Economy & Trade, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean

TRADE-CARIBBEAN: Steelpan Goes Yankee

Peter Richards

PORT OF SPAIN, Apr 20 2002 (IPS) - A United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) decision to grant a patent to two U.S. citizens to produce a Caribbean steelpan, also known as a steel drum, is causing much controversy here in Trinidad and Tobago, where the musical instrument was invented some half a century ago.

The government has been stunned by the decision favouring George Whitmyre of the U.S. state of Maryland and Harvey J Price, of Delaware, and is initiating steps to challenge the decision.

“If an examination of the claim can indicate to us that the technology is not new and that it was perhaps done here or elsewhere in the world, then we can make an application to have the patent set aside,” says Legal Affairs Minister Camille Robinson-Regis.

Several requests have been made since 1982 to Pan Trinbago — the steelpan community’s umbrella group — to patent technical information about the pan but “unfortunately this has not been done,” she says, adding: “The pan continues to be the national instrument of Trinidad and Tobago.”

On Tuesday, Trinidadians awoke to newspaper reports that the two U.S. citizens had received the patent on the basis that they were now producing “Caribbean steelpan using a hydroforming press.”

According to the newspaper stories, the two claim to have invented a “process for forming a Caribbean steelpan, consisting essentially of determining the shape and dimensions of a Caribbean steelpan.”

The process includes several components which are used in Trinidad and Tobago, where steelpans were first produced from disused oil drums more than 55 years ago: It involves the use of 55-gallon oil drums, the heads of which are rendered concave by physical effort, with the resulting pan being rough-tuned before heating and then fine-tuned after the firing process.

Respected pan researcher Clemont Imbert says the specific method patented by the two U.S. nationals had already been taken way past the drawing board since the mid-1970s but the project was abandoned when the government pulled funding.

The Express newspaper, in an editorial Wednesday, warned that with steelpan music becoming more global (steelpan festivals are held throughout Europe), “it cannot be long from now when mere interest in the sound of pan evolves into a lucrative and sustainable market.”

“We must therefore take the necessary steps now to ensure at that time Trinidad and Tobago does not find itself on the trailing edge,” the Express added.

Pan Trinbago President Patrick Arnold says his association had long sought to ensure such a situation did not happen but with little success.

“As recently as 1999, we sought fresh advice from government’s finest legal minds on this same matter,” he says. “The state’s experts said it was too late to pursue security of intellectual property rights as inventor of the process and although one member had a dissenting view, her opinion was overruled and the initiative was put to rest.”

In 1983, at the first World Intellectual Property Organisation (WIPO) meeting in Trinidad, then vice-president of Pan Trinbago Nestor Sullivan had sought to get a patent for pan.

“They explained we would have to patent the process and that would have been arduous, because it involved every detail, including how many times the hammer should hit a particular note when tuning and with what force,” he recalls.

Managing Director of Trinidad and Tobago Instruments Limited, Michael Cooper, says his establishment uses a mechanised process to mass manufacture the shape and imprint the notes of the pans for export.

“I held extensive discussions with U.S. patent attorneys and they uniformly advised I pursue a process that was nearly impossible, one that required agreement from a number of artisans, people who weren’t likely to agree on design or details of the manufacturing process,” he says.

He adds that as far back as 1980, Trinidadians had been investigating the “very hydroforming process (covered by the U.S. patent) and even went to Sweden to complete experiments there but it all turned out to be pretty expensive research and the exercise was abandoned for lack of funding.”

Cooper, who says Whitmyre told him of his plans in 1999, adds: “This is not a done deal. These developments can almost always be challenged.”

Attorney Tene Reece says the USPTO decision must not be seen as cast in stone, adding that challenges could be filed before the USPTO, U.S. Supreme Court, or any other patent office where the two U.S. citizens tried to patent the invention.

Reece, however, urges local authorities to file their challenge immediately “in order to ensure that we do not find ourselves in a situation where we may be prevented from the free use of our own instruments by virtue of patent infringement or be required to obtain permission and pay royalties.”

“The cost factor to our country by doing nothing far outweighs the cost of commencing legal action,” he says.

Pan archivist Keith Simpson says local authorities should take some of the blame for the failure to patent the instrument.

He says up to this year, there has not been a proper history of the instrument in Trinidad and Tobago, and that a Swiss national has written the best book on pan tuning.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags