Asia-Pacific, Economy & Trade, Headlines, Labour

GULF-LABOUR: UAE Slams Uproar Over Maid’s Death Sentence

Ahmad Mardini

ABU DHABI, Oct 12 1995 (IPS) - Government officials, newspapers and ordinary people in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) are furious over what they see as an aggressive foreign media campaign in support of a Filipina maid sentenced to death in their country.

Sarah Balabagan, 16, a Muslim from the impoverished southern Philippines was awarded capital punishment by an Islamic court at Al-Ain city, 160 kms east of Abu Dhabi, on Sep 16 for premeditated murder of her 70-year-old Emirates employer, Mohammed Abdullah Al-Baloushi.

The international outrage over the sentence has surprised the government and made many citizens wonder why their traditionally low-key country has come under fire.

The maid has been portrayed by the prosecution as an adult who ruthlessly killed her boss, and by the defence as an innocent teenager who tried to fight off a rape.

The prosecution contended that Balabagan, furious over complaints about her work, plunged a knife 34 times into her elderly employer in a planned attack in July last year. But Balabagan said she stabbed Baloushi with the knife he used to threaten her with before raping her, after she had spurned his repeated sexual advances.

Officials contacted by IPS condemned the Western media for linking the case with that of Flor Contemplacion, another Filipina maid executed in March in Singapore for killing the son of her employer. The execution raised an international outcry and soured relations between the Philippines and Singapore.

The UAE weekly Al-Shuruq accused the Philippines authorities of “orchestrating a campaign against the Emirates” and of “distorting the facts”.

“From Flor Contemplacion to Sarah Balabagan, the cries of the Philippines have not ceased….as if the aim was to prevent countries which host Filipino communities from exercising their rights,” it said.

Local newspapers this week hit out at a French lawyer who described Balabagan’s trial as “scandalous”. Gisele Halimi, a former MP and member of a group aimed at saving Balabagan from execution, had protested an appeal court decision on Monday to close proceedings to the public.

The UAE daily Al-Khaleej said “The french lawyer caused a scandal and doesn’t know her limits. Even though the closed-door session had been requested by Sarah’s lawyer, the (French) lawyer protested noisily and impolitely and indecently.”

The court, which met in camera, adjourned the case till Oct 30, saying it needed time to study the matter.

In a statement issued to the press after the hearing, the Ministry of Justice said the court was keen to ensure that the defence would have all the freedom to present its case in full.

“In the light of this and on the basis of authentic reports, and the statements of the accused and her defence and the response of the Appeals Prosecutor, the court will issue a verdict at a later date after completing all necessary legal procedures,” the statement said.

Court officials said the hearing was held behind closed doors at the request of Balabagan’s defence lawyer, Mohammed Al Amin. “Both the public prosecution and the court agreed with the defence lawyer that it was necessary to keep this hearing closed because of the sensitive details that might be presented to the court,” Al-Amin said.

The UAE government, in an effort to dampen the furore over the case, has repeatedly stressed that the death verdict must be upheld by the appeal court and endorsed by UAE president Sheikh Zayed Bin Sultan Al Nahyan before it is final.

Salman Lotfi, Al-Amin’s associate, told newspersons that his team had presented the appeals court with an 11-page memorandum containing six criticisms of the verdict.

“We explained the errors. The prosecutor was charging murder but the court sentenced her to death based on premeditated murder, which is wrong under the UAE penal code. The judges also misinterpreted and overlooked crucial documents,” he said.

“Then there is her age. She is 16, and this is even what the prosecution said in a paper to the court based on a medical test. Her passport was faked. If she is 16, she can’t be sentenced to death under the UAE juvenile law,” Lotfi said.

He said the lower court had also ruled that the young Filipina was not raped, although medical reports and testimony of the gynaecologist who examined her after the incident proved so. “It was suspicious how there was doubt over medical evidence,” he said.

Lotfi said that the prosecution and Al-Baloushi’s son, Faraj repeated their demand for the death penalty for Balabagan, based on the fact that she had stabbed her employer 34 times. Faraj Al- Baloushi told over 60 newspersons from various countries who came to report the case that his family would not accept blood money in lieu of the death sentence.

Philippines President Fidel Ramos, under fire from the large contingent of the country’s overseas workers for not sufficiently protecting their interests, has dispatched several envoys to help with Balabagan’s appeal. They include former Supreme Court Judge and Islamic law expert Abdul Wahid Bidin.

The more than 80,000 Filipino workers in the UAE have been holding prayer sessions for Balabagan ever since she was sentenced to death.

She had initially been sentenced to seven years in jail at an earlier trial in June. But that verdict was quashed and a retrial ordered by the UAE government following protests in the Philippines that the girl had acted in self-defence and should have been acquitted.

A key issue during the trial was Balabagan’s real age. Her passport, which her lawyers say was forged to circumvent a Philippines law banning women under 25 form working overseas, shows her to be 29. She and her parents say she is only 16.

But legal experts say proving Balabagan is underage might not help if the religious court hearing her appeal applies a strict interpretation of Sharia, or Islamic law.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags