Thursday, November 19, 2026
Kanis Dursin
- Hard pressed to put a stop to the proliferation of institutions issuing fraudulent academic degrees, Indonesia’s Ministry of Education has taken to a mass media campaign aimed at discouraging people from buying diplomas instead of earning these.
But many seem to be ignoring the ministry’s call and are falling in line to snap up the instant “degrees”.
“They need diplomas to occupy certain positions or get promotions in government and private offices, that is why they resort to buying diplomas,” says Joetata Hadihardaja, director for Private Higher Learning Institutions of the Ministry of Education, referring to those who are getting diplomas from “dubious” institutions.
Observers add that high tuition and tedious classroom lectures are also fuelling the trend.
The education ministry estimates that at present, more than 30,000 Indonesians are holding either master’s or doctorate degrees issued by institutions claiming to represent some European, U.S., Australian and Asian universities and higher learning institutions.
It has identified at least 11 unrecognised learning institutions operating in Jakarta. According to the ministry, these also have branch offices spread throughout the country.
These questionable institutions, which operate without government permits, sell academic certificates for as low as one million rupiahs or 135 dollars and as high as 30 million rupiahs or 4,300 dollars, depending on the buyers’ economic background.
Some institutions offer master in business administration (MBA) certificates to participants of seminars they organise, so long as the participants pay the administration fee of 500,000 rupiahs (70 dollars).
In fact, only state-owned and government-accredited learning institutions are authorised to issue diplomas and academic titles. There are currently 1,538 higher learning institutions, which include academies and polytechnics, accredited by the government to issue academic titles.
Also, under Indonesia’s educational system, a master’s degree is obtained at least after completing a two-to-three-year post graduate study and a thesis defence, while a doctorate degree requires another one to two years of class lectures and several years of field research and a dissertation defence.
But the education ministry says it finds it difficult to stop the institutions issuing “no sweat” degrees because the National Education Law No.2-1989 endorses only administrative sanctions, ranging from warning to closing down, for institutions illegally issuing academic titles.
Joetata argues, “We could close down the institutions, but the people involved are still going around selling diplomas, while the police (cannot) do anything because people have filed no complaint against those institutions.”
In truth, recipients of fake diplomas are proud of their high- sounding academic titles and sport them in front of their names. Observers say these diploma buyers include not only low-level civil servants and private sector employees, but also high-ranking government officials, military officers and even university lecturers.
Education officials and experts worry that the “diploma trade” would only deteriorate further the quality of education in Indonesia. Says Joetata, “The people will not like to study anymore because they can get the diplomas and academic titles at a cheaper and easier way as they are no longer required to attend classes and do research for their master’s or doctorate titles.”
Mohammad Mahfud of the Islamic University of Indonesia sees the situation this way: “Awarding academic degrees through a very simple process is fooling and cheating people.” He adds: “Those achieving instant academic degrees must not obtain good positions in their offices. Such people have the potential to be corrupt.”
The practice is actually not new. But it began gaining momentum in the 1990s when Indonesia’s economy recorded robust growth and demand for skilled human resources was high. MBA holders became millionaires overnight, resulting in Indonesians racing for tertiary education certificates.
When Indonesia’s economy crashed after the start of the Asian financial crisis in 1997, people became all the more desperate to have more bargaining power in the workplace.
To curb the practice of selling academic degrees, the Ministry of Education is calling for the amendment of Education Law No.2-1989 that will punish not only the institutions involved in the illegal trade, but also the buyers themselves.
But since changing the law can take a while, the ministry has been doing the rounds in television talk shows, placing newspaper announcements, and sending lists of the illegal institutions to companies. It says though that it is still up to the firms whether or not to hire people holding spurious diplomas.
The Indonesian Consumers Foundation (YLKI), however, believes that the government is doing nothing to stop the flourishing trade of academic degrees. YLKI managing chairperson Indah Sukmaningsih also says, “If the trade of academic diplomas is not handled properly, the quality of our human resources will be easily overrun in tight competition in the new global era.”
Some institutions identified by the education ministry as “selling” diplomas have denied that they are engaged in the practice. One of these, Yayasan Global Indonesia (YGI), says it is merely acting as brokers for foreign universities and learning institutions, which issue the academic degrees to Indonesian students.
YGI director Mardiyana, MBA, Ph.D, says, “We are not the ones issuing the diplomas, but our foreign counterparts.”
The YGI, which was set up in 1999, says it offers master’s and doctorate degrees in cooperation with the United States’ American World University (AWU), American Global University (AGU), American Institute of Management Studies (AIMS), Canada’s Senior University and Philippines’ San Pedro College of Business Administration.
Indonesian law prohibits foreign universities or learning institutions from setting up branches in the country. But they can have tie-ups with accredited universities and academic institutions and establish joint-venture operations so long as they adopt Indonesia’s educational system.
At YGI, students can have master’s degrees within a year with a relatively cheap fee of four million rupiahs (570 dollars), while those seeking doctorate degrees can get one within two years, including one year of classroom lectures for six million rupiahs (890 dollars).
Reputable private universities charge about 3,000 U.S. dollars for a two-year master’s degree programme while doctorate studies cost more than 3,000 dollars.
“We are trying to provide cheap, short and equal education to all,” Mardiyana says. The trouble, he says, is that Indonesians are used to thinking that education, especially postgraduate studies, requires a huge amount of money and takes a long time. He says YGI holds classes every Tuesday, Thursday and Saturday from 9 a.m. to 6 p.m.