Friday, November 20, 2026
Jim Lobe
- As corporate executives and trade ministers from all over the Americas gather this week in Belo Horizonte, the big question must be whether and how hard U.S. President Bill Clinton will fight for expanding free-trade agreements in the hemisphere.
It was, after all, Clinton who hosted the Dec. 1994 Miami Summit of the Americas, which committed all of the region’s countries, except Cuba, to negotiating a Free Trade Area of the Americas (FTAA) by the year 2005.
But, despite repeated declarations by top U.S. officials — including Clinton himself — that Washington remains committed to the FTAA, his administration is sounding a very uncertain trumpet on Capitol Hill, where the quest must begin.
The administration has yet to formally submit “fast-track” legislation that would give it authority to negotiate new trade accords, including expansion of the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) to include Chile.
With tens of millions of dollars at stake in new sales and investments, U.S. companies are becoming increasingly agitated about the administration’s passivity, particularly in light of the steady growth of the Brazilian-led Mercosur trade bloc that includes Argentina, Paraguay, Uruguay, and associate members Bolivia and Chile.
Some U.S. firms, such as heavy equipment giant Caterpillar Inc., are already moving production from the United States to Brazil to avoid Chilean tariffs on U.S.-made exports. “Chilean buyers don’t pay duty on our kinds of products from Brazil, but there is a duty when they’re made in the United States,” a senior Caterpillar official told the ‘Journal of Commerce’ this week.
The business press is keeping up a steady drumbeat of pressure on the administration to move quickly, warning that thousands of U.S. jobs are at stake, not to mention the sales opportunities in a region where U.S. exports grew 275 percent between 1990 and 1996.
The United States can only benefit from expanding free trade in the Americas, according to these forces, particularly given the fact that U.S. tariffs currently average only about three percent. South American tariffs, by contrast, come in at about 12 percent.
“As the world’s largest exporter, the U.S. can’t afford to sit on the sidelines in the free-trade game,” noted a recent ‘Business Week’ column entitled, ‘Beyond NAFTA: Why Washington Mustn’t Stop Now.’
Clinton himself seems to agree with this argument. In a major policy address last month in which he promised to fight for the FTAA, he noted ruefully that in 1996, “for the first time ever, Latin American nations had more trade with Europe than the United States.”
“There is no reason to think that others will wait while we sit idle,” he said. “We dare not let this opportunity pass by.”
But the administration is going slow, largely because of domestic political reasons. These include concern over deepening an already serious split over trade within Clinton’s own Democratic Party as well as the widespread unpopularity of NAFTA reflected in recent public-opinion surveys.
One poll released this month by the Wall Street Journal and NBC News found that 42 percent of respondents believe NAFTA has had a negative impact on the United States, compared with only 28 percent who believe the 1994 accord was positive.
The result is that the administration appears to have given up the idea of adding Chile to NAFTA. Noting that trade officials from Washington and Santiago met last week in Montreal, Deputy U.S. Trade Representative Jeffrey Lang said Tuesday that he was “not so sure about the expansion of NAFTA.”
“Our competitors would like nothing better than for us to sideline ourselves, debating NAFTA and our relationship with Mexico for several more years while they move ahead,” Charlene Barshefsky, Clinton’s Trade Representative, told a Senate committee recently.
“NAFTA expansion looks dead,” says Jim Berger, editor of the ‘Washington Trade Daily’ and a veteran observer of the U.S. trade policy. “It’s clear that the administration will go for a bilateral agreement with Chile instead.”
With NAFTA fading from the picture, the question is whether the administration can get its trade agenda back on track, beginning with a bilateral accord with Chile. Last month, Barshefsky described an agreement with Santiago as the “first step” in the process that would lead not only to the FTAA by 2005, but also to “concrete progress by the year 2000.”
An agreement with Chile “is a litmus test with respect to U.S. intentions in our own neighbourhood,” she said.
First, however, Clinton must get Congress to approve fast-track authority — a prospect which remains uncertain.
In addition to NAFTA’s unpopularity, Clinton finds himself caught not only between competing factions of his own party, but also between Republicans who favour fast-track authority which is unencumbered by provisions designed to protect the environment and workers’ rights, and Democrats who insist that including such provisions is the only way they will vote for “fast track.”
While some Republicans, including House of Representatives Speaker Newt Gingrich, have hinted at a compromise, others, such as the powerful and ambitious chairman of the Senate Commerce Committee, John McCain, seem to be spoiling for a fight. On Monday, he said any fast-track bill that included labour and the environment would be a “non-starter” for Republicans in Congress.
Whatever form fast-track authority eventually takes, say trade experts, time is running out. The consensus appears to be that Clinton must have fast-track authority in hand by October when he visits Venezuela, Brazil, and Argentina in his first trip to South America. Without it, “Clinton will basically look like he doesn’t give a damn,” said one U.S. trade official.
In any event, the absolute deadline for gaining fast-track authority is next March when the hemisphere’s leaders convene once again in Santiago. “For the president to go to Santiago without fast track would be a devastating loss of credibility,” Richard Feinberg, one of the architects of the Miami Summit, told a recent press gathering.
Feinberg, who believes the FTAA should be open only to democratic governments in the hemisphere, wants its timetable to be moved up by five years to 2000, a suggestion which was rejected last week by a senior administration official as unrealistic.