Africa, Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

SOUTH AFRICA-WOMEN: WILL GENDER QUOTAS HELP?

GUMISAI MUTUME

JOHANNESBURG, Jul 27 1995 (IPS) - MOST PEOPLE WOULD AGREE THAT SOCIETY DISCRIMINATES AGAINST WOMEN. THE QUESTION IS, BEYOND HAND-WRINGING, WHAT DO YOU DO ABOUT IT?

SOUTH AFRICA’S DEMOCRATIC ELECTIONS EXORCISED THE APARTHEID GHOUL AND USHERED IN MAJORITY RULE. NOW, THERE IS PRESSURE TO ADDRESS AN EQUALITY ISSUE THAT TRANSCENDS RACE — WOMEN’S EMPOWERMENT IN THE POLITICAL PROCESS.

A PROPOSAL IS ON THE TABLE TO ADD TO THE MIX OF DELIBERATION OVER THE COUNTRY’S NEW CONSTITUTION A QUOTA SYSTEM TO STRIKE A GENDER BALANCE OVER REPRESENTATION TO SOUTH AFRICA’S LEGISLATURES.

PROVINCIAL AFFAIRS DEPUTY MINISTER VALLI MOOSA SUGGESTS THERE SHOULD BE A 50:50 SPLIT BETWEEN MEN AND WOMEN ON PARTY CANDIDATE LISTS FOR ELECTIONS TO NATIONAL, PROVINCIAL AND MUNICIPAL PARLIAMENTS.

ACCORDING TO THE MINISTER, A MEMBER OF THE RULING AFRICAN NATIONAL CONGRESS (ANC), SEXUAL DISCRIMINATION WILL NOT CHANGE NATURALLY BUT NEEDS TO BE REVERSED THROUGH A CONSTITUTIONAL PROVISION.

PRESENTLY THERE ARE 101 WOMEN PARLIAMENTARIANS IN THE 400 MEMBER NATIONAL ASSEMBLY. A DECADE AGO ONLY 2.8 PERCENT OF PARLIAMENTARIANS WERE WOMEN.

THE RELATIVELY HIGH NUMBER NOW ONLY CAME ABOUT BECAUSE IN THE RUN UP TO LAST YEAR’S ALL-RACE ELECTIONS, THE ANC’S EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE INSISTED THAT ONE-THIRD OF ITS NOMINEES FOR NATIONAL AND PROVINCIAL LEGISLATURES WERE WOMEN.

HOWEVER, IN LOCAL COUNCILS WHERE THE RULE WAS NOT APPLIED, FEMALE FACES ARE FEW AND FAR BETWEEN.

“QUOTA SYSTEMS DO HAVE THE DANGER OF TOKENISM BUT IT MATTERS LESS IN POLITICS THAN IN OTHER AREAS,” NOTES CONSTITUTIONAL AFFAIRS EXPERT, STEVE FRIEDMAN. “NOT THAT I’M SAYING WOMEN ARE NOT EDUCATED, BUT ONE DOES NOT NEED TRAINING TO GET INTO POLITICAL LEADERSHIP.”

HE POINTS TO THE CURRENT AFFIRMATIVE ACTION WAVE BREAKING OVER SOUTH AFRICA IN WHICH BLACKS (MAINLY MEN) ARE BEING APPOINTED IN LARGE CORPORATIONS AS BASICALLY WINDOW DRESSING.

“BUT ON THE OTHER HAND IF YOU DO NOT HAVE SOME SORT OF LEGISLATION WOMEN WILL CONTINUE TO BE LEFT OUT OF DECISION MAKING,” NOTES THE RESEARCHER FROM THE CENTRE FOR POLICY STUDIES.

HE HOWEVER OPPOSES THE CONSTITUTIONAL INITIATIVE, PREFERRING QUOTAS TO BE APPLIED ONLY BY THOSE PARTIES THAT SUPPORT THE IDEA.

“WE ARE RUNNING INTO THE DANGER OF PUTTING ANYTHING WHICH IS DESIRABLE NOW, INTO THE CONSTITUTION. IN FIVE YEARS TIME IT MAY NO LONGER BE DESIRABLE AND THEN WE HAVE TO AMEND THE CONSTITUTION,” FRIEDMAN SAYS.

MARION STEVENS OF THE NON-GOVERNMENTAL ORGANISATION WOMEN’S HEALTH PROJECT FEELS THE MOVE IS A BOLD STEP IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION. SHE ADDS THOUGH THAT IT MUST BE PART OF A HOLISTIC EMPOWERMENT PROCESS FOR WOMEN, WHOSE POSITION IN SOCIETY HAS BEEN FURTHER DEGRADED BY DECADES OF APARTHEID.

“PEOPLE NEED TO PUT THEIR HEADS ON THE BLOCK AND COMMIT THEMSELVES BY STARTING AT THE BOTTOM WHERE THE REAL NEED IS. RURAL WOMEN NEED TO BE EDUCATED,” NOTES STEVENS.

ALREADY A GENDER EQUALITY COMMISSION IS ON THE DRAWING BOARD WHOSE JOB IS TO MONITOR AND REVIEW GENDER POLICIES AND PRACTICES IN BOTH PRIVATE AND PUBLIC SECTORS.

IN THE JUDICIAL SYSTEM FOR EXAMPLE, WOMEN MAKE UP 10 PERCENT OF THE TOTAL NUMBER OF JUDGES AND MAGISTRATES, 12 PERCENT OF ADVOCATES AND 15 PERCENT OF ATTORNEYS.

THERE ARE ONLY 16 WOMEN IN THE 90-MEMBER SENATE ELECTED BY THE PROVINCIAL LEGISLATURES, THREE FEMALE MINISTERS IN THE 27 MEMBER CABINET AND THREE DEPUTY MINISTERS.

“BOTH WITHIN GOVERNMENT AND IN MAJOR INSTITUTIONS OF CIVIL SOCIETY SUCH AS THE BUSINESS SECTOR, TRADE UNIONS, RESIDENTS’ ASSOCIATIONS AND RELIGIOUS INSTITUTIONS, MEN REMAIN PREDOMINANT AT A LEADERSHIP LEVEL,” NOTES DEPUTY WELFARE MINISTER, GERALDINE FRASER-MOLEKETI.

“IN ADDITION TO AFFIRMATIVE ACTION THERE IS A GENERAL CONSENSUS THAT A PACKAGE OF MECHANISMS AND INSTITUTIONS AT VARIOUS LEVELS OF GOVERNMENT IS NECESSARY IN ORDER TO ENSURE THE ADVANCEMENT OF WOMEN.

“THE NATURE OF SUCH A PACKAGE IS STILL UNDER INVESTIGATION,” SAYS FRASER-MOLEKETI, IN A NOD TO THE CONSTITUTIONAL PROPOSAL.

+

4-’34-MOLEKETI, WHO LEADS THE SOUTH AFRICAN DELEGATION TO THE FOURTH WORLD CONFERENCE ON WOMEN TO BE HELD IN BEIJING IN SEPTEMBER, HAS BEEN PART OF THE ANC’S WOMEN’S LOBBY WHICH HAS PUSHED FOR THE CHANGES TAKEN SO FAR IN PLACING WOMEN IN POSITIONS OF AUTHORITY.

IN WIDER SOCIETY, WOMEN HAVE BEEN DEPENDING ON THE CHARTER OF FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS ENSHRINED IN THE 1993 INTERIM CONSTITUTION WHICH PROMOTES AFFIRMATIVE ACTION.

IT CALLS FOR “THE ADEQUATE PROTECTION AND ADVANCEMENT OF PERSONS DISADVANTAGED BY UNFAIR DISCRIMINATION IN ORDER TO ENABLE THEIR FULL AND EQUAL ENJOYMENT OF ALL RIGHTS AND FREEDOMS.” IT IS HOWEVER A STATEMENT OF PRINCIPAL RATHER THAN BINDING LEGISLATION.

ADDING ITS VOICE TO THE DEBATE OVER THE CONSTITUTIONAL PROPOSAL, THE JOHANNESBURG ‘STAR’ NEWSPAPER NOTES IN AN EDITORIAL THAT QUOTA SYSTEMS SHOULD BE APPLIED WITH CAUTION.

“ONE RESERVATION IS THAT QUOTAS INTERFERE IN THE DEMOCRATIC PROCESS. AN ARGUMENT IN THEIR FAVOUR IS THAT BECAUSE OF HISTORICAL DISCRIMINATION AGAINST WOMEN, PARTICULARLY BLACK WOMEN, SOME INTERVENTION IS NECESSARY.”

“WE BELIEVE FLEXIBILITY SHOULD BE BUILT INTO ANY QUOTA SYSTEM, EMPHASISING TARGETS, NOT ABSOLUTE FIGURES,” IS ITS COMPROMISE CONCLUSION.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags