Friday, November 20, 2026
Abid Aslam
- The International Monetary Fund (IMF) is off to a shaky start with its latest bid to forestall financial crises in member countries.
The IMF’s ‘Contingency Credit Line’, launched late last month, is intended to provide billions of dollars in fast-flowing emergency loans to prevent speculative attacks on countries with Fund-approved economic policies.
This follows the failure of more than 100 billion dollars in international bail outs over the past 21 months to limit the spread and severity of global financial turmoil.
Trouble is the new scheme is “the same kind of club that (comedian) Groucho Marx talked about: The kind you wouldn’t want to join if it would have you as a member,” says Santiago Millan, Latin America economist at IDEA Inc. in New York.
“Just asking for the money signals to the market that you’re in trouble because, to be eligible, you would normally not need to have IMF assistance,” he says.
Latin American countries, who fell prey to investor panic after Russia defaulted on some of its foreign debts last August, have been expected to line up for the emergency loans. Other countries that could qualify include India, Israel, the Philippines and South Africa, say officials and analysts.
Response, however, has been decidedly mixed.
Mexico has rejected the idea, Argentina says it is “sort of” considering it and, when Peru announced last week that it had qualified for 4.5 billion dollars from the credit line, the IMF issued a statement saying that the claim was premature.
The confusion stems from preconditions for using the credit line that remain vague and subject to manipulation, financial analysts say.
Applicants must have Fund-approved economic policies and must not yet be facing balance-of-payments difficulties related to financial contagion. They must adhere to international standards on publishing timely economic data and bank supervision, and must enjoy good relations with private creditors.
The IMF has had another emergency programme in place since December 1997 but the ‘Supplementary Reserve Facility’, as it is called, only provides cash to countries already in the throes of crisis.
Fund officials now hope that access to the Contingency Credit Line will shield a country from speculative attack in the first place; the money would actually be released only if trouble struck.
Critics, including some European and developing-country officials, warn that the scheme could backfire. Because it implicitly guarantees repayment, they say, it actually could encourage excessive private lending and speculative investment in risky countries.
What’s more, the credit line will increase IMF leverage over borrowers, according to the London-based Bretton Woods Project.
“Countries will face pressure to qualify for the facility in order to signal their creditworthiness to investors,” the non- governmental organisation notes. “This will have the effect of extending the IMF’s policy influence into more middle-income countries even if they do not draw on the fund.”
According to IMF First Deputy Managing Director Stanley Fischer, however, the credit line “will encourage good behaviour” and help convince investors “that the country is meeting high standards of economic performance.”
Finance officials have complained that governments in a position to qualify for the money probably wouldn’t need it while those in need probably wouldn’t qualify.
Misgivings also remain about the cost of the emergency credits. The IMF would charge borrowers 7-8 percent, compared to its normal charges of 4-5 percent. Loans would be disbursed within one year and repayments would be expected within 18 months, with a one-year extension possible in extreme cases.
Mexican Finance Minister Jose Angel Gurria has assailed the scheme’s preconditions, saying these bar countries, including his, already using IMF loans to offset crises not of their own making.
Mexico has seven billion dollars in debt falling due to the Fund in the next 18 months and is negotiating a new stand-by loan. This would take longer to pay off and involve more onerous conditions than the new credit line, which it might have tapped for up to 17.5 billion dollars, says a London-based financial analyst.
Argentina, which could access a credit line of up to 14.3 billion dollars, is “sort of thinking about it still,” according to Treasury Secretary Pablo Guidotti. For now, the country enjoys sufficient access to private capital markets for its borrowing needs of 16 billion dollars this year to offset a slump in exports to Brazil, its main trading partner.
Peruvian President Alberto Fujimori is weighing a possible re- election bid next April. His popularity hinges on the economy and his government, seeking to roll over an existing IMF loan, last week said it qualified for a credit line.
“The IMF was quick to recant the government’s claim because of fears that they would use it to loosen policy at a time when it already looks like they’ll miss a number of targets (agreed with the Fund),” says Millan.
Chile, which has expressed no interest yet in obtaining a credit line, also is being mentioned as a possible customer. The country is considered to have sound macroeconomic policies but remains vulnerable to weakness in commodity markets.
IMF officials have hinted that they would look sympathetically on a country under attack from commodity price pressure but observers question the credit scheme’s suitability, noting that it is aimed at short-term shocks and that weak commodity prices remain a long-term problem.