Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Economy & Trade, Headlines, Labour, Population

LABOUR-EAST ASIA: Welcome Mat for Migrant Workers Getting Frayed?

Johanna Son

MANILA, Oct 11 1995 (IPS) - Worries about unemployment and too much dependence on foreign workers by some East Asian economies may be thinning out the welcome mat for migrant labourers, whose work helps fuel these countries’ economies.

In vibrant Hong Kong, rising joblessness has sparked calls by labour unions to stop labour imports. The unemployment rate is now at a decade-long high of 3.5 percent, a figure that Western economies envy but has caused unrest in Asia’s financial centre.

“Let’s just kick them out,” a Hong Kong resident wrote to the ‘South China Morning Post’ recently. Of the colony’s 100,000 maids, mostly from the Philippines, she added: “They are here not from the kindness of their hearts, but to dig for gold.”

These sentiments highlight the uncertainty that surrounds the status of migrant workers, whose ranks have risen as Asian economies post high growth rates and grow short of local labour. There are an estimated 13 million migrant workers in Asia.

From Malaysia’s sprawling plantations to South Korea’s busy factories, foreign workers have become crucial to the production process. But their presence is often resented by locals, who especially in times of economic hardship view foreigners as stealing jobs or undercutting efforts to boost work conditions.

The Migrant Forum in Asia, a coalition of 50 support groups, said: “The main problem of the migrant worker and the greatest threat to her or his well-being is the migrant’s ambiguous status.”

Many countries know they need foreign labour, but are also aware of local feelings and try not to take action that may one day allow their permanent presence. Many thus hesitate to spell out the rights of migrants, leaving them in a netherworld that opens them to abuse by unscrupulous bosses.

“In many countries the migrant worker is brought in to fill an actual and real occupational vacancy or need in the host country,” the forum said in a position paper.

“But because of political and cultural considerations migrant workers are not fully recognised as productive members of society. Rather they are denied status, made invisible, discriminated against or denigrated to appease ‘nationalist’ or ‘protectionist’ sentiments of the public in general,” it added.

In August Malaysia, trying to keep a handle on its two million foreign workers, froze acceptance of new foreign labourers except for domestic maids and shop helpers.

It has also limited the number of entry points for foreign workers to curb smuggling of illegal workers, and specified entry points for Indonesian and Bangladeshi workers.

Malaysia has also been trying to dampen demand for foreign workers by encouraging more women to join the work force. Now and then the government conducts raids on illegal workers, the latest one of which netted nearly 300 illegals, to drive home its point.

But migration is far from just a matter for the police or of closing borders. “We have look into several measures to overcome the shortage of manpower without depending on foreign labour,” said deputy human resources minister Datuk Abdul Kahir.

Singapore, a city-state of 2.8 million people with some 300,000 foreign workers, recently warned of the economic and social risks of relying too much on foreign workers after a row with the Philippines over its March execution of a Filipino maid.

Lee Boon Yang, Singapore’s labour minister, said Manila’s ban on new deployment of maids would not hurt. “But you can easily imagine the consequences if we continue to become more dependent on foreign workers in the economic sectors and one day, for whatever reason, the supply of such workers is interrupted.”

These trends come at a time when East Asia’s fast-growing economies are reaching full employment and undergoing a sometimes painful transition from a manufacturing to a service economy.

Near-full employment, as in Malaysia, means opportunities for migrant workers who take up jobs ranging from professionals to gas station attendants, housemaids, and caddies at golf resorts. But while bosses welcome more and cheaper labour, local workers may not be too happy when the economic tide changes.

Analysts say it is the semi-skilled or unskilled labourers that are hit hardest by the unemployment wave as Hong Kong, much like other tiger economies, proceeds along the structural shift from a manufacturing to a service economy.

It is these labourers who are upset about unemployment and are chafing against foreign workers — not against the expatriates working in finance or business in Hong Kong that residents know power the entrepot economy, but the blue-collar and domestic workers in the British colony.

As labour-intensive industries like garment making relocate from Hong Kong to China in search of cheaper business and wage costs, many low-skilled workers are left jobless. The Hong Kong Trade Development Council says over 80 percent of local manufacturers have based production sites in southern China.

Figures tell much of the story. The manufacturing sector made up only 11 percent of Hong Kong’s Gross Domestic Product in 1993, down from 30 percent in 1970. But the service sector’s contribution to GDP has risen from 60 percent in 1970 to 77 percent in 1993.

Still, Hong Kong’s unions are unimpressed by talk of the costs of long-term transformation, insisting the government failed to protect locals by letting foreigners in. Officials say labour importation will continue, but will be reviewed this month.

Hong Kong also faces with the problem of illegal migrants and has arrested 2,000 in recent months. Trade unions have singled out Filipinos who make up the bulk of foreign workers there.

And apart from domestic workers, Hong Kong allows up to 25,000 foreigners to come in and work. At least another 17,000 were brought in to work on the new airport project at Chek Lap Kok.

The Filipinos’ penchant for doing work wherever it can be found is also a prickly point. They enter as domestics, but soon moonlight as workers in restaurants, offices and shops.

Philippine President Fidel Ramos says host countries have a stake in protecting foreign workers, not the least since many of them “will be short-handed if our Filipinos do not help them”.

“Without question, migrant workers have contributed and are contributing greatly to making Asia the fastest-growing region in the world,” he told a human rights meeting earlier this year. “Yet recognition of their rights and promotion of their welfare have been slow in coming.”

Despite efforts around the world to impose quotas on foreign workers, hiking penalties and limiting entry, stemming the flow of human migration for work is far from easy.

Peter Schatzer, director for external relations at the International Organisation for Migration, urges labour-receiving nations to take a hard look at their need for foreign workers and then adopt a comprehensive policy on migration. But he concedes: “It’s very hard to talk of migration dispassionately.”

In an admission of its need, Malaysia last week reversed a decision to bar Filipino maids below 35 years old from working there. Analysts say a key reason behind the decision, timed with Ramos’ visit to Kuala Lumpur, was pressure from Malaysians who did not like the idea of losing househelp.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags