Headlines, Middle East & North Africa | Analysis

MIDDLE EAST: Israeli-Arab Peace Process at the Crossroads

Analysis - Dilip Hiro

LONDON, Jun 26 1995 (IPS) - On the eve of this week’s meeting in Washington between Syrian and Israeli military leaders — being held under the auspices of the United States — the Middle East peace process is at the crossroads.

The recent agreement between Israel and Syria on the technical military matters concerning the Golan Heights has improved the atmosphere; but major hurdles remain, not least the planned Israeli referendum on the issue.

On the Palestinian track, the Jul 1 deadline for reaching an agreement on the second phase of the Oslo Accord — requiring redeployment of Israeli troops and holding of elections for the Palestinian Council — seems unlikely to be met.

The 13th visit of U.S. Secretary of State Warren Christopher, to the Middle East earlier this month helped to bridge the gap between Syria and Israel on the subjects of establishing demilitarised zones and posting of peacekeeping forces on the Golan Heights which Israel occupied during the June 1967 Arab- Israeli War.

The earlier statements by Israeli Foreign Minister Shimon Peres that the Golan was ‘Syrian territory’ also helped to improve the atmosphere. This was a public reversal of the Israeli stance that had maintained until then that the Golan — officially annexed by Israel in 1981 — was an integral part of Israeli territory.

So that when the talks start in Washington on Tuesday, the first step will be to try to work out modalities of Israeli withdrawal and the establishment of ‘full peace’ between the two countries, involving full diplomatic and economic relations.

What had happened between Egypt and Israel after the 1979 peace treaty is a good model to emulate.

Then, the full Israeli evacuation of the occupied Sinai Peninsula (area, 61,000 sq kms) was carried out between April 1979 and April 1982 in three phases — with each phase tied to graduated upgrading of links between the two states.

Syrian President Hafez Assad wants nothing less than what Egypt got in return for full peace with Israel. But since the Golan heights is only 1,150 sq kms, he wants the Israeli withdrawal to be completed within a year. Israel on the other hand has proposed an eight year period. This is clearly unacceptable to Syria.

But above all this hangs the cloud of a referendum on the subject, something Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin promised to his people. There is no precedent for such a referendum, and there was no need for it.

Current public opinion polls show that between 55 and 60 per cent of Israelis are opposed to a complete Israeli withdrawal in exchange for ‘full peace’ with Syria.

What is equally disturbing for Rabin is that his own Labour Party is divided, with as many as a third of its 44 parliamentary deputies opposed to total evacuation of the Golan.

Since Israel is dealing in this case with a powerful neighbour, a fully-fledged state, led by a strong, wily leader, Assad, the talks are in a way between equals.

This is far from the case in the negotiations between Israel and the fledgling Palestinian state represented by the Palestine Liberation Organisation (PLO) and its chairman Yasser Arafat. Here, there is blatant inequality between the two sides.

And all signs are that, despite having concluded the Oslo Accord with the PLO in September 1993, Rabin appears less than committed to it.

Though there is no mention in the Oslo Accord of Israel being reassured of security of Israeli citizens within its borders and/or the West Bank and Gaza Strip before it would implement the second phase of the agreement, Rabin has unilaterally imposed this condition. And he has got away with it.

The Oslo Accord specified July 1994 for elections to the Palestinian Council to be held in the West Bank and Gaza Strip after the Israeli troops had been removed from the main Palestinian population centres.

It is now one year past the Oslo Accord deadline. And the last teroristic action against Israeli soldiers in Israel occurred five months ago, in January, Yet there is no sign of the Palestinian elections.

As for the redeployment of Israeli forces, Press reports suggest that Rabin is offering to do so in two stages — another breach of the Oslo Accord.

The first stage would cover the northern sector of the West Bank. The Palestinians seem to be agreeable, but want the redeployment in the southern sector to be settled now. Rabin on the other hand wants to postpone that decision to a future date. That is what the current haggling between the two sides is about.

Present signs are that what Israel is offering in the West Bank to the Palestinian Authority is a deal that is as truncated and demeaning as its Gaza strip-Jericho predecessor.

But whereas in that phase of the agreement the Palestinian Authority had to co-exist with only 3,000 Jewish settlers in the Gaza Strip, now it has to do so with 140,000 Jewish colonisers under continued Israeli jurisdiction, protected by a vast army of Israeli soldiers.

All in all, the prospect for peace in the region — whether on the Syrian or the Palestinian track — is far from rosy.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags