Sunday, November 22, 2026
Sergei Strokan
- Russian-Chechen peace negotiations took a turn for the worse Friday when Chechen negotiators walked out of talks to protest reported attacks on civilians in Chechnya by Russian troops.
The break-off in talks followed reports that Russian troops had killed seven civilians in the eastern suburbs of the Chechen capital of Grozny in a pre-dawn raid.
Chief Chechen negotiator Usman Imayev was quoted by the Interfax news agency as saying that men wearing Russian military uniforms were responsible for the deaths at a farming settlement and that the talks would only continue when those responsible were arrested.
Moscow says it is investigating the reports with officials suggesting that the reported attacks may have been carried out by rebel Chechen militants dressed in Russian uniforms.
This third round of negotiations, which began Thursday, probably represents the last chance to end the war between the Russian army and Chechen rebels in the breakaway Russian republic. The fighting began in December when the Russian military was ordered to take control of the republic.
Moscow’s negotiating team headed by newly appointed Nationalities Minister Vyacheslav Mikhailov is looking primarily at settling the political issues, including the future of Chechen president Jokhar Dudayev and the holding of free elections in the republic. Their counterparts stress the need for Russian troops to withdraw from the republic before such issues are considered.
Thursday’s negotiating session lasted for just two hours due to the absence of Imayev, the only representative authorised to discuss political questions.
Nevertheless, the sides decided to establish a permanent communications link to help monitor the ceasefire, which was initially suggested at the first round of talks. In a goodwill gesture the Chechen side announced the release two Russian prisoners of war.
The political status of Chechnya is, indeed, the main stumbling block. In previous rounds President Dudayev offered to resign in a ‘zero option’ peace deal only if the republic’s independence is recognised.
However, on Wednesday Russian Prime Minister Viktor Chernomyrdin ruled out any discussion of Chechen independence. “The future status of Chechnya can be decided only on the basis of the Russian Constitution.”
Nevertheless, speaking to a group of Russian students, Chernomyrdin held out the sovereignty bait to the Chechens, saying that the degree of autonomy of the Russian Federation subjects varies, and that it is a subject open to discussion.
He said that the status of Chechnya in this respect could only be decided after elections, when federal authorities could negotiate with the newly elected government of Grozny.
The only tangible results of the talks so far have been agreement on a ceasefire during the peace process, and the decision to set up a supervisory commission to enforce the agreement ending armed confrontation and another commission to control elections.
The negotiating process was sparked off by last month’s the massacre in Budyonnovsk, a small Russian town in the Stavropol region adjacent to Chechnya. More than a hundred civilians were brutally killed and more than a thousand taken hostage when a band of Chechen rebels raided the town.
The Budyonnovsk tragedy — which incited a political crisis in Moscow, leading to the resignations of three senior government ministers — forced the Kremlin to intensify peace efforts to avoid the eruption of nationwide anger over the poor handling of the hostage affair by the authorities.
It was Chernomyrdin who encouraged the warring sides to negotiate, in a clear bid to win popular sympathy ahead of parliamentary and presidential elections expected to be held at the end of this year.
Previously viewed as the quintessential bureaucrat, the prime minister emerged from the shadow of President Boris Yeltsin to seize the limelight by implicitly criticising Yeltsin for his misadventure in Chechnya.
Chernomyrdin, who now heads the ‘Russia Our Home’ electoral bloc, said that it took a hostage crisis to turn a fresh page in Russian history and instill a respect for human life among the country’s leaders.
“The Budyonnovsk tragedy is the starting point for a new political era. The Russian state, almost for the first time, put the lives of its citizens above political expediency,” he said.
The complexity of sovereignty issues discussed at the talks is compounded by the apparent differences within the Russian contingent over Moscow’s stand.
Aside from Chernomyrdin’s comments no clear cut picture emerged on the Russian position before the resumption of negotiations, with conflicting signals being sent out by the President’s office, the defence ministry and the Russian negotiators themselves.
In a strongly worded statement made at Wednesday’s press conference Arkady Volsky, deputy leader of the negotiating team, criticised the timing of Tuesday’s presidential decree ordering a permanent Russian military presence in Chechnya.
He warned that he would not be going back to Grozny unless he received assurances that the decree would be changed. The decree had been immediately condemned by Chechen negotiator Imayev, who accused the Russians of making contradictory promises.
To add to the confusion Volsky said he had not known about the decree beforehand and he doubted the government did either. On the other hand, the Chechen side, he claimed, knew about it 24 hours in advance.
The usually cautious and suave Volsky — a veteran ‘apparatchik’ and a one-time aide to Leonid Brezhnev and Mikhail Gorbachev, and now head of the Union of Russian Industrialists and Entrepreneurs — lashed out: “This is not just a shortcoming, it is worse — if not a crime — when others learn about it sooner than those with whom such things should be agreed in the first place.”
Volsky explicitly linked the decree with the activities of Defence Minister Pavel Grachev — the only so-called “power” minister and a staunch ally of Yeltsin — who survived the latest cabinet reshuffle. He called Grachev’s position “frightening”.
The reformist party Russia’s Democratic Choice warned Wednesday: “Now when hope appeared that the conflict would be resolved by political means, the decree’s issue proves that the ‘party of war’ that suffered a shameful defeat in Budyonnovsk is beginning a counter-offensive,” the party’s statement said.
The controversy over the presidential decree continued Thursday with the Chechen delegation at the talks voicing indignation over Yeltsin’s signature on it. This sentiment was echoed by Volsky, who said that “if the decree is not changed let those who inspired it come here and replace us at the negotiating table. But it would be the end of the deal”.
Later Thursday, Itar-Tass news agency reported that the ill- fated decree could be, after all, amended. “This shows the rift between opponents and inspirers of the decree is narrowing, giving another hope for peace in Chechnya,” Russian Independent TV said.
Commenting upon the talks, the Russian media offers several versions of what the future holds.
“It looks like there will be no solution in the nearest future. Moscow and Chechen politicians, deeply implicated in the bloody war, will prefer to drag their feet at the talks rather than come to ingenious and fresh solutions,” ‘Moscow News’ weekly analyst Michail Shevelev wrote. “The situation could be changed by new leaders coming to power in Russia itself after the elections.”
The way around the Chechnya status stalemate for Moscow, ‘Izvestia’ daily suggests, may be to make separate deals with Dudayev’s entourage, who would forego his demand for the recognition of Chechen independence, and official negotiators.
But before any of these suggested options can be pursued, Russian negotiators will have to get Imayev to return to the bargaining table, and that means getting to the bottom of Friday’s civilian deaths in Grozny where as many as 5,000 people had taken to the streets to protest the killings.