Armed Conflicts, Headlines, Human Rights

FISHERIES: European Union Freezes Bilateral Relations With Canada

Bob Mantiri

BRUSSELS, Mar 14 1995 (IPS) - The European Union Tuesday froze all bilaterial relations with Canada and at the same time warned Ottawa that commercial sanctions could be taken if the Spanish trawler ‘Estai’, the captain and crew were not released immediately.

The trawler was seized last week Friday in international waters and later brought to the port of St. Johns in Newfoundland where it is chained up.

The captain was charged with several offences under the Canadian protection law of coastal fishing but was set free after a bail of five million Canadian dollars was paid.

The warning came Tuesday morning from the EC commissioner Emma Bonino, who is in charge of fisheries, and from external trade commissioner Leon Brittan during a press conference in the Commissions headquarters in Brussels.

At the same time Spain has told its trawlers to start fishing in the disputed area off Newfoundland despite the risk of seizure by Canadian authorities.

Commissioner Bonino spoke of a tense situation in relations with Canada. She said that these relations “can only be normalised if the trawler is released”.

According to Bonino the seizure of the trawler is the “result of a fisheries and conservation strategy developed by Canada which is against international sea law.

“Canada has not only seized an EU ship for domestic reasons and to hide its inefficiency in fish stock management, but it has taken the international community as a hostage by presenting it with a fait accompli,” she said.

She accused Canada of terrorising the North West Atlantic fishing grounds by harassing the fishing vessels with radio interference and airplanes.

But she added: “If Canada released the trawler today, we are ready to resume negotiations tomorrow.”

Commissioner Brittan stressed that the conflict has to be solved through diplomatic channels.

“The Union does not want this situation to escalate. However, if Canada fails to show due restraint in its actions and continues to demonstrate a lack of respect for its international commitments, we will take measures to defend our interest,” he said.

He did not elaborate on what kind of commercial sanctions will be taken, because he said “you have to keep the element of surprise”.

Canada will be heavily hit by a European Union boycott since Canada’s fish exports to Europe stood at 381 million dollars last year — while the European Union is exporting only 25 million dollars to Canada, Brittan said.

A scientific accord with Canada was put on ice Friday and during a meeting Monday of the EU ambassadors it was decided to break off formal ties with Ottawa, until the vessel is released unconditionally.

But like Bonino, Commissioner Brittan condemned the Spanish move by sending warships to the area where the Spanish trawler was seized as “not a good idea”.

The Canadian government accused the captain of the Estai of catching undersized halibuts with nets which are forbidden by the NAFO (the North Atlantic Fisheries organisation).

As evidence the Canadian authorities pointed at the fact that the captain of the trawler cut his nets when Canadian maritime officials boarded the vessel.

Bonino stressed that there is no rule by NAFO about the size of the halibut. “There is no agreement on this whatsoever within NAFO,” she argued.

She also noted that on Dec. 22 Canadian maritime police checked and approved the nets of the same trawler which had been seized last Friday.

The Fisheries Commissioner also rejected Canada’s accusation that European trawlers are destroying the stocks of the Greenland halibut.

She reminds Canada of the fact that the European Union had agreed with NAFO it would stop fishing when it reached its maximum of 27,000 tonnes.

Furthermore, Bonino said the European Union had demonstrated that it respects the conservation of endangered species like the hailibut — by proposing to limit its catch from 44,000 to 18,000 tonnes. But Canada rejected that.

Greenpeace is backing the Canadian position. Greenpeace spokesperson Heleen Boers accused the Europeans of “over-fishing all over the planet and not respecting regulations and quotas “.

According to her and NAFO the Greenland halibut stocks are the lowest on record.

“Canada has historic rights in the North West Atlantic fishing region, while Spain is fishing there for only five years. The Europeans have been fishing for all kind of stocks in this area for a long time.”

“The Canadians are taking the right approach. They have been forced by the circumstances to correct the situation. Europe thus far did nothing to change its policy in fisheries,” said Boers.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags