Thursday, November 19, 2026
Alejandro Sciscioli
- ”Since the controls began, our clientele has grown,” says Patricia, a transvestite who offers sexual services on the streets of the Paraguayan capital, when asked about the effects of a new curfew for businesses selling liquor.
That is just one of the consequences of the controversial new statute that went into effect a month ago.
Local authorities say results have already been seen, pointing out that the number of accidents and crimes reported in January was three percent lower than in the same month in 2003.
But the statute setting a curfew for restaurants, bars, discotheques, night clubs and other businesses that sell alcoholic beverages, with the aim of reducing violence, has many critics.
Under the new city ordinance, businesses that sell alcohol must close at midnight from Sunday through Thursday, and at 2:00 AM on Fridays, Saturdays and the night before holidays.
Carlos, a father of four who worked until last month in a night club on Brasilia Avenue, where most of the city’s discotheques are located, lost his job as a result of closures and lay-offs triggered by the new ordinance.
”I’ve never done anything else, and starting over again at 40 is impossible,” he complained, explaining that he had worked in night clubs for 20 years.
The measure has led to the closure of over half of the night clubs along Brasilia Avenue and in other areas of the capital, and to the loss of nearly 60 percent of the jobs generated by the sector.
The curfew, which some call a ”dry law”, has had a drastic effect on the Mouse Cantina, an exclusive discotheque that was forced to slash its payroll from 60 employees to 12, said the club’s administrator, David Chamorro.
He added that the number of customers in the first half of January amounted to just 10 percent of the total from the same period in 2003.
”The municipal government is unable to control 1,000 drunks, so it’s restricting the freedom of more than 500,000 residents of Asunción,” complained the owner of Zoë Café, Jorge Zafuán.
But this was no hastily improvised ordinance, said José Arias, the director of Prevention Programmes in the Asunción Municipal Health Agency.
He said the measure promoted by Mayor Enrique Riera was adopted after studying similar curfews applied in Colombia, Brazil and European Union countries, which led to ”a drop in violence, up to 50 percent less accidents, and a 30 percent reduction of crime” in some cases.
According to the Health Ministry, 25 percent of the nearly 5,000 patients treated every month in Medical Emergencies, a public hospital in Asunción, involve consumption of alcohol and intoxication-related violence.
Drinking is a factor in around 90 percent of all deaths resulting from accidents and murders in Paraguay.
And violence is the top cause of death among Paraguayan men between the ages of 15 and 44, said Pan-American Health Organisation (PAHO) representative Hernán Málaga.
”This vaccine (the curfew) has been well-proven, and if it doesn’t work here, that’s another question,” said Arias. ”But let’s try it for at least six months. If it doesn’t work, we’ll revise the statute.”
Health Minister Julio César Velázquez said the executive branch will provide support for the application of similar measures in other cities in this South American country of 5.7 million. The mayors of 22 other cities are considering the adoption of a curfew.
Governing Colorado Party lawmakers also plan to study the possibility of a bill that would establish a nationwide curfew.
”If citizens (in Asunción) were more responsible and self-regulated, and if society was more mature in terms of its obligations, rather than rights, this ordinance would probably not be necessary,” said Mayor Riera.
”But as we learn and grow and continue building our sense of citizenship, can we continue to allow our young people to die? I don’t think so,” he added.
However, the director of the non-governmental organisation Decidamos (Let’s Decide), Juan Carlos Giuste, said that ”We share the concern over the violence, but we also believe that grossly restricting personal freedoms is like cutting off your head when you have a headache, instead of taking a painkiller.”
To reduce crime levels, ”what is needed is the enforcement of existing laws, without having to trample the inalienable rights and freedoms of individuals,” said political analyst Félix Lugo.
But Jorge Seall, who has a doctorate in law from Harvard University in the United States, said the statute ”is not blatantly unconstitutional.”
”The argument that there is a certain level of damage to or loss of other rights is not sufficient” to prove that a statute is unconstitutional, he said.
For his part, Giuste argued that ”People will continue finding places for going out and drinking, and will end up going to private venues, like homes. We will start coming across cases of abuse of minors, and a series of other issues that will get out of hand.”
In public venues, ”there is control, the owners can be held accountable, and there are regulations that must be respected,” said Lugo.
However, proponents of the curfew point to success in other countries. According to PAHO representative Málaga, in the Colombian cities of Cali and Bogota, which have restrictions on liquor sales and on carrying weapons, ”the effect was immediate.”
Similar measures have also been implemented in Medellin, Colombia, and Quito, Ecuador, ”and there is interest in implementing curfews in Lima, Caracas and Montevideo,” said Málaga.
”In places were a curfew has remained in force for three or four years, injuries due to external causes have been reduced by as much as 50 percent,” he said.
Curfews on liquor sales even exist in cities internationally renowned for their roaring nightlife.
In London, pubs close their doors at 11:00 PM, after a bell rings for last call at 10:30.
In the Argentine capital, the sale of liquor in kiosks and gas stations was prohibited in December, and businesses found violating the ban began to be closed down on Jan. 20.
The Buenos Aires statute also limits sales of alcohol in food stores and supermarkets to between 8:00 AM and 11:00 PM. After that, only home deliveries are allowed.
But restaurants, cafés and discotheques, where liquor is consumed on the premises, are exempt from the ordinance.
In the Argentine province of Buenos Aires, a ”nightlife law” in effect from 1996 to 2000 set a 4:00 AM curfew for discotheques and bars, to combat crime and drug trafficking.
But the curfew was not respected. The then-governor of Buenos Aires province, Carlos Ruckauf, said ”The curfew makes no sense, and even ended up becoming a source of corruption.”
In 2001, the Buenos Aires provincial legislature authorised municipal governments to set their own curfews and regulations for businesses selling alcoholic beverages.