic governance.
While conditions are clearly vastly better than they were under Abacha, according to HRW, which praised the robust debate in the country’s thriving press during the election campaign, abusive and repressive practices have continued.
The main perpetrators, says the report, include members of the Nigerian police force, acting in some cases on direct instructions from senior officials, and the intelligence services, known collectively as the State Security Service (SSS).
The victims have included journalists, human rights activists, supporters of opposition political parties and other political activists, as well as peaceful demonstrators, as in the petrol-price protests last summer.
While activists and government critics have always faced a measure of harassment in Nigeria, the report – which includes testimonies of individuals detained by the government – found that, if anything, leaders have become increasingly intolerant of criticism, particularly in the run-up to elections earlier this year when Obasanjo was re-elected.
The report details harassment of opposition party activists and supporters during the elections campaign, which was itself marred by political violence, and widespread fraud and ballot-rigging, according to both HRW and election observers.
Members of organisations that have called for autonomy for the Yoruba or Igbo ethnic groups were often subject to illegal arrests and detentions, both during the campaign and since, adds the report.
Rights activists and journalists have borne the brunt of the harassment, as police have attempted to exercise censorship and, in several cases, physically assaulted several journalists.
On Nov. 21, for example, Psaro Yornamue, chief of the Rivers State bureau for the ‘Daily Independent’ newspaper, was beaten and threatened in connection with an article he wrote alleging corruption by the state’s deputy governor.
Also last month, police disrupted public parades organised by Ogoni activists to commemorate the 1995 execution by the Abacha government of the ethnic group’s leader and world-renowned writer and environmentalist, Kenneth Saro-Wiwa, and eight other Ogoni activists.
Also in October, Ogoni activists were harassed and threatened, and in one case in the oil port of Bonny, 17 of them were arrested and allegedly beaten by police.
In July, some 30 people were arrested after staging a peaceful protest outside the U.S. embassy in Abuja against a visit by U.S. President George W. Bush.
The report, which includes testimonies of some of those who were arrested, said the 30 were detained for two weeks, and several were tortured on what HRW believes were direct instructions from the highest levels in the police.
HRW said Nigeria’s foreign supporters need to be more outspoken about abuses there lest they be accused of double standards.
”Foreign governments remained virtually silent about election violence in Nigeria, yet abuses during the Zimbabwe elections provoked widespread condemnation,” Takirambudde said.
”Unless the Commonwealth addresses abuses in all its member countries and denounces them accordingly, it will stand accused of maintaining double standards, and its credibility will be undermined.”