Saturday, November 21, 2026
Johanna Son
- A campaign by rich countries to make market access contingent on labour and environmental standards of developing nations reeks of protectionism, false fears or misplaced altruism, according to trade experts.
They warn that efforts to forge such a linkage is causing a North-South despite of the world trade accord forged last year.
In the new agreement, nations widened international trade rules to include two new areas: services and intellectual property protection.
Now countries like the United States and France want the fledgling World Trade Organisation (WTO) to take on two other areas — and make market access dependent on countries’ acceptance of environmental standards and a ‘social clause’ containing certain labour standards.
Tension arises from the fact that while industrialised governments in the West say higher standards would help Asia’s ‘exploited’ workers and protect its environment, developing countries say these can be used to weaken their export power.
“Sadly, just when all countries have unified behind the passage of the Uruguay Round, a divide is opening up, predominantly in North-South terms,” says trade economist Jagdish Bhagwati of the Columbia University in New York.
Developing nations, including those in Asia, fear that proposed preconditions to free trade may soon become barriers to free trade, Bhagwati adds.
Officials from the United States Trade Representative arrived in Indonesia this week to look into labour conditions amidst fresh charges by the New York-based Human Rights Watch/Asia that Jakarta has not taken steps to guarantee internationally-recognised workers’ rights.
Last month, Malaysian premier Mahathir Mohammad said labour- related proposals like setting a worldwide minimum wage was a Western attempt to “eliminate the competitive edge of East Asia” and not a show of sincere concern for workers’ welfare.
“They know that this is the sole comparative advantage of developing countries,” he pointed out.
Added Mahathir: “Sanctimonious pronouncements on humanitarian, democratic and environmental issues are likely to be motivated by a similar selfish desire to put as many obstacles as possible in the way of anyone attempting to catch up and compete with the West.”
Narhari Rao of the Asian Development Bank (AsDB) says developing countries view attempts to link labour standards and trade policy with “considerable suspicion and no different from disguised protectionism”.
Asia is especially worried about the linkage, because its record growth in the past 20 years drew heavily from its export muscle.
A common assumption in North America and Europe is that falling real wages and rise in unemployment in the last two decades was due to trade with the South, whose strong exports are made possible by using cheap labour.
But Bhagwati says it is modern, information-based technical change that is substituting unskilled labour with computers, disproving the belief by industrialised countries that “trade with poor countries will produce more poor at home”.
Industrialised nations also fear that developing countries get an unfair edge by using cheap labour, often associated with poor working conditions, and that such an edge would lure foreign investments overseas.
And even if the use of international labour standards is accepted, adoption of common benchmarks would be a problem because of wide cultural and economic diversity.
Minimum labour standards in the West such as union formation, minimum wages, annual paid holidays and a 48-hour work week may not be relevant in nations where most workers toil in agriculture.
Bhagwati argues that the U.S. has no moral leadership in labour rights either, given its 12 per cent rate of unionised private- sector workers, ill treatment of migrant labour in agriculture and sweatshops “exploiting female immigrants in textiles”.
Bhagwati and Rao say the International Labour Organisation (ILO) and not the WTO is the right body within which to forge a consensus on labour rights, away from the shadow of trade sanctions. But Rao also notes there is no enforcement mechanism for the ILO’s 174 conventions, implemented by persuasion.
Likewise, experts say the belief that developing countries will focus on getting a market edge or attracting capital by deliberately destroying the environment or adopting lax rules does not hold water. “Trade can endanger or enhance environmental quality,” says AsDB economist Douglas Brooks.
While Asia’s fast-paced growth does take a toll on the environment, he said economic growth can also lead to improving environment.
Countries like Korea, Taiwan and Thailand are switching to burning fuel oil with less sulphur, he said. Many South-east Asian governments, alarmed by deforestation, have banned lucrative exports of logs.
Trade policies aimed at protecting the environment may have unexpected results, Brooks says. For one, Indonesian limits on wood exports have lowered domestic timber prices and led to more intensive use of logs.
The international community’s inclusion of labour and environment within the WTO’s ambit may benefit the bigger countries. Brooks says powerful countries are more likely to use trade as a tool to enforce so-called labour and environmental standards in weaker countries.