Asia-Pacific, Headlines

MEDIA-MALAYSIA: New Alternative Paper Widens News Menu

Anil Netto

PENANG, Malaysia, Oct 2 2000 (IPS) - Every evening, a few young Malaysians huddle in a second-floor room in a suburb of this northern city, working feverishly on the country’s first independent Chinese-language newspaper on the Internet

Their work on ‘Mytianwang’ aims to sidestep the country’s tight controls on the print media — even while established media firms consolidate their Internet editions.

Work on the alternative newspaper began in October last year, about a month before a general election that saw a resurgent opposition eating into the political dominance of the ruling coalition led by Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad.

Some half a dozen Chinese Malaysians — a reporter, fresh graduates and university students majoring in management and mass communication — started discussing how they could come up with alternative news for Chinese-speaking Malaysians.

Initially, they planned to come up with a print magazine in Mandarin.

But they also saw the rise of cyberspace as an alternative source of news as more Malaysians shunned the jaded mainstream newspapers, in the aftermath of the protest movement spurred by the ouster of former deputy prime minister Anwar Ibrahim.

Thus, the group decided to give the Internet surfers what they were looking for: a cyber newspaper providing independent news in Chinese.

‘Mytianwang’ aims to emulate the highly successful Internet newspaper in English, Malaysiakini.com (Malaysia Now), which was launched in November.

Some 1.9 million Malaysians out of a population of 23 million surf the Internet. Out of that, Malaysiakini draws more than 100,000 visitors a day with its daily diet of independent political news and biting commentaries written by youthful columnists.

But the Chinese-speaking surfers have been left out. About a third of Malaysia’s population is ethnic Chinese, though not all of them are Chinese-educated. Still, the Chinese-speaking population is significant enough to translate into a huge potential market for a Chinese-language cyber newspaper like ‘Mytianwang’.

The ‘My’ in ‘Mytianwang’ is an abbreviation for Malaysia and ‘tianwang’ is Mandarin for the Internet. According to Ng Tien Eng, 31, one of the project leaders, ‘tianwang’ can also mean a ‘net’ falling from above to trap and punish wrongdoers.

He expects the site at http//www.mytianwang.com- to be ready for its soft launch and test run in mid-October.

“There’s no independent Chinese-language e-news in Malaysia,” points out the soft-spoken Ng, who studied business management and graduated with a master’s degree in political science. For a year, Ng worked as a management accountant before joining a consumer rights group as research officer for its rural section.

Now he holds frequent meetings with the ‘Mytianwang’ team. The team includes two staffers, including the editor, 25-year-old Ong Ooi Heng, a fresh-faced mass communications graduate. They are now on the lookout for two other staff, including a Kuala Lumpur-based reporter.

‘Mytianwang’ will not have an easy task ahead, taking on the established Chinese print media giants in Malaysia: ‘Sin Chew Jit Poh’, ‘China Press’ and ‘Nanyang Siang Pau’.

Hardly anyone in Ng’s team has any hands-on experience in journalism, but they say what they lack in experience and hard in determination, enthusiasm and y Ng concedes that unlike the tightly controlled mainstream Malay- language and English-language newspapers in Malaysia, the mainstream Chinese-language press is relatively freer. “So the desire for alternative news is not so high” among Chinese- speaking Malaysians, says Ng.

But even so, the Chinese media’s freedom is a limited one, hemmed in by parameters they dare not go beyond. For instance, “they are reluctant to criticise Mahathir,” says Ng, and “they dare not criticise (Mahathir’s) capital controls.”

This caution is partly due to Malaysia’s Printing Presses and Publications Act. Under this law, the home minister has the final say on revoking a publication permit from any publisher. His decision cannot be challenged in court.

The Internet, which Mahathir has vowed not to censor in a bid to draw software investors to his Multimedia Super Corridor project, therefore offers safer refuge with hardly any curbs.

So enter ‘Mytianwang’, which Ng says will focus on politics, the economy, human rights, social issues, development woes, environmental problems and Chinese education.

“They may have potential,” media analyst Mustafa Anuar says of ‘Mytianwang’. “I suspect that it’s the first of its kind in Malaysia and it will certainly add to the variety of sources of information for the Chinese-speaking audience.”

“It will be good for young Chinese readers to get alternative views on various issues facing the country,” he adds.

That could spell trouble for the ruling coalition, which maintained its hold on government in the November 1999 election, despite inroads by the opposition, on the back of fairly solid ethnic Chinese support.

When the reformasi movement first erupted in September 1998 following Anwar’s ouster following a rift with Mahathir, many political critics argued that majority of the Malaysian Chinese were content to remain as spectators on the sidelines.

That perception, however, may well change if more and more Chinese are exposed to critical, alternative views.

For now, the biggest problem for Ng’s resource-strapped group has been raising funds. Ng figures they will need at least 150,000 ringgit (40,000 U.S. dollars) to keep afloat for the first two years. So far, they have raised just 40,000 ringgit (10,670 dollars) from 10 individuals in Penang.

They have already spent 10,000 ringgit (2,670 dollars) to buy two personal computers, a facsimile machine, a printer and two digital cameras. That doesn’t leave much for daily operating expenses.

The people behind ‘Mytianwang’ hope to raise more funds in the capital Kuala Lumpur and in southern Johor state. No point going to the banks or other financial institutions for loans, says Ng: “We don’t have anything to offer as security.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags