Development & Aid, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Population

DEVELOPMENT: Women NGOs may be taking on too big a burden

Jaya Dayal

UNITED NATIONS, Jun 21 1995 (IPS) - The current enthusiasm for non- governmental organisation (NGO) participation in social change may be a double-edged sword — one that may hurt women the most, warns an independent report published by the United Nations.

Spirited calls by western donors and governments for new partnerships with NGOs “should be approached with caution by women and development advocates,” say Shahrashoub Razavi and Carol Miller, authors of the report.

They note that while women NGOs have a critical role to play as a key platform for their demands, they could also be letting governments off the hook in creating, implementing and enforcing state-sponsored gender-equitable policies.

Women NGOs, argue the authors, should keep up the pressure on governments to enact fair policies. If they fail to do so, they run the risk of shouldering the burden of social change and male- biased programmes.

The report, ‘From Women in Development to Gender and Development,’ is part of a series of papers put out by the Geneva- based U.N. Research Institute for Social Development (UNRISD) in advance of September’s Fourth World Conference on Women in Beijing.

At that meeting, more than 35,000 women representing NGOs and grassroots groups from poor and rich countries will lobby for changes to a U.N. action plan that will set governments’ priorities for women over the next 10 years.

The draft action plan for the Beijing meeting makes repeated appeals to these groups and other representatives of civil society, like academics and school teachers, to help “empower” women.

But Dharam Ghai, director of UNRISD, says that while these thousands of groups have a role to play in bringing real-life experiences to the drafting-table, “there are serious limits to what institutions of civil society can achieve.”

The report’s authors agree, noting that the optimism of the role to be played by women NGOs in bringing about greater equality between women and men may not be well-grounded.

According to Razavi and Miller, the “bottom-up” NGO rhetoric currently favoured by development advocates and Western donors may run into the same kinds of problems associated with “top-down” strategies implemented by governments and huge international bureaucracies.

These problems include social and cultural insensitivity by project planners, and isolated projects that, though productive, fail to change existing power relations between women and men, different groups, or economic strata.

For example, the India-based Self-Employed Women’s Association (SEWA) is regarded as hugely successful in raising the consciousness of women’s rights as workers. But it has made little headway in reconciling differences between classes or ensuring women’s access to markets.

“SEWA’s experience, with all its achievements, illustrates the fundamental point that civil society can not substitute for the powers that states have in regulating markets,” say the authors.

Another potential problem with NGOs is their own accountability and representativity.

“In view of the growing proportion of donor funding being made available to NGOs, it is difficult to imagine how NGOs will resist becoming influenced by the objectives of donor agencies,” say Razavi and Miller.

The proportion of development money handled by the NGO sector has ballooned in the last decade, reflecting a shift in thinking away from the state as provider of services to local and non- governmental outlets.

The World Bank, for example, channeled about half of its 1993 development funds for Africa through NGOs. This March, the United States announced that more than half of its foreign aid would be channeled through NGOs instead of governments.

But the shift has also included a move away from traditional development concerns with economic issues to more political and social issues like human rights, good governance and participation.

Spurred by the United Nations, this has included a renewed focus on the active role of women in the environmental, economic, population, education and health spheres.

As a result, NGOs, and women NGOs in particular, have been embraced by policy-makers as the “missing link” in efforts to integrate gender into development planning.

But the authors warn that these groups — in winning the right to be counted as partners with governments — may be buried under the work of implementing all the proposals for economic and social change spelled out at recent U.N. meetings.

Finally, they note that these groups may end up bearing the brunt of change associated with social and economic reforms while remaining outside the political process of decision- making.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags