Asia-Pacific, Headlines

MEDIA-MALAYSIA: Alternative Press Gets Warnings

Anil Netto

PENANG, Malaysia, Jan 10 2000 (IPS) - It seems to be a variation of killing the messenger, although for now Malaysia’s critical and alternative Malay-language press is still alive and kicking.

But five of its members have received stern warnings from the government in the last several weeks, including threats to revoke their publication permits if they fail to comply with various stipulations in these.

And while there has been no official explanation for the sudden scrutiny of the country’s alternative press, observers say there is little doubt that the moves are connected to the sharp erosion in popular support for the ruling Barisan Nasional (National Front) coalition.

The warnings have come within weeks after the Nov 29 polls, in which the Barisan’s share of the popular vote fell from 65 percent to 56 percent, resulting in two state governments landing in opposition hands.

The small band of hard-hitting Malay-language publications had played a crucial role in reaching out to voters especially in the northern rural Malay heartland, where the reach of the Internet is limited.

Many political and media analysts feel that the hugely popular bi-weekly opposition newspaper ‘Harakah’ in particular was the trump card in the opposition campaign there.

The Barisan Nasional ended up bagging less than half the votes cast in many ethnic Malay-dominated constituencies – the coalition’s traditional base of support.

So it did not come as a surprise when, on Dec 24, the Home Ministry announced that ‘Harakah’, published by the opposition Islamic Party (PAS), had until Jan 8 to limit its sales to party members only. Until then, this was only a loosely enforced condition in its publication permit.

“We expected this – that some form of action would be taken after the election,” the paper’s English section news editor, Abd Rahman Koya, told IPS.

Previously, ‘Harakah’ had been sold at newsstands throughout the country. It was selling up to 340,000 copies in the run-up to the elections, making it what analysts say is the largest selling Malay-language newspaper in the country.

After the polls, Abd Rahman says that instead of falling, ‘Harakah’s sales rose even further to 360,000. Though the paper carries a “For Members Only” notice prominently on its front page to comply with a condition in its publication permit, its sales to non-party members had soared.

But the PAS paper has not been the only publication to attract the government’s attention. Two weeks after the November polls, the weekly tabloid ‘Eksklusif’ was said to have received a warning letter from authorities for allegedly “spreading rumours”.

Recently, the independent bi-monthly magazine ‘Detik’ announced that it had downgraded its editor-in-chief Ahmad Lufti Othman to the post of editor after receiving a show-cause letter from the Home Ministry. The letter stated that the publication had failed to inform the ministry of Ahmad’s appointment.

“We admit to have carelessly made such a big mistake and have therefore apologised to the ministry,” ‘Detik’ was reported as saying in an open letter.

Detik’s hand was forced following a delay in getting its fresh annual publication permit approved when its previous one expired at the end of November. The publication has already fallen three issues behind.

The Home Ministry was also reported as having warned two monthlies — ‘Wasilah’, a newly launched sister publication of ‘Detik’ that targets the youth, and ‘Tamadun’ — that action could be taken if they did not respect the conditions of their licences.

On Jan 6, the Paris-based Reporters Sans Frontieres (RSF) sent a letter to Home Affairs Minister and Deputy Prime Minister Abdullah Badawi expressing “its worry after the threats of closure made against (the) five newspapers.” RSF asked the minister to “ensure that the publication licenses of the newspapers are not withdrawn by the ministry”.

RSF said the closure of any one of these publications would constitute “a grave violation of press freedom”. It also called on the minister to liberalise press laws, which require publishers to apply for a new permit annually for each publication they produce.

“Obviously, the government is not interested in or concerned about the emergence of an enlightened citizenry,” said P Ramakrishnan, president of the social reform group Aliran, responding to the restriction on ‘Harakah’ sales to the public.

He added, “A thinking and critical citizenry, it seems, is inimical to the Barisan Nasional’s existence and therefore it must be contained by whatever means.”

Harakah’s management has acted swiftly to stem the loss of its street sales. Since the warning, sales have slumped to around 250,000 as the paper’s regular vendors fear selling the paper openly.

But even at this reduced circulation, Harakah still leaves the other two main pro-government Malay-language dailies trailing, according to Abd Rahman.

“We are trying to create a vendor system to deliver direct to homes and also focus on postal subscriptions,” says Abd Rahman. “We don’t want to give them any reason to ban Harakah.” He is confident Harakah’s circulation will rise again once this system is in place.

There has also been a fresh initiative to loosen the pro- establishment mainstream media’s stranglehold on the Malaysian public. Just before the general election, a new website, Malaysia Kini (Malaysia Now, http//www.malaysiakini.com) featuring independent news reports appeared on the Internet.

Conceived by Malaysian journalists unhappy with the sorry state of the Malaysian mass media, Malaysia Kini is partly funded by the South East Asian Press Alliance, an organisation promoting press freedom in the region.

“Our main intention is to provide Malaysians with independent media,” Malaysia Kini editor Steven Gan told IPS. “Hopefully we can help improve the situation of the media here in Malaysia.”

Gan says the response to the website has been quite overwhelming, reporting that “in our first full month, we have had half a million ‘hits”. That compares favourably with the highly successful Laman Reformasi (Reformasi Website), which receives more than 20 million hits a year.

Gan hopes to give the mainstream media a run for their money, though he is aware of much of the hype over the Internet’s potential. Still with only about one million Internet users in a population of 22 million, there is clearly much scope for a wider audience for Malaysia Kini and alternative sites.

“The print media will continue to exist but maybe in a different form,” says Gan. “Hopefully, we will become a force to be reckoned with.”

But much will depend on how much leeway the authorities allow the alternative media.

Many Malaysians are hoping that the latest official scrutiny is just a knee-jerk reaction to the poll results and that the alternative media will find a way to continue to find its voice, and make it heard, to the public.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags