Asia-Pacific, Economy & Trade, Headlines, Labour

LABOUR-PHILIPPINES: Protests over Maid’s Death Sentence Intensify

Johanna Son

MANILA, Oct 3 1995 (IPS) - Just seven months after a Filipino maid was hanged in Singapore, the case of another woman on death row overseas has emerged to spotlight the steep price the Philippines is paying as the world’s largest exporter of human labour.

The March execution of Flor Contemplacion for double murder made headlines, and triggered a national wave of protests and a diplomatic row between the Philippines and Singapore.

In the case of 16-year-old Sarah Balabagan, a Muslim Filipino sentenced to death for killing the 85-year-old United Arab Emirates (UAE) boss whom she says raped her, Filipinos’ anger is no longer new.

But the outrage is not any less, aired by human rights groups here and Muslim groups, some in black veils, that marched through Philippine streets to protest what they said was the UAE’s flouting of Islamic law that allows women to defend their honour.

Balabagan had invoked self-defence in stabbing her employer, Mohammad Abdallah al-Balouchi, 34 times with a knife he had used to threaten her during the rape.

The outcry over her sentence is shared by a growing list of international groups and governments as the Oct. 9 date of the appeal of the verdict nears. Death sentences need to be confirmed by the UAE president before they are carried out by firing squad.

Japanese groups advocating foreigners’ rights last month sought amnesty for Balabagan in a letter to the UAE ambassador to Japan. Last week, women deputies in the German parliament urged their government to intervene, and European women’s and human rights groups joined the clamour to save Balabagan.

At home, activists are organising protest actions to culminate on Oct. 9 as the government of President Fidel Ramos scrambles to send extra legal help to the UAE to avoid national anger on the scale of the Contemplacion case.

“Sarah was not the first Filipina to be raped and beaten in the UAE. But she was one of the few who were brave enough to defend themselves and their dignity,” said a unity statement issued by the Moro-Christian Solidarity For Sarah Balabagan.

“For a woman, and a Filipino, which are both highly discriminated in the UAE, it was not expected that she could show such defiance. She was being punished for asserting her rights,” it added.

Balabagan is only one of more than four million Filipino overseas workers, over half of whom are women. Some 80,000 Filipinos work in the UAE, many of them domestic helpers toiling in private homes in an alien culture that often puts them at risk for physical and sexual abuse.

For years, there have been documented cases of maids from Asian nations like the Philippines and Sri Lanka who are commonly mistreated or raped in the Gulf states. But these maids are drawn by the prospect of earning much more than they would at home.

Balabagan’s fate illustrates what is a common story for Filipinos lured to overseas work. Balabagan, who hails from a poor family in southern Philippines, signed up with an illegal job recruiter who got her a passport listing her age as 27.

That forgery is now a weapon that the UAE court is using in Balabagan’s prosecution, though human rights groups argue that a minor should not be meted out capital punishment. Balabagan’s mother, Bai, recently left the Philippines with documents showing her daughter’s real birthdate as Mar. 3, 1979.

In July 1994 an Islamic court sentenced Balabagan to seven years in prison for the manslaughter of her employer and ruled that she indemnify his family, but also found she had been raped.

Both the dead man’s family and the Philippine government appealed the verdict. On Sep. 16, Filipinos were stunned by news that a second court reversed its findings of Balabagan’s rape and sentenced her to death.

The first appeal hearing for the death sentence was set for Oct. 30, but was moved up to Oct. 9. Since the verdict was handed down, protests in front of the UAE embassy in Manila as well as a flag-burning incident have taken place, angering Dubai officials.

The case has stirred Filipino Muslims, usually a less than vocal group, into action ranging from street rallies to prayers for absolution in local mosques.

Abenasal Romboa of the Moro Women’s Federation argued that the Quran “imposes punishment on criminals and the wicked” and not on people like Balabagan who is a “victim”. Killing out of self- defence is morally correct, she added.

Ironically, Balabagan’s case emerged at about the time the government held an employment summit as part of efforts to create more jobs at home. Ramos has time and again said the government intends to curb migration by young Filipino women, especially those eyeing domestic work in high-risk areas such as the Gulf.

But critics say migration for work cannot be curbed by government order. “If we are able to generate jobs here that provide adequate income to our workers, the attraction of overseas employment will substantially diminish,” said Prof Fermin Adriano of the University of the Philippines in Los Banos.

That is the long-term strategy. But for now, it is the young Balabagan’s fate that worries her countrymen, who find themselves increasingly wondering if the cost of overseas work has not reached its unpalatable height.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags