Economy & Trade, Headlines, Labour, North America

LABOUR: Plight of Domestic Workers Wins Congressional Ear

Abid Aslam

WASHINGTON, Feb 16 2000 (IPS) - U.S. lawmakers, citing the exploitation of domestic workers by diplomats and international officials, are pushing legislation to police a community long considered above the law.

Provisions of a proposed “Trafficking Victims Protection Act” would grant legal aid and social services to migrant servants and shield them from deportation if they leave and sue their abusive employers.

Under current law, run-away servants risk deportation because their U.S. visas were sponsored by their employers, namely diplomats and officials from international institutions including the United Nations, the World Bank and Inter-American Development Bank, the International Monetary Fund (IMF), and the Organisation of American States (OAS).

In the absence of legal protection, servants fleeing their employers must gamble on the charity or inefficiency of an overworked immigration bureaucracy. For their part, employers legally are required to honour U.S. labour laws but duck punishment by invoking diplomatic immunity or transferring to posts overseas.

The U.S. State Department issues some 4,000 visas per year for migrant servants, most of whom end up in the Washington area, according to Martha Honey, director of the Peace and Security Programme at the Institute for Policy Studies here and a member of the Campaign for Migrant Domestic Workers Rights, a coalition set up two years ago.

Almost all of the exploited servants are women and they “come here with both dreams and obligations: Dreams of bettering their lot in life and obligations to send money home to support their families,” Honey says. “Sadly, many have ended up living their worst nightmares.”

For Juana Condori, a soft-spoken 32-year-old with a child’s demeanour, the dream had simply been to travel in an airplane. At the end of her journey from Bolivia, Condori says she was forced to work more than 12 hours per day in return for an hourly wage of less than one dollar.

She tells of being raped by a friend of the family and turning for help to her employer – a human rights attorney at the OAS – who refused to take her to a doctor or assist in any other way.

“I have suffered more abuse than I have been able to explain,” she says through an interpreter.

Condori is among women to have escaped what they call modern- day slavery in the homes of foreign officials here. She briefed legislators and reporters at the U.S. Capitol Tuesday as other former housekeepers wept in silence.

Dora Mortey, a 28-year-old Ghanaian woman, says she was brought here last May by World Bank official Amarquaye Armar and made to work longer hours for less pay than agreed. She reports being denied adequate food, and says that “my clothes were washed with the rags used to clean bathrooms and floors.”

“I didn’t leave behind a teaching job in Ghana to come to America to be treated like a dog or a slave,” Mortey says.

Many employers – including Mortey’s – deny their servants’ accusations but Xiomara Salgado, a psychotherapist and nine-year veteran of a county government agency charged with helping victims of sexual assault, says she sees cases that are all too real.

“There is no ‘exploited domestic worker syndrome’ that we know of but the symptoms and reactions these workers experience are similar to those of prisoners of war and victims of domestic violence,” according to Salgado.

The troubles include “recurrent and intrusive thoughts and images of the traumatic experience, nightmares, flashback episodes, intense psychological distress, insomnia, and hyper-vigilance,” she adds. Yet, “it is common for these domestic workers to experience self-blaming and guilt in the beginning. (Then) they are afraid of speaking out, of being further abused, of being sent back to their countries, or of being deported.”

Placing their trust in strangers is no mean feat for women who have been betrayed by employers who are their compatriots and – in some cases – by their own parents, who arranged the jobs overseas, Salgado explains.

Mark Poletunow, a Franciscan friar who heads the Spanish Catholic Centre, concedes that the workers’ advocates themselves have not done a good job of documenting the problem.

Nevertheless, he estimates that “over the years we have handled at least one thousand cases” – or about 30 per year since the centre was established in 1967.

Emissaries of foreign governments will resist attempts to regulate their behaviour, says Washington lawyer Peter Flanagan, but “diplomatic immunity was never intended to operate as a free pass for abusive employers.”

What’s more, immunity as applied to international civil servants – including UN, IMF and World Bank officials – covers only functions performed in their official capacity. “It would be difficult to argue that the retention or abuse of a domestic worker is conduct pursuant to the official capacity of an international civil servant,” he asserts.

The proposed anti-trafficking legislation has been approved by the International Relations Committee of the U.S. House of Representatives and has been referred to the lower house’s Judiciary Committee. Similar legislation has been introduced in the U.S. Senate.

Whatever the bills’ eventual fate, the cause of protecting migrant servants has made allies out of people whose positions on other issues would appear to pit them against each other.

The House bill was co-authored by Rep. Sam Gejdenson, a Connecticut Democrat, and Rep. Chris Smith, a New Jersey Republican.

In other times, some of the groups arrayed in support of the domestic workers might have chided Gejdenson for promoting what they call “corporate welfare” by writing laws providing government subsidies for everything from market research to export credit for domestic firms eyeing overseas sales.

Smith, who decries the lack of medical attention following Condori’s rape, is better known to women’s rights advocates as a former executive director of the Christian fundamentalist Right to Life Committee in his home state. He has repeatedly blocked domestic programmes, foreign aid packages and dues payments to the United Nations on the grounds that some of the money would go to family planning and reproductive health services.

Whatever their stripe, Elizabeth Iguago is clear what she wants from the legislators.

The Ecuadorian beautician says she was lured here by an IMF official only to be “loaned out like an object” to a U.S. couple who overworked and underpaid her.

“I am seeking justice from this Congress to take the necessary steps to stop these abuses,” Iguago says. “This country is said to be the land of the free, but unfortunately we find that more abuses are committed here than in our countries.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags